Trophy Mom was was great. From art to story. Just so sad that Y3DF gone suddenly.
I liked every chapter but the fourth, though to its credit, it did set up the expectation for NTR since the very first chapter. And I would imagine that many didn't have a problem with it because the NTR involved her other son. Still, I agree that both the art and story were quite stellar. (I figure I better answer this way since your avatar is from Chapter 2.)
Going back to the MILF of Daval, any of your ranking will do. All of Daval's MILF are great. But here is mine.
Sarah = most beautiful (for me).
Amanda = most provocative beauty and my first love (for me).
Lana = complete package (for me)
All three of them are so sexy, so hot and #1 for me among Daval's creation.
The other MILFs are great but Alexa is on top of them but just a little bit below of the 3 names on top.
Nice list. I imagine I may have felt different depending on which work first caught my attention. For me, it was
Immoral Desires. I was actually going to stay away from 3D works, especially 3D incest, considering the advancement in 3D art has provided a catalyst to my often escapist and fantasy-prone tendencies. And CrazyDad3D kind of ruined the concept for me at the time. I was aware of Madness Together first, but chose not to read it. I honestly read the first chapter of Immoral Desires on whim, and thought Lana's design was impeccable even with that large brown sweater. Something about her modesty was just appealing to me. Then, I relented and read Chapter Four of Madness Together, and appreciated the slow-burn of the Uncle/Niece incest. Also, Sarah is 3D art's epitome of "blonde beauty." I still haven't read Satisfying Needs fully, only skimming pages, so perhaps my lack of attention on the series has under-served my ranking of Amanda. Though I'm sure many here were introduced to Daval's work through Satisfying Needs, so I understand one's holding Amanda in high esteem. Where I think Amanda's appeal could have been improved was in playing to her strengths. When you have her dress in lewd clothing, it's hard not to compare her to Alexa, who frankly pulls it off better. Don't get me wrong, Amanda without clothes can stand her ground with Lana, Sarah, and Alexa, but because wardrobes are reused throughout Daval's works, and Daval tends to make the female characters dress and make themselves up more lewdly as their respective stories progress, I don't think she pulls off those look as well as the aforementioned three. That's not to say that Amanda's design isn't incredibly sexy when she tries.
Mandologica have a great MILFs too. Check it out.
I'm familiar with Mandologica's work. I like Katherine from
Forbidden Flames. She's wonderfully "thick," and the short temper adds to her appeal. I used to like Adrianna from
Breaking Boundaries, but the attempt to "make her sexier" has actually made her less sexy. Her original design was good enough. But the schoolgirl outfits and the Nurse uniforms just take away from her original appeal. I do like the change from blonde to auburn, though. As for Caroline from
Teamwork, one could probably argue that she's the most attractive out of the four, though I still like Katherine better, I personally just don't like the "slutty mom" look, behavior and vibe. As for the mother in
Just For You, even though I know how she looks, I've never read the story in which she's featured.