You referenced Detective Comics 23.2 with the gameboys, which was published in 2012-2013 I think? Somewhere around there. Rebirth, launched in 2016, introduces a mainline Harley that leaves the Joker, and then Infinite Frontiers establishes her as a heroine. A relaunch and a few years apart, not "an issue or two later." I might be wrong, but I thought Rebirth rounded back to before Flashpoint, deleting what happened in New 52. Hard to keep track because DC is mismanaged as all hell.
I compared her to herself the very next issue, in that reference though, not to today. She was completely different the next issue, when a new author got ahold of her. This is what I'm talking about happens on a regular basis.
Or even batter, comparing Harley in her comic to Harley in Suicide Squad; same Harley, two books, both canon and happening almost concurrently, both wildly different personalities.
And no, Rebirth didn't do that. Its the same Harley; Rebirth Harley has even referenced New 52 events (like her Power Girl team up). What Rebirth did do...is complicated. Not even sure the actual authors quite agre on what happened.
Regardless, DC is a big company with many many more writers. Of course things will be forgotten or rewritten. CoC2 does not have nearly the years or writing staff to handwave these things as a change of writers or direction. A monolith making mistakes monoliths make is excusable, a small team should not be making the mistakes monoliths make because they don't have the same excuses. It's not as if Wsan left for the Mino to waste away and Tobs picked up where he left off, Tobs inserted himself into Wsan's character against Wsan's will. It leaves a bad taste in-game and in real life. Pain for both Mino and Wsan.
In comics you don't bemoan the 5402345th rewrite of Harley, because she's been rewritten 5402344 times already. In CoC2, you bemoan characters acting unlike themselves because they've only been written once.
As someone who frequents comics forums constantly - yeah, people do bemoan EVERY change in character, ad infinitum.
And I think you're mistaking the thrust of what I'm saying here - I'm not defending the inconsistency itself. Whether it should happen or not isn't the point.
I'm talking about my attitude towards the material, not the quality of it. Bad taste or not, its something that's easy for me to just...brush off, and merrily continue on my way in a game where it didn't happen.