VN - Ren'Py - Completed - Dating My Daughter [Ch. 1-4 v1.01] [MrDots Games]

This game has a very nice slow build-up which makes the game feel more realistic. You really focus on your relationship between the mc and the daughter. You also see their struggle with the general idea that incest is wrong, but still continue because of their love. Which gives it bonus points for me.

One of the best VN's out there of this genre. The best part is you don't have to commit incest to experience it, for that we have this game

With 166 reviews for DMD already, most glowing, mine isn't going to count for much, but for anyone browsing up on this VN all unsuspecting-like, just a head's-up:

• The story is LONG. Lots of deep text, much of it unnervingly favorable to the philosophy of incest (esp by Chapter 2-3). Like, don't make it weird, man; it's a kink, we don't have to analyze it.
• The characters are even more unnatural-looking than normal for h-games, at least the females. Breasts that point upward, zero sag or consistent shape; butts that bulge up rather than back/down; foreheads bigger than faces; etc. The animations are bizarre: slow, stiff, repetitive, totally unnatural. I'm not going to mention the size of everything, every h-game has that; this is different, this is just flipping the bird at physics. If this VN had human-shaped bodies, this story would have almost chillingly effective.
• On a related note. While loli is not my thing, as long as the story clearly supports them being 18+ -- and this one does -- I don't care how they look. That said, especially in Chapter 2, most of the female characters in DMD are bizarrely tiny. Like, Dad's hand is clearly wider than the entire torso, not just for one image, but the entire scene. As in, these are the bodies of six year olds. Again: immersion-breaking.

Anyway, this game has a ton of work put into it, but the topic and the graphics really don't do it justice.

Dating My Daughter Review (v. 0.25) / Played with Lain's Mod

TL;DR: Solid 4/5

What I like:
1) Renders - Good looking female characters. Nice and unique designs. 2) Sensual Talk and Scenes - The perverted talk and situations are hot.
3) 4) 5) Elena / Georgina - Biased, but I like their designs and sensual personalities.
6) 7) **** Amount of Content **** - I put extra stars around this because this is the biggest factor for the rating. Although it's mostly focused on the daughter, you can see and enjoy other scenes with other characters, as well. Chapters 1 and 2 were long and enjoyable despite some slow buildup, and even then, it's still not finished. Looking forward for what is to come.

What I don't hate, but could be better:
1) Story - Soap Opera story. No major conflicts, obstacles, or sacrifices. It's also possible that my viewpoint here is tainted because I used a walkthrough mod, which is a fair critique.
2) Animations - The animations get a little better in chapter 3, but in 1 and 2, they can be a little choppy and odd at times.

What Needs to Be Improved:
1) The use of English is underdeveloped and sometimes unnatural (when viewed from an American English perspective). The syntax of some of the characters needs to be cleaned up and diversified to sound more unique and commonplace. They sound too similar and formal to one another sometimes. There are also a few spelling errors.
2) More sound effects.
3) Music needs to be inserted into the game for more dramatic / sensual effect.
4) Dad's neck beard. Please either give dad a nice beard or shave it off completely.

v0.25 chapter 1 - 3

It's a very good game. I really liked the first and the second chapter. The beginning is a little bit weird since there is no introduction and no connection to the characters. Afterwards the dialogues get better and better and the sexual tension between D and F increases. In my opinion this sexual tension carries the whole game and provides the curiosity to see what comes next.

GOOD
- character building, character diversity
- natural and romantic dialogues
- sexual tension between D and F,
- 1st & 2nd chapter: the romantic sex scenes with foreplay, french kissing, etc.

BAD
- most of the models look OK but not amazing,
- facial expression could be improved
- 3rd chapter: sexual tension drops, less french kissing, less foreplay, not
much decisions during sex scenes

Third chapter is still ok but not as good as the previous ones. The central romantic relationship becomes a bit superficial with less romantic, less kissing, etc. Furthermore it's a bit frustrating that they left off all the foreplay options that we build up in chapter one and two. More decision making in sexual scenes would be much better.
Besides that it is still a very good game if you like incestuous stories.

I don't know... The game is well done but it doesn't keep you entertained in the long term. The dialogues and story are kinda dull, the girls are OK but don't have much spice...
It is very similar to "Melody" but in Melody the story was better in my opinion, and the characters were more interesting. To me, it is a weak version of "Melody".

=== Chara Design :
The renders are quite good and the girls quite pretty. Now it is nothing exceptionnal, especially in 2020. I don't really like the MC.

=== Story/Background :
I don't really buy the story. The corruption and relationship progress between the father and daugther is pretty absurd. The dialogues are well written but it is too dull, too slow, too serious....in a word : boring.

=== Sex/Animations :
I have only played the 1st chapter, I did not have the courage to play other chapters. Probably this chapter was done in 2018, and therefore had animations from 2018. Correct but outdated.

=== Contents/Gameplay :
Nothing to complain here. Contents are very solid. The game is long, the gameplay is simple but neat. The interface is nice. No music ??

Well if you really like incest and vanilla games, you can try this one, it will probably suit your taste. Otherwise, if "Melody" wasn't your thing, don't even try this one, it is even worst.

I have to say this is by far the best visual novel i have ever had the pleasure to experience. I cannot wait for more of this content to be released. And the author and everyone else involved in the making of DMD are doing an excellent job. Absolutely love this. Again i cannot wait for more. 10/10

• Models 6/10 - most models look like Barbie dolls, very unnatural skin tone and sometimes facial expressions as well.
• Animations 6/10 - they're mostly ok, but still remind lopped pics and of course they're nowhere near top level like BaDIK and Milfy City.
• Writing 7/10 - quite good for VN, no heavy language, no stupid babbling.
• Plot 6/10 - plot lacks suspense, the whole game is just the sequence of dates with D and nothing in between, it's tiresome.
• Sex Scenes 7/10 - scenes mostly are well developed and variative, still there're should be more dirty talking and devs should put more work to make some of the scenes special (longer than the others, unique and polished)

Walking Penis Chronicles Dating My Daughter consists of 3 parts:

1. Undressing and BJ. The weakest part, devs should really consider to add some penetration scenes with D in form of night dreams.
2. Licking and defloration. The strongest part and the one with most intresting plot too.
3. Fucking and threesome. Mediocre at the time of writing.

Overall, the game would be much better if story wasn't wrapped around D alone. F especially needs more work, as being said for now he is just a walking cock.

A review of this game

Chapter 1 perfect for me we get to see each characters personality and mc's and dee's relationship whom begins to blossom 5/5

Chapter 2 Masterpiece mc and dee's relationship upgrades to that of love and our characters throws out any last restraints that may have due to their relationship as father-daughter also we have enough sex scenes from other characters as well elena, Jennifer and Georgina 5/5

Chapter 3 Good we have sex scenes evolving threesomes Father-Dee-Elena, Father-Dee-Georgina,Father-Dee-Jennifer unfortunatelly there is some fouls

1.Father-Dee-Elena and Father-Dee-Georgina are the same scenes so instead of Rejecting Jenifer for Georgina you Should Reject elena instead because you get similar sex scenes This also gives the impression to the player that you have neglected this game in favor of Sisterly love or Melody(don't remember which game were working at this time)

2.The Martin isue the problem with Martin could be solved pretty easily for me since there were many debates first you can make the relationship optional and open a route for martin and let people decide and be done with it or you can explain clear that there will be no NTR content on this game(for me this is not NTR is sharing but whatever)

3/5

Chapter 4 Failure the purposose of chapter 4 was to get some scenes that were missing from previous chapters some 4somes with Father-Dee-Elena-Georgina or Father-Dee-Elena-Jennifer instead we got one whole scene in an entire chapter epic fail for me

Second we get the impression of one step forward two steps back we saw in previous chapters that daughter wanted to start a family with mc and at chapter 4 we see the daughter scared of having a baby with mc wtf this gives me the impression that the developers have forgotten what they wrought at previous chapters

Third mr Dots fell to the trap of having continuous sex scenes with dee without even making it more kinky discarding almost entirely other characters Elena, Georgina, Jennifer and they did not even consider to at least spice things up (insert some bdsm scenes for god's sake)

Now for the endings half of them are the same worst is you saw one you saw all and the cherry on top the flashback wtf

These facts makes me think two things either they wanted to extend DMD for as long as they could without any real plot in mind or they gave their attention to their other game either way the 4th chapter failed to deliver what mr dots team said to give...

0/5

Overall Rating 3,25/5

So I'm going to keep this short.

I've only played chapter 1 (so it might not apply to later chapters but you've gotta get through 1 anyhoo) ... and that alone is a tooooooon of content, when I saw it was divided up into chapters I thought each one would be fairly short but no, that was longer than some whole games in and of itself.

But it goes slow, which makes sense, she's your daughter and you've not seen her in ages, you're not going to be getting freaky on day 1 ... buuuut, it means I got bored of my daughter and don't think I'll be dating her any more... it's not just that the sex went slow, I just didn't like her as a person.

One of my major problems with the game are that choices don't seem to matter, it's either right (raises stats) or wrong or didn't matter either way ... so it's real helpful to use a walkthrough mod. But I'd rather it be that I could get with her regardless, and corruption was more about if I want a good little wife, or a dirty whore I was going to share around or prostitute out... rather than what it actually seems to be - just a measure of if you get to do stuff to her ... I'm super curious how high that scale goes up though ... like I wonder what you can do at max corruption, but I couldn't find a wiki for it, does she eventually get into drugs and group sex and things?

My other qualm is just that the models are kinda basic looking, I can't explain it better that that, maybe not as textured or complicated or something so it doesn't feel as real as some other games, and that's probably what ultimately killed it for me.

So tons of content, well polished... but slow, no real choices, and not great models...

Overall, very nice. A little rough around the edges, but overall this is a real treat for taboo lovers in general.

Pro:
-Writing is nice.
-Characters are well developed.
-There's some actually really touching moments.
-Nice designs for the characters, if a little basic.

Con:
-Animations are passable, but could use more work, maybe something a bit more original, and perhaps different options.
-Backgrounds are basic and work ok, but a bit more detail in the env. would be nice.
-Better renders in general (I do not know the authors rig, and if it's simply not possible, it's understandable).
-Sex scene pacing is very varied and can come off as kinda grindy sometimes, which in story context is understandable, it's probably not easy too build up fucking a relative (lmao) in a realistic way, but it still comes off as a bit inconsistant.

The incest aspect in itself isn't generally too serious, but depending on how consequential you want a relationship like that to play out, if you're looking for something super realistic there's probably other options.
(I mean it' still a porn game. Probably wouldn't be able to look myself in the mirror if it was that realistic lmao.)

Again, overall, very nice.
Good start to MrDots library.

I'm in chapter 2 of this game. The game it's self has a pretty good story line, but it gets very grindy after a while (not in a good way). The animations could use a little love, but over all a solid title.

The only problem with this game for me is the model of daughter. For me her boobs and ass is too big and it feels weird on her because she is a small person. Thats why Elena is the best girl in this game. She has a body that fits her. Overall the game is fine and the story is good enough to make you entertained.

Great story and amazing art. I like the daughter's friend character. The way she has been brought into play over the chapters is quite interesting to play.

Just finished Chapter 1 and moving on to Chapter 2 now.

An amazing slow burn game with a well written story. Very story driven as opposed to a "flat out fuck-fest but compelling enough that it makes you WANT to know the characters better and invest in them.

easy feedback from myself.

-great cg.
-although story is a bit linear, there are choices though.
-cant wait for more updates


i do have one minor gripe i guess. can you do away with the kissing click, then boob grab click, then ass grab click. Or Maybe make it an all in one animation. it sort of got a bit annoying. but still like i said its minor and i have no objection through clicking through it.

also is the MC is like always hard, i dont think ive seen a flaccid donger from him anywhere lol that dude has defintely had an erection for more than 4 hours. Or maybe I am wrong and hes is both a show-her and a grow-her.

I love this game very very mutch.
Wonderful animations.
Awesome characteres.
the story is so wow....
I spend hour over hour to play that game and I'm looking forward for more!!!!!
Thanks to all for working on that wonderful game
**************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************as I say I love it so mutch

The very first game I tried by hazard becoming a member of this website in 2017.

I didn't know at that time it would have so much success and supporters.
Now, after playing many others great games, I clearly see that it has become a pure standard reference for many others.

It deserves absolutely his reputation. Nothing compares to it actually.

Long life to DmD and congratulations to the Dev. team and to the uploader as well for the excellent work !

I have played 2 chapters. So far so good. Enough number of characters and enough scenes to keep the player engaging.

If audio would have been there, it would have been much better experience. Kudos to the dev team.

On its own this game is good and probably the best Dad/Daughter game I've played so I'd rate it 3/5. With Lain's Mod there's tons of improvements so I'd rate it 5/5. So I split the difference and gave it a 4/5.


Pros - Models, Story, Characters

Cons - Some odd game overs, some scenes which dont fit(or i dislike).

Not really the best adult VN right there.
But definitely worth a try.
Because my favorite of all time is Acting Lessons and BADIK (sorry but they are way above the rest of all games)

pros:
-good renders
-good animations
-good setting
-story above average i guess despite of the theme

cons:
-some characters really HAVE big heads
-the daughter looks like a brainwashed barbie
-you GUYS really need to add some drama to the story because the major theme of the game is INCEST, but its becoming a stupid harem LN
-no music in incest theme? meh..