For me its 2 things really.I dont like how the devs dont understand what it truly is.What i mean is that this is a porn game with all the hardcore fetishes one can ask of BUT it thinks that we care about the story and the gameplay which no one cares.So they dedicate weeks upon weeks of updates on making minute changes on the gameplay/lore.Second thing is the fact that there is no soul in these characters.I dont care if the game is purely futadom but would it kill you to create a character with some personality,some hobbies,maybe some morals?Sex is good and all but make your characters feel more human and not just vessels to check the X fetish box.
From what little I've played, I see your point. Like CoC2, it's in this awkward middle ground where it's not sure what it wants to be, so it just throws everything and the kitchen sink at you, which just ends up making everything a homogeneous mush of not very memorable things. There's a lot of words, but most of them boil down to "X is really horny and DTF whenever" (replace "X" with "species," "planet," "character," etc.) There's RPG systems and combat, which are both complicated enough that you have to pay attention to them, but not engaging enough to really make them a draw. Last time I looked at the wiki, I counted around half a dozen futa species, not counting the individual characters from non-futa species just having a dick.
/rant incoming (that also kinda applies to CoC2)
I cannot tell you how many times I saw an attractive character, got excited, and then immediatly was dissapointed when it was
yet another futa. Don't get me wrong, if they want to make a text-based futa RPG thingy or whatever, be my guest; I think the game would be better for having a more coherent focus. But it's not, it promises a wide variety of kinks and then half the damn characters are some flavor of futa. And every tomboy is a goddamn futa, because of course you can't have a muscular or short haired or even a fucking confident person be just a woman. No, you have to slap balls on them because those are
masculine traits and wanting to fuck them is
gay. Or something.
I dunno, there's something fishy about the way the sexes are presented in these games that I can't quite put my finger on. I'm not trying to look at it from some
marxist feminist critique lense here, I'm looking to get my rocks off. But in games where there's every variety of futa, furry, and some stuff I don't even know what to label, why does every Dom want to mind break the protagonist? Why does every sub want to go full extreme, "I want to be fucked in public while everyone is watching"? These games feel... I dunno, gender/sex essentiallist? There's no "Dom who will make you beg, then give you cuddles after sex" kind of thing, like what real people do. Like they don't get that a fundamental part of both gender and sexuality is roleplay. We play a part, either because of societal pressure, or because it's a release. And when we aren't in a situation that we either need or want them, we put on a different role. But with characters in both these games, their sexuality
is their personality. There is no contrast between the person they are in public, the person they present themselves as, and the person they are in bed. The contrast between public and private personalities is a standard part of characterization, and (from my understanding) a big draw of things like BDSM and sub/dom stuff. As far as I'm aware, the "woman in a high stress position of power is a massive sub" is a bit of a cliche, and these hacks can't even do that. I know it's supposed to be some hyper sexualized society or something... but there's degrees of sexuality. Like the great Pratchett (GNU) once said: "erotic, not kinky. The difference between using a feather and using a whole chicken."
