VN - Ren'Py - Completed - Dating My Daughter [Ch. 1-4 v1.01] [MrDots Games]

This review has some spoilers but i tried to avoid story specific things. I just finished playing this game for the first time all the way through from chapter one to chapter three's current version with Lains Mod. I can honestly say the entire story is felt like tease and a waste of time .

I appreciate all the options of avoiding NTR and sharing D with other men. Which i am sure was because of Lain's mod. I was disappointed there was no option of discussing pregnancy with D and skirting over the issue of her just taking the pill which is a turnoff for me because by the time i was able to cum inside her, i wanted to impregnate her, and wanted to discuss that kind of relationship with her to let her know what i wanted. It is my fault however of not reading the forum before downloading the game to find out the pregnancy tag was just for Olivia otherwise i wouldn't of downloaded. Another disappointment was most of the time anal fingering and anal penetration in general couldn't be avoided which i would of preferred except for one or two instances.

The story like other reviewers have said is really slow and unrealistic. Most of the story never directly leads to sex or enhances it to be more enjoyable at least for me but given how high a majority of people have rated this game i might be in the minority. Seems like most of the story is just filler to make the game longer.

The sex animations are good except way too fast in the movements given the size of the main character's penis and you are not looking at the Penetration. Penetration of a vagina is the worst i have seen in recent games. It just looks like noclip for the penis is enabled and not actually stretching the vaginal walls which is a turn off for me and takes me completely out of the immersion.

All in all i just can't recommend this game to ease sexual desires. Given mine revolves around impregnation and incest. This definitely falls flat in that regard. I might play it again if impregnation of D becomes possible in an update given how much time i spent on this game.

Void___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

For me the best incest novel ever made! I love the kind of game that has a slow build in character relationship. The closer you get to reality in the history of a game, the greater the pleasure. I hope game designers of this style will realize the power of this detail someday. Congratulations to the guys at Mr Dots games. You are undoubtedly the best reference today, in my opinion

I'm really disappointed with the game. D is really unrealistic. She has unrealistic body( tits of 40yo woman ) and unrealistic personality.
The story isn't that bad.

And if you don't like reading walkthroughs you can fuck this up. So if you want to play "correctly" read the walkthrough.

I always make 2 saves one is my current progress and another 1 day earlier. Turns out in day 10 I had to choose one option, I'd lose in day 12 if not. So I lost there and had to play from the start. No way! It's too boring.

This game is fantastic, the story is good, the romance elements are incredible, the girls are kinky. What's not to like? I especially like how it builds up the incest with corruption levels, unlike some other games of the genre the progression seems more realistic. Updates are at regular intervals and there is tons of content. I would definitely recommend this game!

This is my first review here, even if i've played a couple of games already (Mythic Manor, Waifu Academy, Dreams of Desire, Melody, Acting Lessons, Harem Hotel and a few more) so i'll try to make it as complete as possible.

Thinks that i liked:

- The story is somewhat straightforward but your choices matter and you get to watch different scenes/outcomes depending on what you choose. Also i like how later on he implements the points system (exhibitionism, sharing etc) which makes the routes more flexible.
- The animations are pretty good overall, and there is a decent amount of variety.
- The daughter is absolutely gorgeous for the most part, and her personality is charming (you just want to protect her and slowly show her the ways).
- Pretty good game length, even if it's not completed yet.
- The points system (FP/LP) matter and are rewarding, so it's worth it to try to always get the best outcome (specially before implementing the exh, share, bdsm traits etc).
- Most of the secondary characters are relevant and add depth to the plot (besides Jennifer i'd say).
- There is a good amount of variety in the renders and they offer a pretty good quality overall.

Thinks that i disliked:

- Complete lack of music (this was a huge deal specially while playing Melody (a game about music lol)), but in general i prefer the game to have some music for a better immersion.
- I really disliked the model of Jennifer: Her head is way too big compared to her body, and here body literally looks like she is 8, not to mention that her face is basically the daughter's with different eyes and hair color (what's even the point of this character? make the dad think about his daughter?)
- I didn't like that you pretty much had to read the walkthrough (something that i always try to avoid) in order to go to Koko's concert.
- Some choices that give you secondary traits (or even the existence of these) should be more obvious, specially when you want to afford losing FP/LP to them.
- The story progresses a bit too slow in my opinion, even if 14 days is a good amount of time for a single realease, most of the dates seem to be fillers where the relationship between dad and daughter doesn't really progress.
- Some animations/renders regarding the girls aren't really well made (Daughter's ass looks weird sometimes, and so do some of the poses (for example during the yoga class)).

Pretty decent game overall, was enjoyable to play! Looking forward to the next releases, same with Melody.

The best game I ever played here.
Best fluid animations, story-telling and background details.
I would pay for this.

The best game I ever played here.
Best fluid animations, story-telling and background details.
I would pay for this.

Updated review based on Ch. 4 v0.31:

What was once one of my favorite games and the actual game that got me into the 3d adult game scene to begin with has now turned into a game that I despise. Everything started to go down hill with Ch. 3 when they had for about 2 years teased the sharing content and teasing it heavily in Ch. 3 to just suddenly announcing that they was going to drop it... I knew already then that something had been going on behind the scene as Chapter 3 as a whole was a mess and felt rushed on all fronts, broken promises and fetishes that had been talked about since Chapter 1 suddenly being taken out.

Either way, chapter 3 which was supposed to be the last chapter ended on a cliffhanger and a new chapter was promptly announced. Which they defended with: "We have so much more we want to tell and also to give DmD a fitting end".. But guess what? It is just the same old content all over again, making it quite clear that they are milking the game for everything its worth... While keeping some fans of certain fetishes on the bench with promises for content towards the end. I can already foresee it being two scenes in the last update.

Such a shame...

Spoiler: Old 5 star review

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

I can only echo the other negative reviews here.

- The story is far, far too slow. It would be forgivable if each line of dialogue progressed the plot but most of the time the dialogue is just a re-hash of a conversation they had before.

- Daughter is utterly unrealistic. She's supposed to be 18 or so, but she has the intelligence and self-awareness of a 9 year old. She's ireedemably naive in such a way that it screams of bad writing rather than a ditzy character, because she is badly written.

- The art is... uncomfortable. Proportions are ridiculously off. It's a similar issue to the dev's other game Melody. Bodies resemble tweens when supposed to be 18-20 years old. Their heads are too large for their bodies, and breasts while not ridiculously huge, are modeled in such a way that they look like they're made of solid plastic. It honestly looks like the dev was giving you characters that look underage on purpose for the sake of fucking. It's revolting.

- The relationship between father and D is alright once it gets going, but even then it feels like the dev doesn't know what they want to do with them so they meander through the plot hoping to find something to work with.

- Father's penis is ridiculous and the things this ditzy moron of a girl does to it ( when not knowing what a penis looks like, somehow. Don't ask me, it's the writing) are just stupid.

It falls flat in nearly every conceivable way, not to mention the update schedule is awful.

To conclude - I wouldn't recommend this game if you're looking for an adult game fix. I wouldn't recommend it if you enjoy a well-written and paced story. I wouldn't recommend it if characters needs to have depth for you to enjoy them. I cannot recommend this game, and if you do play I hope you won't notice the subtext "age" of the girls, because I can't ignore it.

Great fairy tale princess-awakes-within-the-modern-world type of story, told with compelling characterizations and reliable, high quality visuals. It's easy to fall for these characters and root for some while hating others, but this game doesn't fall for stereotypes and lets all sorts of things try to work out. You can choose some paths vs others but the primary one stays constant: the MC and his daughter as central focus.

Well paced story with lots of content and characters. The choices are plenty and pretty significant. There's a reason it's one of the most popular ones here. Definitely check it out if you're OK with the title lol.

Let me just briefly say: it was one of the worst I've ever played.

Even if there was quite a few funny & good moments and some of the girls are really catched me with their talk/body, but still, the two main characters completely ruin the whole game.

Especially D and for me she is a minus 5*. Apart from all the other characters in the game her body type is so unrealisticly perfect like a plastic doll. That would be okay for a simple porn game like FILF but this one is (want to be) different.

What kind of story is it? It is a romantic story about father and daughter how they fall in love each other veeeeery (too) slowly. D is an 18 year old girl but she is basically so moron she dont even know what a PENIS is... not even know anything about sexuality, body anatomy, natural reactions and so on, so lets just say she is more like a 5-6 year old girl with a body of an 18 year old porn star (after millions of surgeries).

And all of these things just make the game more sick... I mean look around, of course we dont mind incest, but I strongly believe that most of us better addicted to certain situations than to the real fact of incest. Hope Im right. In this game Daddy slowly slowly brainwash his (in fact braindead) daughter just to f**k her and it is not just pure incest, but it is pedophilia as well because D is just as mature as a 5-6 year old kid.

So the whole story wants to be an "anytime could happen" romance based on real life (most of characters completely compliance to this fact) APART from the two main character.

I have tried to force myself to play through but I gave up at 2nd episode, it was too much...

Beautiful game, kind of painfully slow though. The MC has some saintly patience, good thing he has other outlets for his little devil!

Very much looking forward to new chapters to see how this relationship grows as they explore her sexuality !

-Hours and hours of gameplay to have the first handjob, until there is just teasing the player so you don't quit.
-The daughter has the innocence of a child while being 18.
-Too much blah blah blah I'm her father "I shouldn't do this" , okay, it's good for the realism, but him repeating this after masturbating for her, touching her ass and boobs, having french kiss, oh god, and yes, after some kind of 10hours of gameplay you only have this, for me this would be playable if you jump everything by looking the walkthrough, the game just sucks.
-The good thing is that the art is good, good graphics and the creator know how to keep you playing, but for me after +10hrs playing I get bored asf. The worst is the points, the game has friend points, love points and etc, and it says to you that you have choice, but choosing it will make you lose points and you don't even get the scene, for example, touch daughter ass, so you touch it, them there's a option, stop or keep touching, after you fucking touch her ass, if you continue she will get mad at you and end the scene, like, what? you have already touched, you have already french kissed her, touched her boobs, and if you KEEP TOUCHING she gets mad, ok. If this doesn't happen, what I said up there about the father with his mental problems will happen, this game it's just a joke for me, that's it, 3,40gb of just bullshit time-wasting.
-Another point is: anyone who isn't the daughter in the game is a bitch who the most thing she wants is fuck you, just like that, to keep you in the game like I said, but even to fuck them you have to wait hours because shit happen, like your daughter waking up or anything and you just can't fuck.
That's it, I'm done with this shit, these people who give more than 4 stars for the game made what I said, just jumped the conversation, because if they readed they would see the game just keeps repeating the same fucking shit.
I'm giving it 2 stars just for the quality the game have in graphics and the potential it had.

I really don't want to be too harsh with this game since is obviously made with a lot of effort, and there is a lot of content.
And I actually have nothing to say about the technical side of things, the renders are pretty alright, and the animations are good.



But o.m.g, everything surrounding the writing is so bad, so cliche, so unispired, so unsastisfaying.



- The characters are one-dimensional. The daughter is so cliche, I hate that shy virgin girl shtick, when she obviously shouldn't be. If you want do that, at least choose a more plausible design

- Another story where every girl fall in love with the MC at first sight, for no good reason.

- The frienship and love point system is too punitive, you almost never really have a choice, since most alternative choices beside the good one will result with the daughter whining about something and you losing the points.

- Yes there is a lot of content, it is long, but it is also because a lot of the scenes drag. Not a very good pacing

- The dialogs in general are pretty terrible. The MC's seem so overly nice with each other, doesn't feel natural at all. And the conversations always revolve around the same themes (shyness, awkwardness, tension between them). It gets very boring and frustrating.

Love this game. Its in my top 5 for sure.. Hours of fun with many girls to choose from. Great renders and a fun story the leads you everywhere. Everyone will enjoy this one. A must have along with Mrdots's Melody title.

This was my first ever adult game. I found f95zone for this game in 2017. And somehow I forgot to write a review. Even it it doesn't matter if I write or not. This game will always be the best of the bests. I thank MrDots Games for this amazing game

Pros :
* Awesome Renders
* Awesome Story
* Awesome Girls
* Awesome Animations
* Awesome Sex Scenes
* Long Gameplay
* Everything is Awesome

Cons :
* You think you can find any cons in this game???

Man, this game sure is a throwback for me. First adult game I downloaded, so it's like I'm looking back at Super Mario 64 or something with the nostalgia this gives me lol. But as far as quality, I haven't actually played up to the most recent release of content, but I did get pretty damn close. That being said, the game doesn't have the most realistic portrayals of characters, (particularly the daughter, who is so naive she probably gives away all of her savings to Nigerian princes looking to ship gold via email). That being said, there's a reason this game is so popular, (aside from the seemingly explosive growth of incest popularity, which I too find myself enjoying quite a damn bit), and that is that the development really takes its time to make things feel like a much more natural progression rather than an immediate barrier-skip of societal taboos. That being said, the game might take its time a bit too much, considering up to the point I played to I still hadn't gotten the chance to bang the titular female, although there were plenty of hot interactions with her and her particularly enticing friend character named Elena. Man oh man, a minx-like character trying to seduce her friend's dad certainly got the job done for me. Overall, there is a LOT of content here, and it will keep you occupied for a very long time. Above average VN experience, and hopefully Patreon will stop being so oppressive about this genre so we can get back to faster development cycling for this game.

For me personally DMD is the GOAT of Adult Games.

The writing, graphics, variation in girls, looks of girls, animations are all fantastic but where the game really shines is in it's pacing. The slow teasing build towards getting more and more intimate with your daughter coupled with the character building leads to incredible sexual tension that so many other games fail at producing. It's that level of building and tension that makes the payoff so rewarding and boy does this game pay off and yet still keep building towards more.
Despite all the tension building the game gives you instant gratification away from the daughter too, so don't worry you don't get blue-balled.

Overall I can't recommend DMD enough. A top tier game from a top tier dev (Melody is great too)

For me it's the best porn game ever.
It's a bit ankward sometimes when characters seems to be underage and not only physically but in it's behaviour and life style (Goes to school and lives with parents by the law OR Elena or D and u cannot be seen in public, why if you are legal aged u can do it, no one know D is ur daughter after all appart of Elena and Jennifer when you are in your country) too, but the perfect plot makes me forget about this thing.
A thing i see almost trashy are the love or friendly points given at least for now. It was only of use at the begining of the game in 2 or 3 options but it becomes useless when everything you do (of some importance) with D is obbligatory if u dont do it, it turns into a game over. And the relations with other characters u can do wharever u what and there is any bad way to do anything that mess the things and makes the girl and u to split.
Something that is fixed in Melody game.

I don't know what developer will add in the future but i don't care as long as he don't mess up the story try to force things.
For example if the lawyer goes after D and dev includes NTR he has to do it so ggod because D promises u love forever and don't seems to be interesed in other thing than haviing a relationship with you, no matter what she has to do. And i don't see D fooling around with random people so suddenly (because she had chances before and didn't go further ). [I think dev will include this after two or mor updates]
But i have faith that the dev will do it good.
Sad we have to wait more than two months to see the next part