I don't like Mallory either. How can I trust someone who's come to the ski lodge wrapped in multiple layers of lies?I have a question. So, I'm currently going through Chapter 3... am I *supposed* to hate Mallory's fucking guts? Because I do. More precisely, I hate when she visits me in my room and I'm left with the option of either sleeping with her or being a complete dick that ruins her attempts at regaining her ability to be intimate with others. I'm okay with her as a friend and companion, but *not* as a fuck-buddy or GF. I already have someone in mind for that, and it IS NOT HER, but the writers keep trying to force her on me and guilt-trip me if I decline. That's some heavy-handed writing, IMO, and not cool.
Sorry. Just needed to vent. Please, carry on now.
How can you trust yourself, being a man whole and having sex without condoms?
The only way forward is virginity, the MC stays virgin, the girls stay virgin, this way we all can have fun together and don't need to have these arguments! NTR yes or no? Harem yes or no? Mallory yes or no? All solved forever! We need a virginity patch, now! Then it also does not matter, if they are brother or sister, blood related or whatever! Have your virgin harem, no one will complain!
Tuor_of_Gondolin
Newbie
- Nov 9, 2022
- 93
- 159
- 133
No. For me there's only 1 LI in this VN, and it's not Mallory, regardless of how hard the game devs push it.
Chuck_Bass
Member
- Nov 25, 2022
- 340
- 831
- 103
HornyyPussy
Board Buff
- Apr 26, 2020
- 18,919
- 44,846
- 998
Tuor_of_Gondolin
Newbie
- Nov 9, 2022
- 93
- 159
- 133
But that's very much how this game works. The very fact that there are only 2 real LIs available in the game (my own perceptions notwithstanding) makes that clear. The MC *can* be a player, but for the most part he seems to focus on one person. The others are distractions or just "for fun". The writer, for example, made it possible for you to advise one of your earlier partners to fix her marriage. You can shut out Fiona if you want (not sure if that will work in the long run, as she's definitely got stalker vibes going on). You probably won't be going back to Colorado to see Rikki again, even if you did bed her.
The game seems intent to have the MC focus on just two possibilities, but I haven't noticed much of a chance to combine them. Thus, you need to choose one of them to end up with. I chose which one I wanted right at the beginning and nothing has happened yet to make me want to change that choice, despite what I feel are some heavy-handed attempts by the writer to make the choice more drama-laden.
At any rate, we can all choose for ourselves how we want to play and what our choices mean to us. We're the ones that give those choices meaning, or no meaning. I *have* played Grandma's House, and with *that* MC, I was happy to have him bang everything he came across (which is *a lot*), but this one is different and my feelings and goals while playing it are different.
- Apr 25, 2022
- 2,691
- 9,438
- 637
A few things to say here.
First, There are two main LIs in this VN plus several side girls. That's been very clear since the beginning. Both will have multiple endings, and there will also be several endings with neither of them. So the game is not forcing you to focus on "just two possibilities".
Second, the Mallory scene in CH3 that you mentioned is, in fact, avoidable. You're not forced into it. That scene requires that you have 6 or more "Trust" points with Mallory. You got that scene because of the choices you made. Basically, if you treat her completely platonically up until that point, you will not get that night visit scene. So it is not a forced scene and it really shouldn't be hard to avoid if you really dislike or distrust Mallory that much. I think if you don't hug her in CH2 and don't raise Mallory's access level in CH3, then that's probably enough for her to reconsider making her move on MC that night in CH3.
Third, as you may have guessed, the "helping with intimacy issues" thing is more or less a pretext. There is truth to it, sure, because of her traumatic experiences in foster care, but I think it's more so that Mallory is already very attracted to the MC by Chapter 3. However if you still do get that scene and you choose to turn her down at that point, you don't have to feel like a dick for it. Mallory will be embarrassed/disappointed as she leaves, but that is a realistic reaction. She took a big chance, but Alex didn't feel the same. She gets over it and there are no hard feelings. Besides, that scene is probably the safest time to reject Mallory if you plan to remain friendly with her on a Jaye playthrough. There are far worse ways to reject and/or hurt her later on but only if you go full asshole.
Fourth, #MALLORYBESTGIRL
Tuor_of_Gondolin
Newbie
- Nov 9, 2022
- 93
- 159
- 133
Well, I did end up rejecting her. The writing while doing so *did* make me feel less like I just beat down a baby harp seal, and I appreciated that such an option existed. It was just... a pretty frustrating moment, which actually speaks well of the overall story that caused me to care enough to sweat the results of my choice here.
My goal with Mallory is to try to keep her friendship while not getting in the way of the MCs relationship with Jaye.
And, no, I'm not going to dignify your absurd provocation with a response! Hmph!
- Aug 30, 2017
- 1,652
- 4,660
- 445
Hey watch it now. Don't be hating on Grandma! She's my girl! sure all the other girls in that VN are hot, but Grandmas the closest to my age,
ename144
Engaged Member
- Sep 20, 2018
- 3,734
- 15,500
- 681
I don't see the problem here. The MC is given three options on how to handle Mallory's request:I have a question. So, I'm currently going through Chapter 3... am I *supposed* to hate Mallory's fucking guts? Because I do. More precisely, I hate when she visits me in my room and I'm left with the option of either sleeping with her or being a complete dick that ruins her attempts at regaining her ability to be intimate with others. I'm okay with her as a friend and companion, but *not* as a fuck-buddy or GF. I already have someone in mind for that, and it IS NOT HER, but the writers keep trying to force her on me and guilt-trip me if I decline. That's some heavy-handed writing, IMO, and not cool.
Sorry. Just needed to vent. Please, carry on now.
- Agree to teach her about intimacy. Simple enough.
- Drop the pretense and accept their feelings for each other. Obviously only of interest to people who fancy Mallory, but it's nice we can make that distinction.
- Turn her down as gently as possible
No, to me the problem with Mallory comes in Chapter 5 when she sneaks back into the MC's room to deal with Amanda. That's when the MC insists on either fucking her or mocking her as she leaves. There's no valid middle ground to ask WTF is going on, which means it's ultimately impossible to differentiate an MC focused on Jaye from an MC who likes Mallory but thinks she's moving to fast (thanks Amanda!
) from an MC who is legitimately angry that Mallory would violate his privacy like that yet again. It's particularly bad since the 'off-ramps' from Mallory's path are a lot less overt than the way we can slam a door in Jaye's face if we don't want to sleep with her. I'm not sure how the devs are going to dig their way out of this mess, but I'm not feeling especially optimistic.
- Apr 25, 2022
- 2,691
- 9,438
- 637
I consider this proof that the Mallory path is the one true path.
- Oct 24, 2018
- 4,666
- 31,848
- 647
I love the lack of self awareness in complain about Mallory being pushed, but being perfectly ok with Jaye's writing.
RNasc4444
Well-Known Member
- Aug 16, 2022
- 1,848
- 7,548
- 637
Depends on the perspective. While I totally get what you mean, to me, the way the story is written makes it so that Jaye's romance path makes perfect sense but I can't look at Mallory in any other way than the quirky friend I'd pity bang but never in a million years even consider dating. Also I don't get the feeling either of them is being "pushed" on the players. They are the main love interests and they share an even amount of screentime.I love the lack of self awareness in complain about Mallory being pushed, but being perfectly ok with Jaye's writing.
Actually this is one of the rare cases where Patreon rules ended up enhancing the product for me. As someone who doesn't particularly love incest I'm glad there is literally no blood relation between MC and Jaye.
felicemastronzo
Message Maven
- May 17, 2020
- 12,209
- 23,196
- 978
the reason is that it cannot be denied that Jaye is the absolute protagonist of the story, so that the story pushes towards her is almost 'acceptable', after all, the driving force of the story is precisely this forbidden attraction between the 2.I love the lack of self awareness in complain about Mallory being pushed, but being perfectly ok with Jaye's writing.
Mallory is a new acquaintance, who even leaving aside the fact that she appears at the least opportune moment to make friends with a journalist, has this strange habit of entering the MC's room half-naked, regardless of our choices. she jumps out more.
needless to say who would have been the perfect second or third LI
Lostanddamned
Engaged Member
- Mar 29, 2019
- 2,866
- 18,965
- 701
I've always said it that Tara would have been a better option to be the second LI. She knows both Jaye and MC since forever and her story is intertwined with theirs.
Tara would have been the perfect ice to Jaye's fire.
RNasc4444
Well-Known Member
- Aug 16, 2022
- 1,848
- 7,548
- 637
I don't get this "forbidden attraction" thing. Pardon my ignorance but the only reason incest is forbidden/taboo, as far as I know, is the consequences to offspring of two individuals with identical genetical material. So I cannot, by the life of me, understand how a relationship between two completely unrelated people (in any way that matters) is unhealthy or wrong or "forbidden". If anything, compared to Mallory who is a genetic clone of MC's mother, him banging Jaye is the most fucking natural thing in the world.
Agreed on the Tara thing though. Tara is #1. No question about it. More Tara more better. Always.
felicemastronzo
Message Maven
- May 17, 2020
- 12,209
- 23,196
- 978
if you've practically lived with someone for a long time and considered her as your sister, going on to consider her as just a girl is not immediate, at least not for everyone. and evidently for them it was a problem, an attraction to be repressed, on Jaye's part, and to be denied by MC
In my opinion it is much more inexplicable that the two teenagers consider the whole thing resolved by the death of their parents.
- Aug 4, 2020
- 1,659
- 9,111
- 698
Lost Lost Lost you're forgetting this game is called "Chasing Sunsets" not "Intertwined"... Your theory would work for Nyx's game but not here
- Apr 25, 2022
- 2,691
- 9,438
- 637
Technically, neither Jaye nor Mallory is really "incest" though both situations dance with it. Both relationships make the reader consider, hypothetically, what they would be comfortable with. Could you be intimate with someone you grew up with as siblings, or could you be intimate with someone who is a genetic clone of your mother BUT she is her own woman, she's your age, and has a completely different unique personality and appearance?
It's "No blood relation but she's family" vs "Synthetic Blood Relation and she's not Family"
For me, I'm personally more comfortable with the Mallory situation. I still see Jaye as a sibling character, but Mallory as a more traditional love interest. Mallory and Alex have great chemistry with each other and are falling in love by the time the "clone" revelation came about.
I remember reading a story several years ago in the U.K. about a couple who were married several years and then later found out that they were actually blood siblings. When they found out, they said "fuck it" and didn't let that get in the way of their relationship. On paper, they are incestuous, but they never had a sibling relationship and the love came before the revelation.
If I were in the same situation, I'd say "fuck it" too. If I were to put myself in Alex's shoes, the clone thing would change literally nothing for me.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
ename144
Engaged Member
- Sep 20, 2018
- 3,734
- 15,500
- 681
I, unsurprisingly, disagree. The MC's love for Jaye is at the heart of the story, but it's been 5 years since he ran away to put some distance between them and work out what he really wants. There's no need insist his answer has to be romantic love. The game would have worked far better if we could choose between romantic love, platonic love, and practiced disinterest (maybe with bitter resentment as an optional extra). The fact the game insists the MC go on a romantic date with Jaye even after everyone involved knows there's no romance here speaks volumes.
That's not to say Mallory's path is going swimmingly, of course; I think we all know my opinion about her second foray into the MC's bedroom. But the game at least comprehends the idea that the MC doesn't love Mallory. It can't seem to grasp the idea he doesn't love Jaye even when he forces his way off her path. The closest it comes is the non-standard game over if you try to let her drown and even there it seems like more of a twisted "love gone wrong kind" of thing that destroys the MC as much as Jaye.
As for your girl Tara, logically she should have a larger presence in the game (either as a LI or as a prominent side character); maybe that will still happen when we get back to Boston. But given how much the game is struggling with Jaye and Mallory's paths, I think it's for the better if they leave Tara in the background.