Six0

Active Member
Mar 22, 2019
847
2,198
IIRC the island itself has a libido boosting effect on the people living there.
Among the various other weird effects it has.
Oh yeah, forgot about that. :rolleyes:

That's one part of the story I prefer to ignore. Or pretend the effect isn't that strong and these people really are genuine perverts. Applied phlebotinum in porn only ever makes any given story unnecessarily cheesy. Why would you want to be the youngest person on an island full of adults and the only reason they want to fuck you is because of... magic. Instead of something more realistic like a sense of lawlessness and destitution.
 

Fluffy_one

New Member
Feb 10, 2021
2
4
> I asked this dude to get me the flowers that will surely let me fuck lady hale (and told him what I need the flowers for)
> Dude never comes back.
> Dude is now fucking lady hale
> If only I wasn't an NPC I could put 1+1 together and figure out he gave it to her himself.

like, my dude, just because the NPC did not personally SEE you give her the flowers he asked you to get her does not mean he can't figure it out.
And that is even putting aside the fact that flowers don't just evaporate, they are kept in a jar with water for a few days. so he would have probably seen those flowers in said water jar later on.
Just tested the route where you turn flowers into a mixture and dont fuck any women - Jack still betrays you, so I guess he IS a jerk after all :D
 

Fiberglasstask

New Member
Jan 6, 2024
5
8
Here's my theory on Lily. Though it's probably more like my personal "wishlist" of things wrong with her.

She's a closet pervert, one who's been trying to groom the MC. But at the same time, she's trying to resist her own urges. She doesn't like being slutty and despises slutty women. Since perverts can recognize other perverts, Lily knows what the other women on the island want. Young meat. Therefore, she doesn't just want to have the MC all to herself, she wants him to stay pure. That's her desire as his former caretaker and also because that's what turns her on the most. So when she sees him being horny or asking for sex during the day, it's annoying to her. Like she's not in the mood and doesn't want to be. Meanwhile, him having sexual experience is disappointing but also makes things easier. I think this is most evident when you finally do have sex with her. She's showing more frustration than anything. Telling you to hurry up and get it over with. To fuck her hard, because she might as well get off too. And if she cums before you, she's not going to finish you off. To me, these are signs of a woman who's either done sex work or was subjected to sexual abuse. Not as a child (necessarily), but as an indentured servant. Her former employer(s) must have fucked her several times. Enough for her to get used to it. That's why she likes it rough and how she can be so emotionally detached. Her body wants one thing while her mind wants another.
I'm guessing how Brutal she is in her exclusive route is because of both the Vitriol she has from the fact she doesn't want to feel like this and the fact that she knows she's the exclusive target of the mcs advances, therefor she can completely and harshly shut him back down into being 'pure' again and take her frustration on him being perverted out on him knowing he doesn't have sexual experience in that route and can dismiss him easier.

One thing I'm confused on is if the island is also having a "Libido effect" on the mc or not.
 

HeathenFilth

Active Member
Jan 10, 2022
501
935
I'm guessing how Brutal she is in her exclusive route is because of both the Vitriol she has from the fact she doesn't want to feel like this and the fact that she knows she's the exclusive target of the mcs advances, therefor she can completely and harshly shut him back down into being 'pure' again and take her frustration on him being perverted out on him knowing he doesn't have sexual experience in that route and can dismiss him easier.

One thing I'm confused on is if the island is also having a "Libido effect" on the mc or not.
I kind of wish that there isn't a libido effect going in, and it is just the people themselves being disinhibited because they all know they are basically 'native' now and rules and customs back home no longer apply. They just maintain a veneer of 'dignity' because it hasn't been long enough yet to drop all pretense.
 

Fiberglasstask

New Member
Jan 6, 2024
5
8
I kind of wish that there isn't a libido effect going in, and it is just the people themselves being disinhibited because they all know they are basically 'native' now and rules and customs back home no longer apply. They just maintain a veneer of 'dignity' because it hasn't been long enough yet to drop all pretense.
Yeah I get what you mean. If there is an outside influence effecting everybody the its kind of hard to know what their motivations actually are.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HeathenFilth
Nov 13, 2017
311
342
> I asked this dude to get me the flowers that will surely let me fuck lady hale (and told him what I need the flowers for)
> Dude never comes back.
> Dude is now fucking lady hale
> If only I wasn't an NPC I could put 1+1 together and figure out he gave it to her himself.

like, my dude, just because the NPC did not personally SEE you give her the flowers he asked you to get her does not mean he can't figure it out.
And that is even putting aside the fact that flowers don't just evaporate, they are kept in a jar with water for a few days. so he would have probably seen those flowers in said water jar later on.
I forgot, does he know mc is fuckin Lady Hale?

As for the flower, he doesn't know where they are exactly and asked us (a person less knowledgeable with flora than him, a gardener) to find them, after which we told him we couldn't get the flowers, and I just assumed it's in her personal room where he isn't allowed anw.

It was already weird that Jack was mad at this random dude for not finding these flowers for him so he could get his booty call, and the only reason he would rat out the guy who just saved his LIFE, TWICE, provided that he doesn't know the MC is actively fuckin Lady Hale, is that he is an asshole who holds a grudge. Or the libido enhancing curse(?) of the island makes ppl behave their worst, judging from MC's behavior as of late.

I know it serves as a consequence to the MC becoming a horndog and thinking with his dick, and it's not even unbelievable that there are people who are that petty irl, I'm just astonished at the audacity and pettiness of this mf.
 
Last edited:
Nov 13, 2017
311
342
...either done sex work or was subjected to sexual abuse. Not as a child (necessarily), but as an indentured servant. Her former employer(s) must have fucked her several times.
Honestly not that far fetched since MC and Alice's uncle (and Lily's previous master, iirc) is HEAVILY implied to have SA'd Alice
 
  • Like
Reactions: {0__0}

DougDimmadope

Newbie
May 21, 2020
84
747
Here's my theory on Lily. Though it's probably more like my personal "wishlist" of things wrong with her.

She's a closet pervert, one who's been trying to groom the MC. But at the same time, she's trying to resist her own urges. She doesn't like being slutty and despises slutty women. Since perverts can recognize other perverts, Lily knows what the other women on the island want. Young meat. Therefore, she doesn't just want to have the MC all to herself, she wants him to stay pure. That's her desire as his former caretaker and also because that's what turns her on the most. So when she sees him being horny or asking for sex during the day, it's annoying to her. Like she's not in the mood and doesn't want to be. Meanwhile, him having sexual experience is disappointing but also makes things easier. I think this is most evident when you finally do have sex with her. She's showing more frustration than anything. Telling you to hurry up and get it over with. To fuck her hard, because she might as well get off too. And if she cums before you, she's not going to finish you off. To me, these are signs of a woman who's either done sex work or was subjected to sexual abuse. Not as a child (necessarily), but as an indentured servant. Her former employer(s) must have fucked her several times. Enough for her to get used to it. That's why she likes it rough and how she can be so emotionally detached. Her body wants one thing while her mind wants another.
My theory is super far-fetched but I feel like she planned the shipwreck or has something to do with the island's tribes. she also has the same skin color and hair color as the island's native tribes. she keeps encouraging mc to look for his sister in native part of the island. would also explain why she seems to hate all the nobles/colonizers (lady hale, charlotte, etc) which is why she constantly says he shouldn't trust them.

she is also extremely secretive, always holding back her words.
 

Six0

Active Member
Mar 22, 2019
847
2,198
My theory is super far-fetched but I feel like she planned the shipwreck or has something to do with the island's tribes. she also has the same skin color and hair color as the island's native tribes. she keeps encouraging mc to look for his sister in native part of the island. would also explain why she seems to hate all the nobles/colonizers (lady hale, charlotte, etc) which is why she constantly says he shouldn't trust them.

she is also extremely secretive, always holding back her words.
The one thing I hope they don't do with Lily is have her be part of some secret organization or mastermind plot. I'm so tired of that trope and the telltale signs that come with it, like said person talking to themselves. Which Lily does.

ab.jpg ba.jpg

Even the MC is like, "I've had enough of this shit. Stop acting like you're a character in a JRPG." Speaking of which, there was another trope in this update that made me wonder if this was written by a Japanese person. And that's when the MC "charges" at Charlotte right before her sex scene. Using the godawful "Sorry, I can't control myself!" excuse we hear from every male character in a Japanese hentai when they push a woman down. Because their writers don't know of many other ways to convey passion outside of using force.
 

HeathenFilth

Active Member
Jan 10, 2022
501
935
And that's when the MC "charges" at Charlotte right before her sex scene. Using the godawful "Sorry, I can't control myself!" excuse we hear from every male character in a Japanese hentai when they push a woman down. Because their writers don't know of many other ways to convey passion outside of using force.
Yeah, I mentioned this sort of in my review of the game. It feels really weird. I wasn't sure if that was because I had been fucking everyone I could up until that point and my MC would have been more restrained had he still been a virgin. But I really don't like the pouncing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fiberglasstask
4.80 star(s) 73 Votes