felicemastronzo
Message Maven
- May 17, 2020
- 12,219
- 23,209
- 978
being, those listed by you, 4 profoundly different scenarios how can they have exactly the same reaction? and having decided to choose the maximum reaction, that becomes "average" completely exaggerated, a WTF momentI still think it's OK for the mc to get worried when he finds out who Sage's parents are, for all potential paths leading to that point.
He did come on very strong with the "Fuck. Fuck. Fuck. Fuck." reaction at the end of ep 8, but as has been dissected many times now, that reaction has been reduced based on the path that lead the mc to that spot.
The different scenarios:
1) MC rejected Jade from the beginning:
You may believe this is a non issue scenario here. And yes, the mc hasn't done anything to be ashamed of.All he's done is reject an extremely forward Jade, who has literally sexually assaulted him twice (once in the cafeteria when she grabs his cock through his clothes, and the other with her foot at the back of the gender studies lecture hall).When he turned her down, she threatened him:Jade: "You should spend the time left in this class reading and be quiet..."Jade: "That way I might not fail you..."And that's what he did. The next time they even acknowledge each other is when he finished the class:Jade: "Fuckface. Pass. Next."All the other students she chats with them, even mulling over whether to fail Derek with the consequences of him repeating, but she can't get rid of the mc fast enough.Her actions have made their dynamic extremely awkward, I mean he could press charges for real if he wanted to, so him coming along with the girls to ask for monetary help for Maya, who knows how she would see that, or how he would think she would see that.2) MC is fucking Sage and Jade:
We all know why this is awkward, so it doesn't require further discussion.
3) MC dumped Jade in ep 8:
Jade was really pissed. This scenario requires no further discussion.
4) MC is still in a relationship with Jade:
The only other scenario is he's never been intimate with Sage, but he's been fucking Jade. Jade really likes the mc, so he's not gonna have any drama with her, but he's gonna be sitting there with her daughter and her husband with the knowledge that he's fucking with their family. I think it's reason to be very uncomfortable.
So really, given all those potential thoughts going through the mc's mind. I don't find it being far fetched at all that he panics when he finds out.
that was such an obvious exaggeration that DPC himself had to remedy it already in the interlude, where, finally MC reacts differently depending on his situation.
probably DPC wanted to press the pedal because it was the close of the season, but the result was quite alienating.
you didn't follow the reasoningOh man it's simple why some characters don't disclose everything about themselves. Because they don't want to.
- Maya had to trust the MC first, not only because she is introverted, but also because she has made the experience in her past that certain truths should remain hidden, because otherwise she harms herself with it.
- Sage wants to stand on her own feet, ergo it would be counterproductive for Sage if everyone knew that Sage is the adopted daughter of the Burkes. On the one hand she is a member of the Burke family, but on the other hand she is not 100% Burke because she was adopted. I even assume that Tybalt makes Sage feel this, because he is at least a 50% Burke, if he is the biological son of Jade.
- Jill is slandering her last name herself because she wants to meet normal people and not only snobs.
These are only 3 different reasons why the characters in the game don't want to reveal everything. To be honest, this is even realistic writing from DPC because he includes the characters' pschye.
whatever Sage's motives were for keeping her family hidden, they are motivations that by the time she asks Mc to accompany her simply no longer make sense.
and not telling her at that point is either very stupid, or very selfish. indeed the more she wanted to hide it from him before, the more she should reveal it to him at that moment
Sage is worried that the meeting might go badly, and involving MC in an argument with two college professors is a risk he must be aware of, it cannot be a surprise