they are all immature in this story, i lost hope for Jill and Bella too
It's more likely you will find people willing to put up with cheating or even enter a polyamorous/free love relationship than the daughter of a multi-millionaire, like Jill and Sage are implied to be, dating outside their circle.
I didn't mean the apology in the bathroom, there was no apology there she was only thinking of herself. I meant the text 'apology', which was still pretty bad, and cowardly to boot.
The problem is that Josy spends the first 3 episodes far away and what moments you do get with her have her 'boyfriend' hanging over it. Then when she finally arrives at the college its straight into the Josy/Maya threesome (which while I like both isn't really working for me) and now she feels more like Maya's shadow. It also doesn't help Josy that, in the last episode, Maya feels more like pre episode 4 Maya when she isn't around. Don't really want drama with her, just some time for her to shine.
i don't wanna go into blame game but this threesome or lesbian stuff ruined her story , the very first girl we met in game .
And what's interesting about Bella beyond her looks and the locked door? What's interesting about Sage beyond her looks and being quite an easy lay for the MC? What we do we really know about them, or Jill, or even Maya? We know probably about as much about each of their personal lives as we do Josy's and we still know virtually nothing about Bella's, so what makes Josy so different?
And really, what about the other LIs makes them so different from Josy? We know a little bit about each of them and what's going on with them, but we still don't really know them, do we?
Again, this point about being "interesting" is odd to me because it's almost like people want Josy to be as drama-laden as all the other LIs, as though because she seems to have a fairly uncomplicated home life and history that this doesn't make her appealing. In my opinion, she doesn't have to be dealing with some serious past or present trauma to make her "interesting" She's a sexy girl with a fun, bubbly, and quite liberal attitude and that, for me, is all that's needed to make her "interesting" because over time you'll find out more about her and if there's not much else there, then so be it, but for now she's still an enigma and that's what makes a relationship so exciting; peeling back the layers of a person one by one to reach the centre and to understand all there is to know about them.
Bella for me in fact has many problems like Josy in her storyline ... but at least she has it, however stupid and superficial
Josy is both cute and sexy which is a deadly combination.This was a response to to a comment, I don't know where disappeared
Josy, without doubt. She is damn near perfect in every way, Her body is in perfect balance
View attachment 960648 View attachment 960650 View attachment 960651
But isn't it better to not have anxieties about a LI? If the only anxiety about Josy is that something would happen with her relationship with Maya because of Maya's Dad, then that's far preferable to some of the more extreme anxieties associated with other LIs.
tbh I dont want her to be overly complicated and drama-laden as you put it, I love Josie's girl next door feel that's what attracted me as a player/reader to her person, I just want there to be a bit more of a nugget of character because we haven't spent much time with her outside being the 3rd wheel to the Maya/Josy relationship and I just want a bit more, not asking for much and hopefully episode 7 we get it.
I dont agree with you there. I dont think anyone said that Josy wasnt interesting, we are saying that she is indeed interesting but the way that DPC chose to portray her made her bland and co-dependent on Maya, making it seem like Josy is just in the game to be Mayas LI, like DavDR said before.
. Im just waiting for their eventual break up (at least on the other paths) to see what people REALLY think about Josy.
how do you "know" him? Please, indulge us. P L E A S E. All you did was, just like almost everyone here, play Acting Lessons. Do you live in the same house with him? Are you his friend? Do you even know his name and age? Did you have a discussion with him about his vision in writing?
but I talked about anxiety in general, in fact after I specified anxiety / expectations
100% agree
agreementate my frenI dont agree with you there. I dont think anyone said that Josy wasnt interesting, we are saying that she is indeed interesting but the way that DPC chose to portray her made her bland and co-dependent on Maya, making it seem like Josy is just in the game to be Mayas LI, like DavDR said before.
Thats just one (of many) evidences to show that DPC seems to have a preference to Maya... But I dont want to discuss this on this post because I want to at least give Josy something that she doesnt have to share with Maya
And, to be truly honest, I think peoples opinion on Josy is being dragged down by peoples opinions on Maya and on the M&J path
think that I like that scene instead, I like the whole epilogue of the third episode / beginning of the fourth. I think it works
is that portrait in the top picture supposed to be Jill's sis? if so I still am amazed at how much I miss in this game every time I play it.
Well, we can say this as an undeveloped storytelling. This scenario truly only works if MC is indeed involved with Josy and Maya the way it meant to be. In that Case he is also responsible for his own action, like it or not.
.
