I don't think the maths is quite right on that one.
One thing we know is that Lynette had just turned 18 when she met Neil. Now, she could have got pregnant and given birth when she was still 18, and presumably her friends Miranda and Viv are the same age as her or a bit older. By the time the MC was born, Jill would either be 2 years old or close to it. This would mean that Jill's sister would have to be at least 16 years older than her in order for her to be either of those friends mentioned by Lynette, and presuming that picture in Jill's room is of her and her sister (which is very likely), there doesn't appear to be an age gap that wide.
The person who keeps saying they're right and everybody else is wrong, and that people will owe them an apology when they believe they'll be proven so.
Not everybody, only a few people, who seem to believe they make up a majority of the people, quite egotistical if you ask me though. But I honestly don't expect reading comprehension from people who can't tell the difference between red and brown when there is an example of both on the same scene.
Says the person who believes themselves to be 100% empirically correct on everything and that people owe them an apology for casting serious doubt on their claims.
Says the person who believes themselves to be 100% empirically correct on everything and that people owe them an apology for casting serious doubt on their claims.
There's no explicit proof to the player... The dad was there, he would have seen her burial or cremation. He's not gonna forget or confuse something like that... But yes, we don't see that scene.
There's literally no evidence or even the slightest indication that the dad is a liar. He's a very genuine, good dad who raised his son to have good morals.
Is there a possibility that the dad is hiding the truth? Sure. Is there the possibility that the dad is actually an alien and has been grooming the mc to save the universe? Sure. Are any of these indicated so far in the game? Absolutely not.
So yes, any random theory that has no basis from within the game can be stated, but just because it can't be refuted with proof, doesn't make it a good theory...
So:
The dad lying about the MC's mom's death is not based on any evidence in the game whatsoever. It's not a good theory.
The dad being an alien and grooming the mc to save the universe is not based on any evidence in the game whatsoever. It's not a good theory.
The dad isn't an unreliable narrator. He's not even a narrator.
The mc's quote regarding the dad's (un)reliability is as follows:
"My mother died shortly after giving birth to me."
"It's a shame that I never got to meet her."
"I would have loved hearing stories from her past and truly getting to know her."
"Sure, my dad told me stories growing up...but his memory sucked."
"He would always forget the punchline. Not surprising, since he would talk so long before reaching the point where the punchline was supposed to be."
The only example we get of this is as follows:
Neil: "But your mom, stubborn as a mule, didn't give up that easily."
Neil: "It took her three days to run away from home and track me down."
Neil: "No...wait...five days?"
Neil: "Hm...maybe it was something along the lines of a week?"
mc: "Are you seriously asking me that?"
Neil: "No, well, it was something like that."
Neil: "Either way...where was I?"
Neil: "Oh yeah!"
Neil: "She didn't want her dad's life or his money..."
So he rambles a bit, loses the point a bit, and inconsequential details like how many weeks between him leaving and Lynette coming to find him are not crystal clear. In no way does that make the core of his stories unreliable, or does it set him up to be a liar. What, he just forgot that Lynette didn't die?
When the mc says the dad's memory sucked, he then followed it up with an example ("forget the punchline", "talk so long before reaching the point"). It doesn't give the impression his dad has Alzheimers...
Not everybody, only a few people, who seem to believe they make up a majority of the people, quite egotistical if you ask me though. But I honestly don't expect reading comprehension from people who can't tell the difference between red and brown when there is an example of both on the same scene.
Welp, you finally found something to truly shock me. That close up face...is what you see at the gateway of hell.
"I am become death, the destroyer of worlds."
Welp, you finally found something to truly shock me. That close up face...is what you see at the gateway of hell.
"I am become death, the destroyer of worlds."
Says the person who believes themselves to be 100% empirically correct on everything and that people owe them an apology for casting serious doubt on their claims.
Correct. As the resident Sage aficionado, I can say the early years hair color looks too Arieth (as do the Joker facial expressions). I generally like hair down, but Sage's ep. 1 hair looks stringy as fuck. Hair up is the best for now, but if DPC uses a different (updated) hair down asset, then I'm sure it would look great too.
She definitely matured in that short time. Not sure if the lipstick she used to wear adds to the younger look, but yeah, the mc may have missed her prime.
Current Sage with hair up is the best in my opinion.
But the last pic is breathtaking.
I'm wondering if in the endgame with Sage we will get a scene with her asking why Derek call MC Assman
but if Quinn and Mc got high on cocaine, it would be disgraceful from a moral point of view, but what change would it bring? practically none compared to the joint on the roof, we can't talk about addiction at the first round, but then for how poor MC is he can't even afford it, and maybe even Quinn can't afford to use it for recreational purposes....
The cocaine has something to do with Quinn personally, either because of her Father or because she had her own problems with the drug in the past. Look at the scene where she orders it from Buddy, he's shocked that she would even ask for it.
You're walking around saying bearded man is 100% without any doubt is Sage's father. I present other options, possibly Jill's or just anybody but Sage's father. And it's attacked. So of course I double down, how else can one carry on a theory discussion when other people attack and say one is wrong when it's all speculation. At this point I'm not right, and you aren't right, and neither of us will be right, for at least a couple more years.
Lynette is all in fun. I'm rewatching Chuck, seeing how he lost his dad before finding his mother makes me think how that can work in this story. It's a fun theory that hurts nobody.
I have no ego here, I'm here for fun discussion, but other people don't want that.
