So this overall was not great... the atmosphere was good, the story books were kinda neat, but getting lost every 2 minutes was not fun. Hiding passages in the background behind the trees, no indication of where to go, and a general lack of sex just makes this DLC not worth replaying.
We've already seen these characters naked (not that I'm complaining about seeing them naked again) but we could have had some sex scenes with them. I didn't really care about having sex with some ghosts. And they also even lacked some good scenes that could have used more nudity. Like when you rescue Asuka and her panties are missing, they should have definitely had a scene where she didn't notice yet and she bends over and you see everything, that would have been great. And to have Tess and Trev in a more suggestive pose being tied up close together. A nice view of Erika from behind on the table, so many wasted opportunities.
I understand he may want to save a lot for the main game when you first see these characters in action, but in that case he should have just not done this DLC and used the several months of working on this to finish the main game. Then he could have done this DLC afterwards with more sex scenes. I'd rather see that than alex masturbating with no naked girl on the screen.
Also I know the statement has always been "game first, porn second" but really, who the fuck cares about the gameplay? The platforming is awful here, even with a keyboard press I ended up falling off the window sill so many times. I was not confused by puzzles, but I was lost on where to go because its just random. Then when you find where to go, you have to search every room AGAIN to find the next place the ghost will be. It's not fun, it's a time waster to make this seem longer than the 20 minutes it would take to complete.
Not to mention to advertise this DLC he put up a picture of Melissa, who is not even in the DLC other than the card you get for her.
It's not particularly bad, but it's got way too much filler, bullshit mechanics, and was just generally not needed when the main game is not even close to being done yet. Just my 2 cents.