- Thread starter Zemax
- Start date
- Sep 17, 2017
- 242
- 227
- Nov 2, 2017
- 1,540
- 1,715
TCW posted his roadmap and it seems that we first will get the Brandi Reed game. Oof.
I really don't like futa content and this game will have it as the main theme. Only after this there will be BT4 on the horizon. So maybe end of 2026......
Anyway I will look at the brandi reed game and the content he will dish out. I might sound like a broken record but the decision to animate every scene left me dissapointed on the content department. The simple fact that we have less content than his first game is just sad. No matter the quality of the animations.
Ever since the third game came out I have a feeling that we will never reach the peak again that was BreedTown 2. At least not when everything is animated again.
I love to be proven otherwise but only time will tell.
I really don't like futa content and this game will have it as the main theme. Only after this there will be BT4 on the horizon. So maybe end of 2026......
Anyway I will look at the brandi reed game and the content he will dish out. I might sound like a broken record but the decision to animate every scene left me dissapointed on the content department. The simple fact that we have less content than his first game is just sad. No matter the quality of the animations.
Ever since the third game came out I have a feeling that we will never reach the peak again that was BreedTown 2. At least not when everything is animated again.
I love to be proven otherwise but only time will tell.
Last edited:
I'm sorry to those who don't like futa but I for one am super-excited bout the Brandi Reed game, precisely because it'll be much more like Breedtown 1 and 2 (which were peak, I agree) than BT4 will be. The fact that all the girls in BT4 are previous characters returning puts a massive damper on my enthusiasm for it. If the girls already know about the breeding power thing, it takes all the fun out of it for me. I'll basically only be playing it to see Nero's fate, and even there, I feel it'll be less satisfying, for reasons I've already posted way too much about in this thread.TCW posted his roadmap and it seems that we first will get the Brandi Reed game. Oof.
I really don't like futa content and this game will have it as the main theme. Only after this there will be BT4 on the horizon. So maybe end of 2026......
Anyway I will look at the brandi reed game and the content he will dish out. I might sound like a broken record but the decision to animate every scene left me dissapointed on the content department. The simple fact that we have less content than his first game is just sad. No matter the quality of the animations.
Ever since the third game came out I have a feeling that we will never reach the peak again that was BreedTown 2. At least not when everything is animated again.
I love to be proven otherwise but only time will tell.
I 100% agree, however, that the shift to fully animated scenes is a mistake. I've played through the first two again and I enjoy them way more. BT3 only had a few scenes I liked (Alexandra, Mia, Caroline, Ellie, in descending order). And none of them were so good that I want to keep coming back to them... I've probably re-watched The Nerd and The Punk/Bimbo scenes from 1, and the Sauna Girl, Sweet Slut and Technician from 2, dozens of times each over the past couple of years...
- Nov 2, 2017
- 1,540
- 1,715
Wait what?.......is this a confirmed fact?
Maaannnn get out of here how lame is that?
I really like the models and focus of fetish TCW dished out but his decision making for his main games baffles me.
Wait what?.......is this a confirmed fact?
Maaannnn get out of here how lame is that?
I really like the models and focus of fetish TCW dished out but his decision making for his main games baffles me.
As someone who writes smut fic myself - I think one common mistake for writers and creatives doing porn stuff is overestimating the appeal of novelty.
Honestly, I think the desire among their fans for novelty is something writers/artists of every genre tend to think is greater than it really is, but that's especially true for porn, and double-plus-ultra especially true for niche fetish porn. Generally speaking, viewers/players/readers who like your stuff because you do a certain fetish want you to 'keep things interesting' and try something new a WHOLE LOT LESS than you, the creator, want to. Most of your audience wants the same thing that they fapped to last time, with minor variations.
As someone who posts way too much in these threads I think that the vast majority of players pretty much just wanted TCW to make Breedtown 2 again with a new cast of girls. And I do think the creator himself is somewhat aware of this, based on the retrospective he posted on patreon. It's a crying shame, because in terms of creativity and humor, Breedtown 3 is by far the "best" of the three games. It has snappy dialogue, strong characterization, hilarity, drama, and an engaging mystery-solving premise that isn't too difficult but also isn't so easy you feel condescended to. But it's the least popular of the three games despite being the "best", precisely because it was trying to not just be Breedtown 2 Part II.
I think that's where we're at. alot of people want more of the same, creator wants to do some more creative stuff and there's friction there
I will admit that I am weird, but it's really the stuff surrounding the sex scene that does it for me. I can dig a good sex scene but I can only stare at some thrusting bodies for so long before I just kinda get bored, I need something to distract my brain a little. so this plot focus is also for the best for me at least
also even if he transitions to just making more and more breedtown 2's. there's enough rough edges and fresh or fresh enough ideas for the next one to be great but if they kept going it's all going to fall apart. the games start to blend and it'll feel cold and mechanical in a way that's bad for both creator and consumer. there's also the point where the matter of scale kinda wears off. you can conceive over 100 children in a single night and that's kinda insane. if you keep doing that then it stops being special. continuing to ramp up the scale turns breedtown from a series about strange misadventures to redefining the term "baby factory" and not in a good way.
Like I get that even if you like a certain piece of hentai but you can just keep spanking it to the same thing every time even if you aren't tired of that fetish but if you keep chasing it you'll get burned out eventually in my experience
An aside I don't see what makes BT4 being all revisits such a turn off for people. it's not like it'll be the exact same scenes, and the year or two since we last met them may have lead to them changing quite a bit one way or the other...
I will admit that I am weird, but it's really the stuff surrounding the sex scene that does it for me. I can dig a good sex scene but I can only stare at some thrusting bodies for so long before I just kinda get bored, I need something to distract my brain a little. so this plot focus is also for the best for me at least
also even if he transitions to just making more and more breedtown 2's. there's enough rough edges and fresh or fresh enough ideas for the next one to be great but if they kept going it's all going to fall apart. the games start to blend and it'll feel cold and mechanical in a way that's bad for both creator and consumer. there's also the point where the matter of scale kinda wears off. you can conceive over 100 children in a single night and that's kinda insane. if you keep doing that then it stops being special. continuing to ramp up the scale turns breedtown from a series about strange misadventures to redefining the term "baby factory" and not in a good way.
Like I get that even if you like a certain piece of hentai but you can just keep spanking it to the same thing every time even if you aren't tired of that fetish but if you keep chasing it you'll get burned out eventually in my experience
An aside I don't see what makes BT4 being all revisits such a turn off for people. it's not like it'll be the exact same scenes, and the year or two since we last met them may have lead to them changing quite a bit one way or the other...
- Nov 2, 2017
- 1,540
- 1,715
The huge problem with BT3 was that TCW wanted to create a mystery novel first and a porn game second. At least it felt like that to me. I admit it was interesting and I adored the horror section but it most certainly was not a game you could fap to while playing. The sex scenes were too few and too far between.
As you said the problem are the revisits.
TCW said that he want BT4 to be his biggest game. His magnum opus but you can't achieve that with only old characters.
Half the fun in BT2 was running around the map finding new girls to impregnate. Maybe some hidden/optional ones. With returning characters you don't have that at all.
He also outright denies himself of some funny options. Like an opposing lawyer, 1 or 2 police woman, a prisoner down in the cells, the secretary from the outro of BT3 or heck a random cook from the cafeteria of the police station.
None of this is possible if were only returning characters.
Also from a player pov let's say if you run around the map and the only NPCs you see are the old characters and no one else? The rest are all men?
That does not work. I understand however that from a narrative stand point that some old characters need to return but not the whole cast for BT4. At least make it 50/50 of old and new characters.
For a magnum opus he needs to deliver new characters. It's not about having new sex scenes. The problem is that we know them already.
Last edited:
English was not my first language, but I would share my theory below:
All personal theory for 4
PC: Postive Confirmed in 4, which meaned would breedable in 4 had been confirmed.
PU: Postive Unconfirmed in 4, which meaned might breedable in 4.
N : Negative in 4, which meaned might not showed up or breedable in 4.
U : Unknown in 4, which meaned I was not sure showed up or breedable or not in 4.
1
PC: Olivia Bardische, Maid, Red Biker, Pink Biker, Vivian LaRoe, total 5 in 1；
PU: Clerk, Doctor, Ruffian, Hooker, total 4 in 1；
N : Punk, Beach Babe, Nerd, Queen Bee, total 4 in 1；
U : Bimbo, Tomboy(also in 2), Country Girl, Bartender, Yandere(also in 3), total 5 in 1；
2
PC: Natasha, Breedbot, Takano, total 3 in 2；
PU: Waitress, Floozy, Priestess, Gyaru Bimbo, Bougie, Casting Director, Pornstar, Rude Girl, total 8 in 2；
N : Gyaru Schoolgirl, Sweet Slut, Sauna Girl, Baker, total 4 in 2；
U : Idol, Party Girl, Drummer, Bassist, Cop, Nurse, Masseuse, Cafe Maid, Ebony, Courtesan, Technican, Bitch, Girl in Black, Cashier(Tomboy in 1), Courier, Hippie, Peppy Girl, Succubus, total 18 in 2；
3
PC: None so total 0；
PU: Caroline DuPont, Gyaru(Anna), total 2 in 3；
N : Shiori Yuland, Noe Dua, Mia Halabi, Rosine Chantagne(Nero), total 4 in 3；
U : Ellie Powell, Hellen Smith, Alegandra Varga, Yandere(first in 1), total 3 in 3；
total
PC: Olivia Bardische, Maid, Red Biker, Pink Biker, Vivian LaRoe, 5 from 1；Natasha, Breedbot, Takano, 3 from 2； 0 from 3； total 8；
PU: Clerk, Doctor, Ruffian, Hooker, 4 from 1；Waitress, Floozy, Priestess, Gyaru Bimbo, Bougie, Casting Director, Pornstar, Rude Girl, 8 from 2； Caroline DuPont, Gyaru(Anna), 2 from 3； total 14；
N : Punk, Beach Babe, Nerd, Queen Bee, 4 from 1；Gyaru Schoolgirl, Sweet Slut, Sauna Girl, Baker, 4 from 2； Shiori Yuland, Noe Dua, Mia Halabi, Rosine Chantagne(Nero), 4 from 3； total 12；
U : Bimbo, Tomboy(also in 2 as Cashier), Country Girl, Bartender, Yandere(also in 3), 5 from 1；Idol, Party Girl, Drummer, Bassist, Cop, Nurse, Masseuse, Cafe Maid, Ebony, Courtesan, Technican, Bitch, Girl in Black, Courier, Hippie, Peppy Girl, Succubus, 17 new in 2； Ellie Powell, Hellen Smith, Alegandra Varga, 2 new from 3； total 22；
All personal theory for 4
PC: Postive Confirmed in 4, which meaned would breedable in 4 had been confirmed.
PU: Postive Unconfirmed in 4, which meaned might breedable in 4.
N : Negative in 4, which meaned might not showed up or breedable in 4.
U : Unknown in 4, which meaned I was not sure showed up or breedable or not in 4.
1
PC: Olivia Bardische, Maid, Red Biker, Pink Biker, Vivian LaRoe, total 5 in 1；
PU: Clerk, Doctor, Ruffian, Hooker, total 4 in 1；
N : Punk, Beach Babe, Nerd, Queen Bee, total 4 in 1；
U : Bimbo, Tomboy(also in 2), Country Girl, Bartender, Yandere(also in 3), total 5 in 1；
2
PC: Natasha, Breedbot, Takano, total 3 in 2；
PU: Waitress, Floozy, Priestess, Gyaru Bimbo, Bougie, Casting Director, Pornstar, Rude Girl, total 8 in 2；
N : Gyaru Schoolgirl, Sweet Slut, Sauna Girl, Baker, total 4 in 2；
U : Idol, Party Girl, Drummer, Bassist, Cop, Nurse, Masseuse, Cafe Maid, Ebony, Courtesan, Technican, Bitch, Girl in Black, Cashier(Tomboy in 1), Courier, Hippie, Peppy Girl, Succubus, total 18 in 2；
3
PC: None so total 0；
PU: Caroline DuPont, Gyaru(Anna), total 2 in 3；
N : Shiori Yuland, Noe Dua, Mia Halabi, Rosine Chantagne(Nero), total 4 in 3；
U : Ellie Powell, Hellen Smith, Alegandra Varga, Yandere(first in 1), total 3 in 3；
total
PC: Olivia Bardische, Maid, Red Biker, Pink Biker, Vivian LaRoe, 5 from 1；Natasha, Breedbot, Takano, 3 from 2； 0 from 3； total 8；
PU: Clerk, Doctor, Ruffian, Hooker, 4 from 1；Waitress, Floozy, Priestess, Gyaru Bimbo, Bougie, Casting Director, Pornstar, Rude Girl, 8 from 2； Caroline DuPont, Gyaru(Anna), 2 from 3； total 14；
N : Punk, Beach Babe, Nerd, Queen Bee, 4 from 1；Gyaru Schoolgirl, Sweet Slut, Sauna Girl, Baker, 4 from 2； Shiori Yuland, Noe Dua, Mia Halabi, Rosine Chantagne(Nero), 4 from 3； total 12；
U : Bimbo, Tomboy(also in 2 as Cashier), Country Girl, Bartender, Yandere(also in 3), 5 from 1；Idol, Party Girl, Drummer, Bassist, Cop, Nurse, Masseuse, Cafe Maid, Ebony, Courtesan, Technican, Bitch, Girl in Black, Courier, Hippie, Peppy Girl, Succubus, 17 new in 2； Ellie Powell, Hellen Smith, Alegandra Varga, 2 new from 3； total 22；
Some example for 1, iirc, Hooker writed "vauld for one free breeding!" on the test, Clerk was bred again, Tomboy was bred again in 2(part of me do not wanted that again), and Yandere might escape from the asylum (or not).
Last edited:
For 2, iirc, whole band of Drummer and Bassist might all bred by Reed, Cop should not showed up on court (avoiding criminal investigation on Natasha), Technican might stand the side of Natasha, family company of Bougie co-operated with Fertech after the bred, and Idol might be called on court by Takano to stand the side of Reed (thought she might not strong enough to keep on the side of Reed).
Last edited: