- Aug 27, 2021
- 1,147
- 826
- Thread starter mirrorofpain1234
- Start date
- Jul 26, 2020
- 161
- 33
- Jun 4, 2020
- 51
- 21
Can u share a save file at the elsxa route?living with elsa
she not a whore !!
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
- Jul 21, 2017
- 124
- 100
- Oct 7, 2023
- 419
- 1,099
the description alone makes this sound grindy AF. the only thing worse than being an actual blacksmith is being a fake one, hammering my keyboard while it's hot, and my dick with the other hand. hard pass.
so i finished elsa's route and i cant seem to start charlotte's route in a new game. tried multiple times and the option to ignore her isnt there. any ideas?
yup, it's got better concept where there're two girls with nice stories but less activities. anyway, at least he did improve the timing. i couldn't get BS3 100% perfect critical click. second, BS3 girl is the worst design out of his game in my opinion.
Anyone knows how to use the ring? There was an event where I bought it for 100,000 gold but idk how to use it.
edit:
It triggered on the 25th. The blacksmith gave the ring during dinner, and the santa costume event also triggered during this day haha.
edit:
It triggered on the 25th. The blacksmith gave the ring during dinner, and the santa costume event also triggered during this day haha.
Last edited:
did anybody got a complete gallery for Elsa? the gameplay is kinda meh, the size is big enough to tempt me to delete, but I fall in love with Elsa design. complete with all her costume if possible.
- Aug 1, 2022
- 32
- 121
There are dangerous days in the game, but girls don't get pregnant if you cum inside on these days.
Why...
Why...
- May 25, 2020
- 1,561
- 2,718
After analyzing everything and crap
Truly our prostitute Charlotte (her stage name) is actually Elsa.
They have same breast size and everything.
Even the ending sex quote is the same.
Plus if you go to shop on same day after you pump multiple load to Elsa, (use the pill to get your dick strong) you can still see the semen inside Charlotte's womb and she even said you the first guest (still this brothel got hella no people or something.)
Plus her feeling carry on from Charlotte to Elsa
So Elsa = Charlotte theory is right.
So why Elsa ending and Charlotte ending?
My best guess is
Elsa is her real identity where she is innocent villager.
Charlotte is her work identity where she is sex worker.
Reputation-wise she want to keep things down and not wish harm Blacksmith as in medieval-time, whore is frowned upon.
But Blacksmith logic is he's a commoner, no one cares what he does, he can marry a whore if he wants. Therefore, he does. I think Elsa know that Blacksmith broke the promise to go to brothel as she is Charlotte so this sadden her much. It could be Elsa might be keep herself for Blacksmith when her feeling level is above 5 and see no one beside Blacksmith, so she happy if he came, and drop by 5 or 3 or 4 if he didn't came.
Truly our prostitute Charlotte (her stage name) is actually Elsa.
They have same breast size and everything.
Even the ending sex quote is the same.
Plus if you go to shop on same day after you pump multiple load to Elsa, (use the pill to get your dick strong) you can still see the semen inside Charlotte's womb and she even said you the first guest (still this brothel got hella no people or something.)
Plus her feeling carry on from Charlotte to Elsa
So Elsa = Charlotte theory is right.
So why Elsa ending and Charlotte ending?
My best guess is
Elsa is her real identity where she is innocent villager.
Charlotte is her work identity where she is sex worker.
Reputation-wise she want to keep things down and not wish harm Blacksmith as in medieval-time, whore is frowned upon.
But Blacksmith logic is he's a commoner, no one cares what he does, he can marry a whore if he wants. Therefore, he does. I think Elsa know that Blacksmith broke the promise to go to brothel as she is Charlotte so this sadden her much. It could be Elsa might be keep herself for Blacksmith when her feeling level is above 5 and see no one beside Blacksmith, so she happy if he came, and drop by 5 or 3 or 4 if he didn't came.
Last edited:
not really, in BlackSmith series, they only worked as host girls...so basically they can do many sexual thing but no intercourse. the shopkeeper also state that intercourse is illegal in their services. and some how MC is exceptional cause Charlotte allow him to process.
it also translate in real Japan. despite they have huge adultery, host girls were seperate from this industries. even if you only bribe them to have sex... they can still call police on you for sexual harassment.
cause, Charlotte ending is where you only treat her as friend with benefit while Elsa is the one you are to marry.
I should be in your AppData Local
C:\Users\XXXXXXXX\AppData\LocalLow\XXIV\BlackSmith4\NaninovelData\Saves
anyone have Charlotte save? i try many way but cant see any different, and still my game got the bug, some scene will mix together