ename144
Engaged Member
- Sep 20, 2018
 
- 3,733
 
- 15,499
 
- 681
 
Perhaps I'm misunderstanding, but it seems like you're on the same page with Jaye:I am not arguing that he wasn't doing it to save his life, but the alterations that were made to the scene completely altered the nature of the character.
In the original release, he's a rogue, not necessarily a "good" guy, but not a villain, either. Greedo looks like he wants to get the money and kill Han anyway, and would probably keep the money for himself. Han shoots him, proving to be smarter and faster to act.
After the edits, he's no longer a charming rogue who steps outside the law, he's a poor delivery boy who probably had no choice but to work for criminals, and he only fires in self-defense. Drastically different.
I don't doubt your book might say different, but that wasn't what happened in the OG movie and it doesn't count.
As such, Jaye is wrong. She witnessed a blasphemous copy of the scripture.
Almost as bad as replacing the officers' guns in ET with walkie-talkie radios.
Personally, I think it would have been more interesting to let Jaye buck the popular consensus and argue in favor of the Special Edition. If nothing else, it would make it less likely she'd be stuck waiting for the MC to take her virginity.
But I suspect the devs didn't want their heroine to alienate most of the audience right off the bat.