Sacred_Lamb

Well-Known Member
Sep 15, 2024
1,220
2,851
341
The problem with evil in RPGs is that evil actions are, by definition, anti-social and tend to make things worse. And since RPGs are on a personal scale, it's hard to really create compelling content that one can call 'evil' without diving into real-world nastiness that a lot of people deal with. So "stab a guy because you can" or "be a random asshole" tends to be the norm, because those are power fantasies. Any other kind of evil would dive straight into edge lord territory, or just be unappealing. Nobody wants to roleplay an abusive parent or a serial kiddy diddler. Not that the CoC 2 devs are any good at writing even the basic kind of evil you commonly see, but this is one case where I don't blame them for not doing well.
IRL begs to differ, Epstein Island and other such things require social interaction and camaraderie. The Phantom Trope from the anime HxH do evil shit together but their also good friends that care about each other. People tend to forget that villains are also people because they're too fixated on their actions alone. Remember, Hitler loved dogs so much that he made an animal rights law, which is the modern animal rights law of today is based on, Saddam Hussein loved romance novels and books and wanted to direct some. Being evil doesn't stop you from being social or a person. If that were the case, a lot of serial killers who seduce chicks would never exist. Not to mention Bonnie and Clyde.
Most Devs just don't get it because a lot ppl are used to labeling monstrous actions as "other" or demonizing them. They forget that even the Devil has friends.
 

ChubbyFatBoy

Active Member
Aug 19, 2024
916
4,138
321
They lack an understanding of boundaries unless it's something that they don't like. Somebody pointed out that Sav will suck off Kas about how shes not a monster while she's literally keeping drugged up breeding slaves in her basement.
When there are no boundaries or distinction between good and evil, then everything is permitted and nothing is wrong.
But is that a lack of understanding? Or are they just doing it on purpose? I mean the game treats rape like a trip to Disneyland. It's more rude to not give someone the ol struggle snuggle. Like how many game over/loss scenes (not including the two classics) are actually bad bad? And I can only think of a handful of enemies we can outright kill. We mostly just beat everyone down until they ass up. Totally not wanting what comes next. I don't disagree with the end of what you said.

But I think folks viewing this from them unable to do it. Instead of them not wanting to do it. I know we can rag on the writing in general. But if they wanted to make it darker, they easily could have. We're just being given diet coke corruption.... purposefully.
 

ChubbyFatBoy

Active Member
Aug 19, 2024
916
4,138
321
I don't hate Cait.

View attachment 4826449

In fact, I like her a lot. As a friend with benefits, not as a lover. Which might explain why I, unlike a lot of people in here, don't lose my mind over her acting like a whore.
But there are plenty of characters who are whores in this game. Kas is one of the biggest whores around, yet plenty love her. I have gladly blown premium smoke up her ass. And despite her still messing around for story sake. I ain't loss sleep over it. I still maintain that all Savin had to do with Cait. Was to not force her popping up on people. Don't treat her like a secondary MC. And don't try to mix main waifu energy, with super slut. It's weird.
 

Cerneu

Member
Nov 9, 2017
443
864
247
I still maintain that all Savin had to do with Cait. Was to not force her popping up on people. Don't treat her like a secondary MC.
But she is literally the Deuteragonist. The story starts with her sister being kidnapped, and us helping Cait to find her.

So get used to seeing Cait, a lot.
 

MangaKing

Active Member
Oct 16, 2017
810
947
284
I don't hate Cait.

View attachment 4826449

In fact, I like her a lot. As a friend with benefits, not as a lover. Which might explain why I, unlike a lot of people in here, don't lose my mind over her acting like a whore.
I agree Cait is just a friend with benefits, I mean she tells you that she is going to sleep around before you first have sex with her, I haven't seen her as a romantic partner just a friend, I honestly don't care what she does, the butt virginity thing was weird though. The temple stuff is some wild stuff though like WTF were they smoking.
 

Jbuster

Active Member
Oct 25, 2019
808
3,699
380
IRL begs to differ, Epstein Island and other such things require social interaction and camaraderie. The Phantom Trope from the anime HxH do evil shit together but their also good friends that care about each other. People tend to forget that villains are also people because they're too fixated on their actions alone. Remember, Hitler loved dogs so much that he made an animal rights law, which is the modern animal rights law of today is based on, Saddam Hussein loved romance novels and books and wanted to direct some. Being evil doesn't stop you from being social or a person. If that were the case, a lot of serial killers who seduce chicks would never exist. Not to mention Bonnie and Clyde.
Most Devs just don't get it because a lot ppl are used to labeling monstrous actions as "other" or demonizing them. They forget that even the Devil has friends.
Now imagine Savin & co., take this advice to heart and decide to write their own version of, let's say, Ted Bundy so they make this character who's supposed to be all suave and charming but also, a massive creep and... Yeah I forgot they already did that
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Devs (unless they're in that niche market we won't talk about) struggle a lot with what makes a monster, that lack of empathy that differentiates normal people from those not so normal from which the wide range of anti-social behaviors emanates, dunno, maybe it's a recent issue because I remember even the cheapest soap opera from my country could produce gold given the chance, and create some memorable monsters

But is that a lack of understanding? Or are they just doing it on purpose? I mean the game treats rape like a trip to Disneyland. It's more rude to not give someone the ol struggle snuggle. Like how many game over/loss scenes (not including the two classics) are actually bad bad? And I can only think of a handful of enemies we can outright kill. We mostly just beat everyone down until they ass up. Totally not wanting what comes next. I don't disagree with the end of what you said.

But I think folks viewing this from them unable to do it. Instead of them not wanting to do it. I know we can rag on the writing in general. But if they wanted to make it darker, they easily could have. We're just being given diet coke corruption.... purposefully.
They could but there's the chance to cross into edgelord territory and I'm not sure anyone wants that

I don't hate Cait.

View attachment 4826449

In fact, I like her a lot. As a friend with benefits, not as a lover. Which might explain why I, unlike a lot of people in here, don't lose my mind over her acting like a whore.
She doesn't have enough FWB energy to reclaim that spot (unlike Anno from outer space sex adventures), having said that, I do like her and want her as a lover, but wish her whorish behavior would be more of an issue for the champion and have some tension here and there

I crave toxicity
 

ChubbyFatBoy

Active Member
Aug 19, 2024
916
4,138
321
But she is literally the Deuteragonist. The story starts with her sister being kidnapped, and us helping Cait to find her.

So get used to seeing Cait, a lot.
Cool. I've played the game. I know. Does not change what I said, about how to change the outlook on her. Or at least how I think it could've helped. She was written that way... she could've easily not been written that way. That's kinda the perk of it being a game. But hindsight is 20/20 I suppose.
 

Skandranon

Well-Known Member
Nov 28, 2016
1,548
3,694
455
but wish her whorish behavior would be more of an issue for the champion and have some tension here and there

I crave toxicity
Wouldn't work I think.

For all the discourse around Cait being a "whore"....she's barely any sluttier than anyone else. Less slutty than some others tbh.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JungleNuts

Tsubuhaza

Active Member
Sep 28, 2020
758
2,887
363
I don't hate Cait.

View attachment 4826449

In fact, I like her a lot. As a friend with benefits, not as a lover. Which might explain why I, unlike a lot of people in here, don't lose my mind over her acting like a whore.
Different folks, different strokes.

To me, Cait is overpushed even for a deuteragonist. I don't find her charismatic enough to be a close friend and she's rather lacking for a romantic interest.

She does start things but...
 

Jbuster

Active Member
Oct 25, 2019
808
3,699
380
Wouldn't work I think.

For all the discourse around Cait being a "whore"....she's barely any sluttier than anyone else. Less slutty than some others tbh.
It's less about her being a slut and more of caring about her sluttery for me, but yeah because almost everyone is the same it would't work that great :unsure:

Having said that, who outslutted her?, who's the Mr. Slave to her Paris Hilton?
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Yeppers34

Skandranon

Well-Known Member
Nov 28, 2016
1,548
3,694
455
It's less about her being a slut and more of caring about her sluttery for me, but yeah because almost everyone is the same it would't work that great :unsure:

Having said that, who outslutted her?, who's the Mr. Slave to her Paris Hilton?
Well, the PC for one. I would wager even an average PC outsluts her every day of the week. The centaurs prostitute, the femboy centaur who just bangs people all day for free, probably Kas...

She just doesn't do much really? She has sex with a few if your companions (common), she gets in some three Somes (allof which you're also in) and very occasionally she bangs someone you sic her on.

Idk, I just wouldn't hand her any slut of the year prizes.

Even her sex menu is mostly just...vanilla.

If it were up to me I would have had her whole sex menu have absolutely ridiculous names. Like " the Jassiran Jangler!", and the tool tips are all just ??? Until you actually do it. Then you find out it's just like, a blowjob from behind while she fondles your balls, while she indignantly insisted it's a time honored technique passed down through the ages.

Fun stuff.
 

YouShallNotLol

Engaged Member
May 6, 2022
3,325
9,474
628
Well, the PC for one. I would wager even an average PC outsluts her every day of the week. The centaurs prostitute, the femboy centaur who just bangs people all day for free, probably Kas...

She just doesn't do much really? She has sex with a few if your companions (common), she gets in some three Somes (allof which you're also in) and very occasionally she bangs someone you sic her on.

Idk, I just wouldn't hand her any slut of the year prizes.

Even her sex menu is mostly just...vanilla.

If it were up to me I would have had her whole sex menu have absolutely ridiculous names. Like " the Jassiran Jangler!", and the tool tips are all just ??? Until you actually do it. Then you find out it's just like, a blowjob from behind while she fondles your balls, while she indignantly insisted it's a time honored technique passed down through the ages.

Fun stuff.
For one, centaur prostitutes aren't being shoved down my (player's) throat at every opportunity throughout the entire main (and most side) plot of the game. Unlike the pink cat slut.
 
2.90 star(s) 133 Votes