2.00 star(s) 4 Votes

Centrophy

Active Member
Dec 2, 2017
865
1,011
Why don't porn writers ever innovate? It's always the same - feminization games always have a guy with a small cock and a hyper weakness to anal stimulation, NTR games always have a guy that wanted to save it for marriage or whatever and a third party immediately gets into the girl's pants. I swear I've read the synopsis for this game over and over again complete with the mage joining the party.
 

Bustapr

Member
May 22, 2017
256
506
This is one of those games not worth the 5 minutes it takes to complete. No gameplay or story. No one handed progression either ;) Just fail a minigame and girl gets fucked.
 

Meaning Less

Engaged Member
Sep 13, 2016
3,540
7,078
Why don't porn writers ever innovate? It's always the same - feminization games always have a guy with a small cock and a hyper weakness to anal stimulation, NTR games always have a guy that wanted to save it for marriage or whatever and a third party immediately gets into the girl's pants. I swear I've read the synopsis for this game over and over again complete with the mage joining the party.
Isn't this like saying, "why bestiality games always have to show sex with animals?"

It's literally the definition of the fetish, how would you lose your girl if not for a third party getting into her pants?
There are only so many scenarios you can write without completely changing genre...
 
Feb 10, 2019
63
143
Why don't porn writers ever innovate? It's always the same - feminization games always have a guy with a small cock and a hyper weakness to anal stimulation, NTR games always have a guy that wanted to save it for marriage or whatever and a third party immediately gets into the girl's pants. I swear I've read the synopsis for this game over and over again complete with the mage joining the party.
"What has been will be again, what has been done will be done again; there is nothing new under the sun." Ecclesiastes 1:9
 

Centrophy

Active Member
Dec 2, 2017
865
1,011
Isn't this like saying, "why bestiality games always have to show sex with animals?"

It's literally the definition of the fetish, how would you lose your girl if not for a third party getting into her pants?
There are only so many scenarios you can write without completely changing genre...
Nonsense. You can write something interesting without being cliche while still staying in the genre. Is every comic book hero the same? Is every romance, thriller, drama, mystery story the same? The problem is that all of these stories are made for a quick buck. There's no artistry to be found here. This tired story combined with the atrocious art, MTL, and RPGM engine make this one to be forgotten.
 

Meaning Less

Engaged Member
Sep 13, 2016
3,540
7,078
Nonsense. You can write something interesting without being cliche while still staying in the genre. Is every comic book hero the same? Is every romance, thriller, drama, mystery story the same? The problem is that all of these stories are made for a quick buck. There's no artistry to be found here. This tired story combined with the atrocious art, MTL, and RPGM engine make this one to be forgotten.
Everything is cliche, you probably just didn't notice it yet. Most stories are the same with slight variations from old or recycled ideas, so much so that they can be divided into specific genres like you mentioned.
Now when talking about fetishes this is narrowed even further to very specific niches, so it really becomes almost impossible to write anything never heard of.

But if I'm wrong I would love to hear your innovative sample or synopsys for any NTR situation that does not exist already...
 

Centrophy

Active Member
Dec 2, 2017
865
1,011
Everything is cliche, you probably just didn't notice it yet. Most stories are the same with slight variations from old or recycled ideas, so much so that they can be divided into specific genres like you mentioned.
Yes, everyone knows the quote. See post #29 of this thread. I mostly disagree with it though I do appreciate it. Just because something may share similarities doesn't mean they are the same. There are pale imitations and great works. This is the former.
But if I'm wrong I would love to hear your innovative sample or synopsys for any NTR situation that does not exist already...
Yeah, I'm not going to do that. I'm not about to waste my time writing something that will never be made. In any case, does a film critic need to have been a film maker to critique a film? Does a lover of wine need to have been a vintner to speak about the quality of it? No. No, they do not.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Leon1dass
Sep 29, 2019
111
232
Nonsense. You can write something interesting without being cliche while still staying in the genre. Is every comic book hero the same? Is every romance, thriller, drama, mystery story the same? The problem is that all of these stories are made for a quick buck. There's no artistry to be found here. This tired story combined with the atrocious art, MTL, and RPGM engine make this one to be forgotten.
Be the change you want to see in the world!
 

Meaning Less

Engaged Member
Sep 13, 2016
3,540
7,078
Yeah, I'm not going to do that. I'm not about to waste my time writing something that will never be made. In any case, does a film critic need to have been a film maker to critique a film? Does a lover of wine need to have been a vintner to speak about the quality of it? No. No, they do not.
Of course not, but the way you critiqued it as if it was something so simple I expected at least some other ideas to be in your mind already.
I fully agree that this game is bad (finished in 5 mins).
It was only your critique on the lack of variation on the genre itself that didn't make sense, it's a paradox because you can't innovate on the defining aspect of the genre, at best you will switch to another genre.
At the end of the day the only thing that really can change is the gameplay and art used around these scenarios, most eroge are silly cashgrabs anyway not sure what you expected.
 

Centrophy

Active Member
Dec 2, 2017
865
1,011
Of course not, but the way you critiqued it as if it was something so simple I expected at least some other ideas to be in your mind already.
I fully agree that this game is bad (finished in 5 mins).
It was only your critique on the lack of variation on the genre itself that didn't make sense, it's a paradox because you can't innovate on the defining aspect of the genre, at best you will switch to another genre.
At the end of the day the only thing that really can change is the gameplay and art used around these scenarios, most eroge are silly cashgrabs anyway not sure what you expected.
Oh, I have no problems with the introduction of a another guy, or the cheating, or whatever. It could be a different setting, it could give the player character a different attitude, it could make the "bull" a woman or an alien or something. I don't know. Something different and interesting. But this exact scenario has played out multiple times in multiple titles which was my problem with it and this didn't look like it did anything remotely innovative. He changed the art of the girl, that's it. I also agree, that most eroges are silly cash grabs. It may have not been the case in the past in the AIF community pre-Patreon but dlsite has existed for aeons and things have not gotten better. Either way I think I'm going to get off this today as I've been getting loads of errors and having to refresh a lot to even access the site. Cheers.
 
May 21, 2018
129
660
The fact that a game so small and pathetic that it can be viewed in its entirety in just the preview screenshots has sparked such an intense discussion is fascinating to me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: QuestionTime

QuestionTime

Active Member
Dec 6, 2019
512
859
MTL should be in the game title so I can avoid it when scrolling latest updates. Also every MTL should have a rating scale or something from "Perfectly understandable" down to "Not understandable."
 
Apr 21, 2020
178
174
we are discussing MTL now ?
i am used to read over 10.000 MTL novel chapter.

majority of people using broken sentence anyway and other people easily understood it because any misunderstanding usually scale up to a fight in real life.

cough in comrademao com
 
2.00 star(s) 4 Votes