Bendover885
Member
- Jan 29, 2020
- 433
- 846
I'm not fully convinced myself. The argument I was making is that is a reasonable conclusion that one could draw. For all we know, this is another detail that will never be fully resolved by DPC's "brilliant" story-crafting, or it's a red-herring. But the original question was if it was Josy's or Jill's dad; out of those choices, it clearly would be Jill's but without more info, we don't know.Man, Jill's parents are very conformist and strict people. How can that dude be her father? how can it be? Don't you see what happens when he leaves? the other guys say he's weird.
Once again: I think you guys should replay the whole story from scratch and pay a lot of attention.