felicemastronzo
Message Maven
- May 17, 2020
- 12,222
- 23,213
- 978
despite the very harsh tone you use toward Jaye I quite agree with you.That's not true for Jaye. When she avoids her brother, it's out of spite. She's angry that he avoided her for two days and stays angry for years. Then she inexplicably plays dumb about it when trying to mend fences as adults, right before she steals his personal journals after promising to be better.
So, all in all, I'd say that I have the exact opposite problem that you do. My biggest issue with the game is that I don't understand how we are supposed to believe that the main characters actually love each other and haven't just been lusting after one another.
The game insists that the player character is madly in love with Jaye, but never explains why. Those days of having fun as children are long gone, and should be overshadowed by the years of anger and contempt that Jaye dished out.
The game would be much better if we were given more control over the main character. Let us tell Tara that we want to forget about Jaye instead of talking about her. Let us tell Jaye that we left because we were tired of the constant fighting. That would make much more sense than what we get now.
The two main paths in the game are not treated equally. It's very clear that the writers favour Jaye, and it hurts the game whenever they yank control of the player character away from the players who aren't interested in Jaye.
despite the fact that almost a whole chapter is devoted to their childhood, the episode that makes us understand why Jaye is immediately in love with MC is really missing (in the narrative she is the first one or feel something, MC reacts almost reflexively, thinking about her only after he finds out that she has fantasies about him, not the other way around)
we are not told of a key episode in which MC does or says anything to kidnap the heart of his sister (who is already extremely attached to him from the start)
with Mallory there is the ploy of the girl feeling "ugly" and undeserving of love, but with Jaye there is not.
Of course we may think that we simply were not told about it, but it remains a flaw in the narrative.