After reading through almost every single line of text in the game and catching up on years of discussions not only here but also on the official forums I can safely say that this game is a mess.
1. The Player Character is their own person with wants, needs and opinions. They do not dump information on you (the player) and let you digest it, the protagonist does it for you and they mostly take it like a bitch. It is a big problem on content related to The Observer but it's an issue that can be seen on the content by other writers as well. To me, that is the biggest turn off a game such as this could have.
2. Lack of conciseness. MANY scenes in this game are massive multi-paged walls of text with very little player input. The way most writers approach this is also quite funny to me, "Don't like it? Skip it. Don't know what's going on? That's your problem."
3. Cait's religious cult. I absolutely despise the idea of a entire nation where children are indoctrinated into becoming whores. Some characters stray from that path like Calla but they are the minority. I am glad I had the option to shoot down the idea of building a temple to Mallach in the Frost Marches.
4. Not a power fantasy. They seem keen on avoiding making the game a power fantasy and yet the PC is, for the most part, a god of sex with an awesome fort that impregnates anything that moves BUT you could not even consider killing/corrupting a "god" or getting rid of the fox-succubi/band of mercenaries/corrupted centaurs/random orcs (that still roam the lands and stay in the Frost Hound even if you wipe them off the map) because...?
5. Kinu existing.
The only way I feel like I can enjoy this game "as it was intended" is by playing a human hermaphrodite charmer ministrel/courtesan with a 12-incher and C-cups (or above) and regarding them as their own character inside the game, not an extention of who I am.
In conclusion, if they wanted to make a mindless sexathon of impregnation with a fixed Player Character they should have. Riding on the nostalgia of the original game was a horrible move that bit them (and will continue to bite 'em!) in the ass, hard.
this seems more like a review but whatever
Devil's advocate:
1. is only a problem if you consider that the player character should be more an avatar for the player, instead of being a character akin to say Geralt from Witcher, or Shepard from Mass Effect. These games allow the player to influence an existing character.
Even if I'm playing the advocate here, I don't actually disagree, since in the past the games have more or less emphasized player choice. Plus as a "text game" it should be suited for it perfectly; hell why have they made such a massive scripting engine in the background? To account for the dozens and dozens of player body choices. One could argue that the body choices are player choices too, but it is quite literally shallow as it goes skin deep.
2. It is a text game. But I must say that the game could definitely use a full time editor that is not the writer. Supposedly Sav does something, and they probably read all the material, but once you have a reputation like Tobs of having good content (according to the community anyway, I think quite a few people here would disagree) I think the editing step is skipped because "They always make good content so just push everything in."
As to the second part, one could argue that it
is the player's fault for not reading. Another argument might be that reading paragraph upon paragraph of text can be a bit difficult when one's dick is going soft. Then again, the games are incredibly successful, so they are doing
something right.
3. I dislike Cait outright, no advocating towards one side or another because of my bias.
4. This is I think the most interesting. I believe that the crew does have to find that certain balance. Corruption, will, inevitably lead to more and more debauchery as per their definition (which I don't have, but it is is something about hedonism and ignoring everything that doesn't make YOU feel good). If that is definition, then the actually IRL illegal acts (anything to do with a minor, incest, etc.) would have to be added too, because, after all why would you care about an individuals psychological health when stretching their holes gives you pleasure?
So why bother at all with corruption? Future-proofing? Shafting your customers?