You are 100% correct that they msg'd on socials and that she had a BF, but ... if you were back in town after lets call it half a year and you wanna meet up again with your bestie, would you shoot him a msg "Yo, I'm back,let's hang" ? I mean, I most certainly would. But what did she do ? Knowing MC is at college and not home, she went to his dad to get the lay of the land for the incoming, no bra-full frontal, no prisoners "Ima gonna get my man back, and that's the bottom line." attack. ( YES, she does sound like Steve Austin and you'll see Zoey 3.16 trending all over the inet post friday !

)
But all things considered, maybe your MC can sweet talk Maya, Josy and Zoey into a 4-way relationship, I mean whats one more ?