VN - Ren'Py - Completed - Dating My Daughter [Ch. 1-4 v1.01] [MrDots Games]

Five stars!

What's really left to say about Dating My Daughter? It's the flagship of it's genre and literally the comparison point of every other father-daughter adult game.

Let's just review the positives and areas MRDOTS could still improve.

Positives:

# The user is spoiled for choice. Many options unlock various paths that allows a new playthrough to be a partially new game. Having to play a title more than once to see all the quality content is my top check-box for choosing a five star rating.

# The models are well-rendered and animations smooth.

# The writing is witty and straightforward. You can feel the story's natural progression and it's obvious the author spends time putting together and proofing a script before creating new content.

# It's fun! I know that's an oddball positive to include, but truthfully not every game with good writing and graphic design is legitimately fun to play more than once. This game is!

Improvements:

# As someone who spends A LOT of my day proofing the writing of others, there are some minor spelling and grammatical errors that tend to be present in every title (adult and non-adult). It's something that I notice, but I'm also strange.

# Please! A Georgina-Elena-Daughter threesome! Please!

I really wanted to give this game 5 stars but the amount of time he takes to progress with the story is ridiculous.

Yes there are side characters that you can have sex with but those are so short lived and have very little passion in them.

0.17 yet the best we got is a blowjob. How dense Di can be to not even figure out that the dad wants to fuck her?
Come on! She can't be that stupid.

By this many updates she should be thinking of trying every possible kinky way to have sex all day long. Instead we are still doing oral stuffs

It's so amazing, with great writing, beautiful 3d images and the character design is the best of any game in my opinion, like Elena and Jennifer and the others, they are all so pleasant and still have such different personalities and traits that make them really interesting too.

There is many choices in this game and you can go where you want with the story, and even if not all the choices do much, the abundence of them makes you feel more like you are playing and not just clicking. The game also feels very long and has alot of content already even if it is not finished.

Edit December 2019: This game was very good when i first wrote this review, like with many of these games, they change with time, since the second half of chapter 2, the game has been going downhill alot, chapter 1 and half of chapter 2 was 9/10, but the rest is 5/10, so much repetition, lack of creativity, worse writing, changed characters, lack of choices(this games biggest positive earlier), forced ntr, etc etc. the list is long, crazy that a game can fall like that

edit May 2020: Chapter 3 has been awful so far, 1/5 stars for chapter 3 and 5 stars for 1 and 2, the quality has gone down alot and the events are just repetitions of earlier ones, no variety, no chocies, worse dialog, the only thing holding up is the graphics, but thats not enough to make a good game. 6 / 10

edit October 2020: Well, everything I said in earlier edits have come true, the game has totally transformed and become just a generic, boring, repetative kenetic novel, and all the choices made during the game have no impact at all. That together with the total deterioration in writing quality have made this game awful, through and through. I guess that shows why to never rate a game until its completed(or stopped/ended in any way). Right now this is an awful game with good graphics, 2/10.

This game is a high quality erotic VN game. Story is totally believable and just nice as it is.
You can easily take the roll of the MC and play along. Not boring at all. This game can suck you in and keep you interested for a long time.
The characters, their build-up and personalities are awesome. Gameplay is good, flowing nicely. Your choices do have consequences.
H-scenes are nice and the 3D graphics are looking good. Drawback: the childish bodies of the other girls.

Definitely a must have game for the VN fans.

This game is really good with the story being well done plus the art is very good. Sex scenes could have been better and more of em plus taking to long to get the daughter back and fucking her. The long waiting for updates is another big issue with the game but once it is finished and if the sex scenes with the daughter and her BFF are done good this is a 5 star game.

Art 9.5/10
Characters 10/10
Story 10/10
Sex 9/10

Yes based on my ratings of art, characters, sex and story it should be a 5 star rating like other games i rated with my rating system but like i said a few issues make it 4 stars for now.

Edit June 29
With the newer updates it is now a 5 star rating!

The best game that I have downloaded on F95Zone by far, I'm glad to hear there will be an update later on this month as I'm eagerly waiting to see if the dad gets his daughter home and away from the b*tch of a mom. Played this game Again and again and again and now i'm off to play again. Keep up the fantastic work Dev and loved your new one also "melody"

This game takes the reluctant slow approach to what amounts to incest. I think tasteful might be a stretch, but it definitely plays with the idea of slowing breaking down barriers. I admittedly haven't gotten through Chapter 2 yet, but I can tell you it's an enjoyable experience. It's not a fuck your brains out style of game, it's more of a relationship development game. Don't get me wrong though, there is fucking to be had. Overall, really decent game.

One of the best games I have played. Excellent graphics, really flawless! Beautiful girls, nice plot, well written dialogues and great game play mechanics!!! There is no unnecessary grinding, but at the same time it's not just a click through visual novel either.
Really loved it!! Can't wait to get the next update. I hope there would be more content coming faster. It has been going really well and I wish the developer continues to get more content out as soon as possible. I am really hooked to this game.

The story in this game is excellent and well thought out and designed. It is one of the best visual novel games on this site. The graphics are awesome and the characters have interesting stories that aren't always predictable. I highly recommend this game.

I think the visuals in this game are very good, and I appreciate the restraint used with the daughter. It would be very easy to push her through to the MFM content and reported beastiality, however, Mr. Dots has shown good restraint.

One of the most erotic Games i know... The Story is brilliant and Alice (thats her Name in my Game) is so cute and sexy at the same time.
I really hope that the Game doesn't End know, with the Patreon Incest Shit and the new Project Melody... but hope dies last.

I think I don't assume to much when I say I first downloaded the game with the intention of using it as fapping material. It has nice images and the story is kinky. So it fits. But on my first playthrough before I got to any 'good parts' (you know what I mean) I was already so engaged with the story that the 'original' purpose flew out the window. I simply wanted to know how it continues and to make sure they get the happy end they deserve.

I'm not saying the original purpose wasn't fulfilled in the playthroughs that followed. Some scenes are way to sexy to not do something about it.

So the long and short of it: The game is simply great and has something for everyone. A great story, very sexy images and scenes, and some kink to it.

The story in this game is excellent and well thought out and designed. It is one of the best visual novel games on this site. The graphics are awesome and the characters have interesting stories that aren't always predictable. I highly recommend this game.

Today DMD is one of the epitomes of adult 3D games. It wasn't the first daughter game, it won't be the last, there are other pretty 3D daughters out there, with more content or much kinkier gameplay. But none of these games can even remotely stand up to the level of character building Mr.Dots has put into "her". To me "his" daughter is the most complex and believable character of all adult games that we actually have: curious, careful, worried, relieved, fascinated, terrified...we follow her development for over a year now and only advanced up to a blowjob! But nobody cares, because she is so well designed, here story is so intriguing, that at least for me it's half wanting to see her naked and half see her story/way unfold...for a fap game this is extraordinary!

The missing 5th star is because of my fear that we won't be able to follow this game for much longer. There is a fundament laid out by Mr.Dots to go way beyond the actual scope, with bondage points, incest threesomes and much more. But Patreons strict guidelines already forced this game out of its spot, gradually getting removed by his new project. It won't take long I fear that this new project, better fitting into the guidelines of Patreon, will take over his time and interest with getting DMD rushed to the end if not abandoned.

Ah DMD, to me, the father of the incest VN market. (pun intended)
This game, this fucking game. I've played through this game probably 10 times now, replay through it all the way re reading everything each time. This game has sucked up probably around 30 hours of my life, and a lot of tissues. (if you know what I mean)

Pros:
-STUNNING VISUALS, GREAT ANIMATION!!!
-The story is decently immersive
-Mr.Dots is a good dude, always updates on time with decent amount of content
-D is adorable! <3
-MC is just (for the most part) an innocent guy not an asshole in most other incest games.
-Even without the incest tag, still a great read with choices of scenes

Cons:
-As I said above the MC is more of an innocent guy, so playing on the fact that D is completely naive to sexual stuff the story takes quite some time to get to any intimate scenes. Mostly voyeurism the first hour or so in the story.
-The story is kinda linear, you will end up in the same spot in the end regardless of your choices in the game. Just miss out on different scenes if you don;t play perfectly.
-.......But that's pretty much it.

TLDR;
Great game, if you haven't played it yet, do it. Don't think about it, do it.... JUST DO IT!

Stunning visuals, great storyline, dialogues that change the outcome of the scene (future scenes not entirely sure if are affected), no sound that's true but once you are in the game you just move along. Still not sure if you have alternative endings, that would be a plus. Congrats

10 out of 10 game best i've ever played i hope to see the future updates of this game i love the concept and the story is incredible i really hope the developer keeps up the great work that he's been doing ever since he started creating this game. i would recommend this game to everyone, you won't be disapointed in it. Simply said this game is Amazing from top to bottom take my advice and try it out and support the developers of the game cause they DESERVE IT !!!!

Its refreshing to play a game where you play the parent in the incestuous relationship. This relationship between the MC and his daughter progresses so naturally, where you have to make choices to slowly corrupt her into accepting the sexual desires she has for her dad. The other characters and their stories as also pretty fun. Its a shame that this game has been taken out of patreon because it will probably never be completed.

Easy to say that this is one of my favorite games at the moment. Let me explain why:

1. Great story. Censored or uncensored does not matter , it still pulls you in.

2. The graphics are a work of art. Great models and it shows that the developer has taken his time to make sexy and adorable characters.

3. You as a player have the option of choosing different paths. Not all choices will lead to a positive result, and you will regret some of them. (The power of the boner takes over sometimes).

4. Re-play value is high. Because of point 3. It is fun to explore all characters, decisions and the different routes.

5. Lets face it. We play it for seeing the sex scenes. They leave you wanting more in a positive way.

I know im not writing anything special. All this has very likely already been said by other members. But trust me, there is a reason why. Try it out and you will see that no one is bs´ing you.

Interesting and fun game, great graphics, excellent writing and story line. Great overall game in my humble opinion and definitely worth a shot for anyone with an interested in this kind of genre. Also, great support and very active creator.