Please not, nothing is more annoying as fapping noises and mindless moaning. Next thing is, close to no dev has a sense of volume, headphone users just get thier ears blown away. In such chases i always hit the mute button on my keyboard instantly and keep it so if i play the game again. That would be a shame, because some games improved with good amience sound and top background music.
Bro there are sound options, There is literally a separate slider for voice , sound effects, and music... Just because you are not a fan of sound effects doesn't mean it shouldn't be an option for others who are. I personally find it weird to not want audio with your porn but I understand some are different or live at home and are scared of people hearing things etc. So just present options for everyone. And as far as porn games go this is basically AAA we are on page 296 of replies lol.. the dev has a very successful patreon/subscribestar. I think adding sound effects would be a good next step to improve this already great product. YOU could mute that slider.
& that's where the difference lies.
This isn't porn. It's an adult story with explicit sex scenes.
I'm reading, I don't need audio, other than for ambience.
All real voice sex audio I've heard in these games has been disruptive to my immersion, so I've muted it.
Exactly my fellow man of culture, you muted it. I would never want you to not have the option to mute that portion of the audio in the settings. But for those of us who do want some more immersive audio, the option being there would be nice. I'm not going to say you guys shouldn't be able to play how you want, and I think its kind of selfish to close off the options of others(not saying YOU have done that but i see some people who do reply in that fashion sometimes) because you personally wouldn't use that audio. Happy gaming my friend.
Exactly my fellow man of culture, you muted it. I would never want you to not have the option to mute that portion of the audio in the settings. But for those of us who do want some more immersive audio, the option being there would be nice. I'm not going to say you guys shouldn't be able to play how you want, and I think its kind of selfish to close off the options of others(not saying YOU have done that but i see some people who do reply in that fashion sometimes) because you personally wouldn't use that audio. Happy gaming my friend.
I fully appreciate you wanting the dev to make his game the way you want it to be.
But that's not free & is quite a bit of extra work - meaning more people moaning about delays, etc.
If multiple paying customers were requesting it, I'm sure they'd consider it.
But, if it wouldn't bring much extra in the way of income, it's not really worth doing.
It is disingenuous to write off my suggestion as "want the dev to make his game the way you want it to be". I did not come on here and say yo dev I want you to make a female character names Lisa who works in a bar, and i want you to write a scene where shes in the ally and gets caught masturbating by a midget, and he blackmails her to have a 3some with him and his donkey. and then... you see what im sayin? What i suggested is a very common thing in many of these games and something that probably close to 50% of the gamers like the audio and prob about 50% dont..
I'm just making a suggestion I'm not holding a gun to the devs head saying do this or else. If he doesn't think it adds value or doesn't think it worth the time or resources he can keep it moving and ignore me. I don't get why some people are so abrasive towards others fetishes or desires like I never go in a thread and say NO don't do that I don't like it!
With that said I think its best we both move on we have said what we think and that's all we can really do. I'm gonna carry on with my day. Hope you have a great weekend
Bro I'm just making a suggestion I'm not holding a gun to the devs head saying do this or else. If he doesn't think it adds value or doesn't think it worth the time or resources he can keep it moving and ignore me. I don't get why some people are so abrasive towards others fetishes or desires like I never go in a thread and say NO don't do that I don't like it!
With that said I think its best we both move on we have said what we think and that's all we can really do. I'm gonna carry on with my day.
Nothing I've said has been, in anyway, "abrasive", about anything. No need to get upset.
I simply explained why, if it's not a popular suggestion with their paying supporters - which its current absence would suggest - then it's unlikely to happen.
It is disingenuous to write off my suggestion as "want the dev to make his game the way you want it to be". I did not come on here and say yo dev I want you to make a female character names Lisa who works in a bar, and i want you to write a scene where shes in the ally and gets caught masturbating by a midget, and he blackmails her to have a 3some with him and his donkey. and then... you see what im sayin? What i suggested is a very common thing in many of these games and something that probably close to 50% of the gamers like the audio and prob about 50% dont..
I'm just making a suggestion I'm not holding a gun to the devs head saying do this or else. If he doesn't think it adds value or doesn't think it worth the time or resources he can keep it moving and ignore me. I don't get why some people are so abrasive towards others fetishes or desires like I never go in a thread and say NO don't do that I don't like it!
With that said I think its best we both move on we have said what we think and that's all we can really do. I'm gonna carry on with my day. Hope you have a great weekend
I've yet to come across a VN that implements this type of audio well and I myself have no interest in it, but definitely respect the way you're going about suggesting it and handling the nay-sayers. You're absolutely right that people tend to get very abrasive against suggestions that do not suit them. It's very bizarre as if they feel they're going to lose something of value. Though, I wouldn't say everyone here so far has been that way.
I would never want you to not have the option to mute that portion of the audio in the settings. But for those of us who do want some more immersive audio, the option being there would be nice.
"But for those of us who do want" is quite precisely saying you'd prefer if the game was made to the specifics you want.
I have never once said you are wrong for wanting it. Stop being so unnecessarily sensitive/defensive.
I simply explained why it might not be likely to happen, unless paying supporters want it in numbers.
Bro there are sound options, There is literally a separate slider for voice , sound effects, and music... Just because you are not a fan of sound effects doesn't mean it shouldn't be an option for others who are. I personally find it weird to not want audio with your porn but I understand some are different or live at home and are scared of people hearing things etc. So just present options for everyone. And as far as porn games go this is basically AAA we are on page 296 of replies lol.. the dev has a very successful patreon/subscribestar. I think adding sound effects would be a good next step to improve this already great product. YOU could mute that slider.
And if you would be not busy fadepalming me 'cause of your butthurt and used that time to read and understand my post you would have noticed my point. That infamous slider you have mentioned is the complete mess about this. Close to no dev had a sense about volume, the fucking volume is always on 100% - really nice for a headphone user.
You get off when you hear moans and groans that don't match the situation? That's ok for me, who am i to judge...
The guy does it with the bitch slowly - because virgin and so - and cozy and the sound sounds like she is nailed by a jackhammer.
Really fitting my friend, really great, for sure.
The problem lies not in the sound but in the dev. Just a little fucking notification at the start of the game would be enough. At least for this guys who can read und understand the text read.
I've yet to come across a VN that implements this type of audio well and I myself have no interest in it, but definitely respect the way you're going about suggesting it and handling the nay-sayers. You're absolutely right that people tend to get very abrasive against suggestions that do not suit them. It's very bizarre as if they feel they're going to lose something of value. Though, I wouldn't say everyone here so far has been that way.
Sound IS important in a game, if done well. But not when the MC is busy yehaa a girl. Thats just annoying, when someone like this, the hub is the place to be... Chasing Sunsets, Summer's gone, Where it all begun are great examples of using sound. But not in h-scenes, not that SG would had anyone of this till now
As I have stated my request for something I personally would like (and is not a random uncommon feature or suggestion) and feel would improve the game if implemented correctly (and I have full faith this dev would do it right) - I am going to leave it at that. I'm not going to keep cluttering up this thread arguing with people who disagree its quite pointless. I respect that some (many even) others do not like that feature or feel it is implemented poorly on occasion. We are all adults (18+) right? So lets just keep it moving and have a good day.
Agreed. I like the use of audio for ambience/atmosphere, used to indicate building fear, or any emotion really.
Outside of that, the sex scene noises completely break my immersion. Usually because they sound so "porn" fake.
I'd rather my imagination makes them moan, over that.
As I have stated my request for something I personally would like (and is not a random uncommon feature or suggestion) and feel would improve the game, I am going to leave it at that. I'm not going to keep cluttering up this thread arguing with people who disagree its quite pointless. I respect that some (many even) others do not like that feature or feel it is implemented poorly on occasion. We are all adults (18+) right? So lets just keep it moving and have a good day.
Still no need to get so upset because others don't share your opinion.
No-one said you were wrong to hold it. I simply showed why it might be unlikely to be taken up.
Agreed. I like the use of audio for ambience/atmosphere, used to indicate building fear, or any emotion really.
Outside of that, the sex scene noises completely break my immersion. Usually because they sound so "porn" fake.
I'd rather my imagination makes them moan, over that.
Thats exactly my point. Its just disturbing hearing a bitch moan i a game and notice that the sound was ripped from a porn i have watched an hour earlier. No fun, that has happened to me. Immersion was complete out of the window for me. The prime expample of this was the game Welcome to Hell for me, not because of the used soundtrack that was used while a cutscene was runnig. I dont remember the track anymore only that it was from Nightwish, and holy cow that was so bad. The music has absolutly not fitted to the situation or the editting. IN. NO. FRIGGING. WAY.
Sound ist a might tool to enrich the game if used well, or can ruin it poorly used.
Whoa... Literally played this game from fresh to completed today all day with brief pauses. What a journey!
I find myself getting bored of the story, or there is something that makes no sense or doesn't blend in with rest of the game often lately in other games. Here? I even read the logs and codexes. Absolutely beautiful atmosphere, despite the violence and ugliness of this universe, but since it's to be expected in this scenario it only adds not ruins. I love that you still have "good" choices even in bad scenarios, even tho I am currently playing the "don't fuck with me" playthrough
I saw some posts get into heated arguments about sharing.. but I found no new sharing since few updates ago? You guys are weird. Just disable sharing then or make better choices lol. Personally I hope wife gets to play with some guests of the house, she is the most beautiful female character in this game for me and since husband spends increasingly more time away from home I hate for her to be so lonely..
It feels like every update the production quality increases, and for size of this game I am mind-blown at how much not only content there is, but content with various paths/outcomes/change-of-detail. Simply incredible craftmanship, this game is and will be in a lot of people Hall of Fame lists. Thanks to everyone supporting the project!
MidnightVT
Speaking from an entirely personal point of view, I have yet to find an AV game that wasn't HTML and using real porn clips, where the moaning and grunting were either done well/believable/didn't feel out of place or weird... more often than not they take me entirely out of the fiction/immersion, such as it is. But that's just me and your mileage obviously varies.
speaking not from a personal point of view: Z is very good with playing with his soundtrack and puts a lot of effort in ambient music, even for the sex scenes.
I think that the kind of sounds you are expecting are probably a bit disruptive to those music accompaniments, which doesn't make it necessarily undoable, but adds another layer of complexity that is of interest to only a fraction of the potential market.
That said, I can't exclude that some day in the future these extra sound effects might be added...but I expect it to be very much a "when the game is mostly done/the budget is high enough to do it really well and possibly do a whole voice over for the characters" type of deal. He does actually add the very rare and occasional sound bite, like the droplets of blood in a certain Fairy scene, or the sound of a gate or door being slammed open, more often than not in animations/cutscenes, for cinematic effect... but that's about it.
As of today, adding sexy noises during sexy scenes does not appear on the development planning log.
Speaking from an entirely personal point of view, I have yet to find an AV game that wasn't HTML and using real porn clips, where the moaning and grunting were either done well/believable/didn't feel out of place or weird...
Really? I find the moans and dirty talk and stuff in real porn a million times worse than the generic understated moaning in most games or animations. Not that the latter are great by any means, but definitely not as bad IMO.
Speaking from an entirely personal point of view, I have yet to find an AV game that wasn't HTML and using real porn clips, where the moaning and grunting were either done well/believable/didn't feel out of place or weird... more often than not they take me entirely out of the fiction/immersion, such as it is. But that's just me and your mileage obviously varies.
Well, a game I feel did sex sounds well is Solvalley School, it has animations that aren't looped and the audio track follows the movements of the animation.
I personally feel that giving the player the option to do so if they feel like it adds to the game. Some choices are obviously "bad", some are obviously "good", and some....yet to be revealed.
....
The problem with seasonal/episodic/however-you-want-to-call-them content for DS is ....
Choice
You can't please everyone with anything. You didn't give them choice they will complaint, you give them choice they will complaint too (too many choices, not enough choices, choices don't matter, choices only change the dialogue, choices only for sex variations and the list go on). My personal opinion on this matter, is that I feel it is counter-productive or pointless to give players choices that will undermine the game in terms of contents or theme, other kinds of choices are fair use. NO, I am not saying about the choices in this game specifically but generally speaking. Let me give (exaggerated) examples, say there is a story heavy game that gives the player a choice in the beginning (or can be updated in the preference) "Skip dialogues and jump to sex scene?" Yes/No. Players that pick "Yes" certainly did not play the game at all. One could argue that there are players who like that, they don't care about the narratives and characters but they just want to watch the scenes especially sexual scenes, mostly for recreational purposes. There is really no need for a developer to cater for such players because clearly they are not the intended audiences. The players already had the implicit choice to play or not to play the game in the first place.
Seasons/Episodes
I don't know if you (Zetan & the Desert Stalker production team) realized it or not but you have been consistently provides episodic releases. However, specific to DS it is actually called quest. There are main and side quests. Some are big, some are small. Big ones already been divived into multiple parts i.e. Quest X Part 1 and so on. In one way or another, you are doing it (of course improvements are always welcomed).
I like how these quests are in a way self-contained, isolated and not intermingled with the other quests but quests may have dependency (and/or sequence) with each other. Releasing this episodic quests gives flexibility in terms of development too, for example to meet deadline Quest Y Part 2 content can be cut short, which means next release Quest Y Part 3 will have slightly more contents than originally planned. If a quest originally planned to be short but can be streched out by adding more parts to it.
Here are some possibilities of exploiting the quest system (which can be applied to some quests NOT all quests) without the need for additional contents like renders and dialogues. I don't know how complex they are but at least I know they are possible.
1. Replay/Re-Live Completed Quests (in view mode)
Usually people just load save for this if they made a save in the first place. Replaying quests that have variations can help especially to unlock the Galllery scenes without having to replay a different path. Player can just be on one path, with as little saves as possible. The replay however should not change your game state, treats it like an extended Gallery Replay, the difference is that Gallery Replay is for scene but this is quest per se.
2. Restart an Ongoing Quests
You have an ongoing Quest Z Part 5 but then you wanted to change your decision back in Part 1, it would be fantastic to have that rewind button and start over (while maintaining the current game state and discarding/resetting the restarted quest state). If I load a save for Part 1, not only will I have to do Part 2 and so on, but all the other quests too (to get back to my current game state). I mean this is only possible if the quest is in isolation but have simple dependent on other quests.
As far as I am concerned, DS does have have too many variables to keep track of stuff, so it might not be overwhelming to do it. It does however add some coding time depending on how good coder the team is.
I hope I do get my points across although it might not have been worded correctly and explained clearly. Cheers.
