She does seem to react favorably to enough of those choices you wonder why
Yea but you still gotta be at least "Neutral" to get on the Maya/Josy train.
Why is it that after that point she reacts well to the DIK choices? Simple. She's a "ride-or-die" kind of girl who's dtf all the time once she finds a guy she likes. That's a keeper.
Also, even though I like Sage the best I think it's just because Josy and the MC are probably the most compatible out of all the other main LIs.
Both are the same age, starting out at college, from the same area/hometown (kind of), both want to party and experience the greek system (if MC chooses mostly DIK choices). She's also just the most outgoing. So as long as MC's not a jackass and she likes him, she'd at least be receptive to a more "extroverted" or "active" MC. Don't know how else to put it lol.