i get where u coming from, but i think Aaron suits the night fiddler role better than Pete, my pitch would be that after Aaron gets his share of Alice’s tight ass she would reject him cuz deep down she wants David, but David continues fucking Sarah which makes her jealous, Alice would then try flirt with Aaron as a rebound but he would reject her out of pettiness thinking that would make Alice chase him, but Pete would start paying attention to Alice, complimenting her, maybe one night he would find her in living room alone while the rest of house sleeps, Pete starts a pleasant conversation with her as she pours her heart out about a boy she likes but doesnt want to name, he would reassure her that if the boy isn’t interested in her then some other boy perhaps a man would be, Pete would unfold some story how Alice reminds him of his wife, since she told him story how after her first heartbreak she found comfort in an older neighbor and after some time they even fucked, Alice would then ask Pete if she regretted it later to which Pete would reply “her only regret was that she was unsure and didn’t enjoy herself sooner, since the neighbor moved out after some time and she was alone again” as a manipulation tactic, then he would ask her to help him to the restroom that he needs to pee and needs supervision so he doesnt fall or some other bullshit, after Pete is done he would ask her to hand him a toilet paper that’s where she would take a peep and she is in awe and drops rest of the paper roll, as she climbs down Pete asks her if she can put his underwear on so he doesnt have to bend over since she’s already down, as her head moves up with the rest of her body her head follows along Pete’s dick and thinks to herself how would that even fit into someone‘s neck which makes her wet, after this awkward but curious moment for Alice she helps him to bed, where Pete says to her that once again he understands how her heart feels certain way towards one person but her body can feel other ways hinting that she can just enjoy sex for the sake of it, he would ask her to close the window in the room and as she turns around Pete’s dick is out as he claims he sleeps natural, she would then wish him good night and on her way to the room she would ask herself if he was hinting something, but says that it doesn’t matter that she doesn’t want to think about it but then she hears a noise and as she checks David’s room, she sees David fucking Sarah as they’re both moaning, telling Sarah how he loves her body and he needed her, this brings a tear to Alice’s eye as she thinks it was nothing to David but it soon turns into anger, she tells to herself that she doesn’t need him, she then goes to Peter’s room and you can imagine what happens
