danb35

Active Member
Jul 12, 2023
555
916
203
I feel insulting any of the primary four girls is just going to piss people off.
Of course it is, and I'm sure that's the point. I'll agree, though, that Lucy's face isn't the most attractive--but she's still my #1 LI (with Sarah nipping at her heels, though). One of the nice things about AVNs is that pretty much everybody's at least 8/10, so it doesn't mean a lot to me that, say Vicky's a 9.5 while Lucy's only an 8.

But to the question of "worst LI," and leaving the obvious answer of "Rachel" aside, I think I'd say the teacher. To me, she's just boring. Looks fine, though she's probably the least-attractive to me of the LIs. And I guess we're going for some kind of corruption story with her. Don't hate her like I do Rachel, but just don't care that much.

Rachel doesn't look bad at all, and with better hair (and a smile) could probably be very attractive. Her figure is closer to my preference than is, say Lucy's (I'm not particularly a fan of huge breasts, which is a point or two against many of the ladies). But I don't care what she looks like if she's such a bitch--and while there are signs she may be softening, she has a long way to go.
 

Karakes

Member
Jan 11, 2019
126
154
195
Of course it is, and I'm sure that's the point. I'll agree, though, that Lucy's face isn't the most attractive--but she's still my #1 LI (with Sarah nipping at her heels, though). One of the nice things about AVNs is that pretty much everybody's at least 8/10, so it doesn't mean a lot to me that, say Vicky's a 9.5 while Lucy's only an 8.

But to the question of "worst LI," and leaving the obvious answer of "Rachel" aside, I think I'd say the teacher. To me, she's just boring. Looks fine, though she's probably the least-attractive to me of the LIs. And I guess we're going for some kind of corruption story with her. Don't hate her like I do Rachel, but just don't care that much.

Rachel doesn't look bad at all, and with better hair (and a smile) could probably be very attractive. Her figure is closer to my preference than is, say Lucy's (I'm not particularly a fan of huge breasts, which is a point or two against many of the ladies). But I don't care what she looks like if she's such a bitch--and while there are signs she may be softening, she has a long way to go.
Alright Alright, I didn't consider Rachel a LI, because she hasn't been part of the shenanigans yet. Probably a bad call but it was 2am and I nothing good happens that late at night. I
 

XK271

Newbie
Jul 20, 2025
79
246
33
Bait aside, my least favorite (and this will get me a lot of hate) of the LIs is Sarah. Personality-wise, she's really cute even if I don't like tsundere archetypes, but physically, she's just far from my preference. I do like all the LIs in the game though, so it's just picking my least favorite of a good batch.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Beduin123

shitass1001

Well-Known Member
Jun 8, 2021
1,197
5,018
656
Bait aside, my least favorite (and this will get me a lot of hate) of the LIs is Sarah. Personality-wise, she's really cute even if I don't like tsundere archetypes, but physically, she's just far from my preference. I do like all the LIs in the game though, so it's just picking my least favorite of a good batch.
Sarah is my favourite, but I cant hate on someone for personal preferences... Even though some preferences are WRONG :devilish::devilish::devilish:

Cant pick a worst LI, they are all too good IMO. Maybe least favourite is Elizabeth, but thats mostly cause we dont know a thing about her yet
 

mordred93

Well-Known Member
Jul 21, 2017
1,852
2,908
476
Since all LI are meant to be LI, I cannot "hate" any. I used to tell my kids, that "hate" is something that you spend the rest of your life, and even give up your life, to eradicate from the earth. I personally think people use the word too freely, that it has is part of the reason people are so violently opposed to others. I don't know enough about them all, to really say which one I like the least. But of the ones that have been presented so far, Misaki is mine. My thing, is I like people who are confident and know what they want (which is why Alison is my favorite), and her being such a wet noodle, just does nothing for me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shy player

masterdc1976

Member
Feb 25, 2021
260
337
187
I must say Catherine is my favorite closely followed by Hanna sine they are both family duty oriented a daddy´s girls, Hanna somewhat rebellious but they both dont focus on love relationship specially Catherine ... "Make me!" she seems patriarchal and that is very refreshing. Slave / Owner but not like Victoria but the right way.
 

Parmenion1405

Member
Dec 27, 2017
231
216
265
Writing this while my wife is watching me type. LOL! Probably I’ll have to sleep on the couch tonight. Out of all the LIs, I like Sarah the most – a real submissive in bed, yet strong-willed and sometimes mischievous. Apart from the boob size (a little too much for me), she also matches most of the features I, personally, find attractive in a woman.

And if you’re reading this, it means I’ve survived so far – because my wife looks nothing like Sarah. She’s half Japanese, with hazel eyes and black hair… slightly different from Sarah.

Okay, I survived posting this. Wish you all a good day, and remember: be friendly even if your opinion is different. Some say you can’t argue about taste; others say it’s impossible not to. Whatever you think, be polite and respectful – you don’t need to share someone’s opinion to value their input.

Now I have to run – my wife just grabbed the broom. Don’t get me wrong, I’m not afraid of her… I’m afraid of the broom!

Just my two cents on a Sunday noon.
 

hameleona

Member
Oct 27, 2018
360
860
234
Honestly... I must unironically say Lucy is the worst LI, atm. I like her a lot, but I'm also frustrated by her a lot. Probably because while every other LI got some major character development, she has been stuck in her personality being "I love the MC" and "I'm a bit of a perv" and consistently sidelined and generally reduced to almost a background character. I expect this to change with time, as IIRC there is more planned for her, but from the "Active" LI's - yeah, Lucy. Misaki is a close second, mostly because of how she feels like that boring b-plot that never leads to anywhere. And again - that's for now, I expect her to get some more development.
From the planned LIs... Rachel, hands down. Like how things with her develop will be the biggest test Cosy has to pass as a writer for me. She is just so... dumb and incompetent...
 

JigglyPal

Newbie
Aug 12, 2022
43
93
141
I also think Lucy is the worst LI, but I also like Lucy quite a bit. She's the most boring of what I find to be an entirely enjoyable cast.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hameleona

Jimskeleton

Member
Nov 9, 2020
389
2,052
397
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.



Hey guys, it's dev log time again!

This one truly will be a tiny dev log, as there is literally nothing interesting to say! Not a bad thing, I suppose, as it means nothing's gone wrong: rendering is proceeding as planned, and that's all I've done in the last couple of weeks, though that doesn't make for interesting reading here.

To make up for that, I've included a custom render set that someone commissioned a while ago. It's a little old at this point, so the graphics are slightly dated compared to the newest stuff, but I think Akatsuki and Lucy look really cute in those aprons. I might have to find a way to fit them into the main game at some point. And just to be clear, the Catherine shot is a 0.13 preview, not a custom. She really is becoming one of my favourites recently!

So that's all there is to say this time. I wonder if this takes the record for my shortest dev log? There should probably be a couple more before the update release, so I'll speak to you again in a couple of weeks.

As always, thank you for your support - I really do appreciate it!

- Cosy Creator
 

nonanonanon

Newbie
Apr 23, 2022
17
90
89
You know what, sure, I'll throw my hat in the ring for "least" favorite LI so far. (I use "least" in quotation marks because, like everyone else, I do like all the girls.)

I think that my least favorite right now is Hannah, but that's almost certainly just due to her being pretty new to the group. She hasn't had enough of a chance to establish herself, so it feels a bit unfair to consider her to be at the bottom. Otherwise, I'd have to go with Misaki. To echo others' criticisms, she's felt like a B-plot to everything else; she hasn't had any involvement with either the café or Founding Families. And, to be honest, I kind of think she has the weakest chemistry with the MC (excluding Rachel, obviously). The whole start of the relationship being founded on lies/secrecy and dubcon just left a bad taste in my mouth, personally — especially considering how transparent he is with everyone else. Even though their relationship has easily advanced beyond that by now, it felt like a bad start that's hard for me to come back from.

Anyway, regarding Lucy: I understand that she comes across as "default" in a sense, but I think she's had considerable growth! She's steadily come into her own since the start of the game; MC's confidence has really rubbed off on her, and having that support has allowed her to discover and pursue other interests like her baking. She's still very subdued and introverted, so it's been more subtle than some of the other girls' development, but it's definitely noticeable!
 

MalLiz

Well-Known Member
Jan 26, 2024
1,166
2,348
340
I am honestly surprised no one else has mentioned Elizabeth as their least favourite LI... Because honestly, to me, she is absolutely the least interesting. And no, I do not mean my counterpart Liz! :ROFLMAO:

In all seriousness though, Elizabeth just seems... I don't know. "Token" I guess? Kind of like a "completely stereotypical bad girl" sort of character, which to me just screams "placeholder!" Maybe she will get more interesting by the time we hit version 0.20 or so, but for now she is just purely uninteresting to me.

Incidentally, Sarah and Rachel are my top two favourites (in that order) with Lucy being third. Yeah, I disliked Rachel at the start, but she is pretty cute, and I have a fairly huge soft spot for characters that first appear bad or such, but then redeem themselves in some manner. I often feel like they simply make for the most interesting ones.

And Sarah, that adorable little firecracker... Really, how can anyone ever not love her?! :D

-Mal
 
4.60 star(s) 270 Votes