Lostanddamned

Engaged Member
Mar 29, 2019
2,854
18,512

Hildegardt

Well-Known Member
Oct 18, 2017
1,115
2,288
I wonder what the preference ratio is in regards to Mallory/Jaye/Others? Based on the vocal minority that posts, it seems that Jaye is the most favored one but I dont trust it. The silent lurking majority are is always such a big unknown as well as all the people that doesnt read this forum.
Who am I to choose? They all love me, so what can I do?
 
  • Haha
Reactions: BigBlueDude

felicemastronzo

Devoted Member
May 17, 2020
11,749
22,669
I wonder what the preference ratio is in regards to Mallory/Jaye/Others? Based on the vocal minority that posts, it seems that Jaye is the most favored one but I dont trust it. The silent lurking majority are is always such a big unknown as well as all the people that doesnt read this forum.
Jaye is markedly the protagonist of the story, sometimes such an official investiture creates discomfort, but I don't think the phenomenon can put her supremacy in the balance.

Between her and Mallory there is just too much disparity.

If on the other hand we talk about who we would like with LI, but this is a purely theoretical exercise, there may be a more balanced race
 

Cabin Fever

Engaged Member
Nov 23, 2018
3,381
5,483
Jaye is markedly the protagonist of the story, sometimes such an official investiture creates discomfort, but I don't think the phenomenon can put her supremacy in the balance.

Between her and Mallory there is just too much disparity.

If on the other hand we talk about who we would like with LI, but this is a purely theoretical exercise, there may be a more balanced race
To be fair, it's Mallory's rotten luck to be up against not just Jaye but also Tara and Lisa. In a different universe she could be a hands down winner.
 

Lostanddamned

Engaged Member
Mar 29, 2019
2,854
18,512
If you guys had to rank a top 5 on this game, how would you rank it? Genuinely curious because most mentioned names are Jaye, Tara, Lisa and Mallory. And I haven't seen Linda, Erica or Fiona mentioned all that much, but that's understandable because they have less screen time compared to the others (but that shouldn't be an excuse, seeing as how Riona in BaDIK for example has less screen time than the main LI's but she's usually pretty high up people's list).

Anyway, here's my list:

1 - Jaye
2 - Lisa
3 - Tara
4 - Mallory
5 - Amanda
 
  • Like
Reactions: WICKEDp4th

WICKEDp4th

AAAAAAAAAAAAAAA!
Donor
Sep 6, 2017
3,527
5,982
If you guys had to rank a top 5 on this game, how would you rank it? Genuinely curious because most mentioned names are Jaye, Tara, Lisa and Mallory. And I haven't seen Linda, Erica or Fiona mentioned all that much, but that's understandable because they have less screen time compared to the others (but that shouldn't be an excuse, seeing as how Riona in BaDIK for example has less screen time than the main LI's but she's usually pretty high up people's list).

Anyway, here's my list:

1 - Jaye
2 - Lisa
3 - Tara
4 - Mallory
5 - Amanda
1. Jaye
2. Jaye
3. Jaye
4. Jaye
5. Lisa
 

Hollerboller

Newbie
Jun 16, 2022
33
63
If you guys had to rank a top 5 on this game, how would you rank it? Genuinely curious because most mentioned names are Jaye, Tara, Lisa and Mallory. And I haven't seen Linda, Erica or Fiona mentioned all that much, but that's understandable because they have less screen time compared to the others (but that shouldn't be an excuse, seeing as how Riona in BaDIK for example has less screen time than the main LI's but she's usually pretty high up people's list).

Anyway, here's my list:

1 - Jaye
2 - Lisa
3 - Tara
4 - Mallory
5 - Amanda
1 - Jaye
2 - Jaye
3 - Jaye
4 - Jaye
5 - Mallory
 

D3xzalias

Well-Known Member
Aug 1, 2018
1,065
4,658
If you guys had to rank a top 5 on this game, how would you rank it? Genuinely curious because most mentioned names are Jaye, Tara, Lisa and Mallory. And I haven't seen Linda, Erica or Fiona mentioned all that much, but that's understandable because they have less screen time compared to the others (but that shouldn't be an excuse, seeing as how Riona in BaDIK for example has less screen time than the main LI's but she's usually pretty high up people's list).

Anyway, here's my list:

1 - Jaye
2 - Lisa
3 - Tara
4 - Mallory
5 - Amanda
Like i said:
Jaye
Tara
Lisa
Mallory
Amanda
 
  • Heart
Reactions: LizaS

felicemastronzo

Devoted Member
May 17, 2020
11,749
22,669
If you guys had to rank a top 5 on this game, how would you rank it? Genuinely curious because most mentioned names are Jaye, Tara, Lisa and Mallory. And I haven't seen Linda, Erica or Fiona mentioned all that much, but that's understandable because they have less screen time compared to the others (but that shouldn't be an excuse, seeing as how Riona in BaDIK for example has less screen time than the main LI's but she's usually pretty high up people's list).

Anyway, here's my list:

1 - Jaye
2 - Lisa
3 - Tara
4 - Mallory
5 - Amanda
Already in general, even more so in a game with such an aesthetic level, the characterisation, the story aspect takes priority over the purely aesthetic one for me.

Mallory, as much as her introduction is quite forced and the many quirks that characterise her, is still more interesting than the secondary characters

Jaye
Mallory
Tara
Fiona
Lisa
 

Cabin Fever

Engaged Member
Nov 23, 2018
3,381
5,483
Why limit to just top 5?
  1. Jaye
  2. Lisa
  3. Bianca
  4. Mallory
  5. Tara
  6. Sophie
  7. Rinko
  8. Erin
  9. Amanda
  10. Fiona
  11. Sarah
  12. Kaili
  13. Serena
  14. Linda
  15. Erica
  16. Tara with side-shaved haircut. That style is an automatic disqualifier for me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Darksoul6565

Lostanddamned

Engaged Member
Mar 29, 2019
2,854
18,512
Why limit to just top 5?
  1. Jaye
  2. Lisa
  3. Bianca
  4. Mallory
  5. Tara
  6. Sophie
  7. Rinko
  8. Erin
  9. Amanda
  10. Fiona
  11. Sarah
  12. Kaili
  13. Serena
  14. Linda
  15. Erica
  16. Tara with side-shaved haircut. That style is an automatic disqualifier for me.
Because that's what top 5 is used for. To rank the best characters in the game. Just like in sports they do top 5 or top 10's. Like in more niche categories you might do top 15/top 20, but in the best overall category it's pointless because the gap between 1st and 15th or whatever is the last one on your list is so big, that it's questionable why they are in the same category. It's like that weird NBA Top 75 list that ESPN did recently and they had Michael Jordan and Anthony Davis on the same list, like the gap between those two is so huge that the difference in statistics alone would be enough for a hall of fame career if it was the stats of a player.
 
4.60 star(s) 364 Votes