Holy Bacchus
Conversation Conqueror
- Dec 13, 2018
- 7,748
- 19,558
- 789
If by "Why would Jill allow Bella to do that?" you're referring to Bella calling the MC, well obviously she wouldn't know that's who she's calling. We also know that Jill is a people pleaser and doesn't enjoy confrontation, so if Bella wants the MC to be there then she's not going argue against it because it's Bella's choice. Also, she didn't exactly have a problem hanging out with him in the library and Tybalt even saw them together, so why would she have a problem here? Perhaps she thinks that the conditions only apply to seeing him alone and not in social interactions where there are other people around, in which case a doubles tennis match qualifies. Also, she might see this as an opportunity to mend the rift between the MC and Tybalt and thus make Tybalt rescind his ultimatum/blackmail.Why would Jill allow Bella to do that? If she's worried about Tybalt's threat (which we know she is, thanks to her idiotic subplot in Episode 6), she should be worried about pissing Tybalt off. That's the fundamental problem with your scenario: Jill isn't stringing Tybalt along until she can outmaneuver him, she thinks she has to give up the MC for his own good. Bella would need to fool her too, and that's a lot harder.
But more importantly, what does your scenario achieve for the audience? If the point is to enjoy humiliating Tybalt again, then we're directly undercutting the whole point of letting Tybalt blackmail Jill in the first place. Tybalt has been a punching bag from day one. We already know the MC is better than him. We know that Jill knows the MC is better than him. We even know that Tybalt knows the MC is better than him (though he'll obviously try to deny it). Illustrating it yet again is a) dull and b) incompatible with Tybalt becoming a genuine obstacle to Jill's romance.
There are only two ways to make this work: either Jill decides the MC is right and she will resume her relationship with the MC (openly or in secret), if the match allows Tybalt to get the better of the MC (something along the lines of the scenario you laid you, but then Tybalt insists Jill leave for their date and she agrees without meeting the MC's eyes).
I don't consider the former tenable because we're back to having no brake on the Jill romance. If the two of them like each other, there's no reason not to get together; even if it's in secret at first, the mere passage of time will eventually render Tybalt's threat moot.
I do consider the latter option viable, but it sure as hell wouldn't be fun.
Yes, Tybalt has been the butt of many a joke, but that's the point. He is that archetypal upperclass twit who thinks he's better than the blue-collar protag, but the protag keeps getting one over on him in various comical and humiliating ways, and that's Tybalt's role here. He's not likely meant to be any sort of serious contender or antagonist, he's meant to be the joke and it can it happen as many times as it wants. In Wile E Coyote cartoons, you always know he's going to get humiliated at every turn, but it never stops being funny, and that's Tybalt.