As a counterpoint to this argument and as someone who just completed the game for the first time i think the whole dom sub thing is ridiculous and needs to go.
I could have agreed with you, but only if you were actually talking about this from a sexual point of view, like the person I was answering to did. From this point of view, and from it only, yes this sub/dom dynamic is useless, because it's not translated into the sex scenes.
But this is forgetting that, so far, it focus more on the MC personality; is he a leader or a follower. And the lack of translation of this dynamic into the sex scene only reinforce this reading. Veronica is the only girl that actually show signs of dominance in a sexual way, while no girls shown a sign of sexual submissiveness.
And it happen that this can possibly play a role later in the story; while the MC be able to oppose someone's agenda, or will he be too much of a follower for this?
You say it's designed that way since certain girls act a certain way but it would be much simpler if you could just have a normal relationship with these girls.
It's not even near to what I said.
What I said is that girls that are sexually dominant will not become sexually submissive, and that the opposite is also true.
Why the dev choose to base the whole game around this dom / sub thing is beyond stupid and will turn people off once the paths start to diverge.
This only apply for those who decided to pick an answer accordingly to its result, and not accordingly to the way they picture the MC. Yet, like they did it for it's sexual implication, they'll only leave if the sex scenes do not match their expectation. What mean that even if they don't actually get the dominant, or submissive, sex scenes implied by this dynamic, they will still stay if the said sex scenes are lewd enough for their liking.
For the others, those who decided that the MC will be this, or that, they'll not leave precisely because this divergence of path is the outcome they expect from their choices. All games that offer choices to the player have this kind of duality, this since the first game that offered choices to the player. Whatever it's being good or bad, loyal or chaotic, leader or follower, it's a slow story bending put into the hands of the players, and most like this. I'll even goes further, many on the adult gaming scene regret that so few games have it.
But your right, as of right now you can get all the content if you play as a switch and take both dom and sub points.
And, once again, it's not what I said.
I said that you can get all the content whatever you decided for the MC. Amina is dominant, but you can see the sex scene even if you decided to have a full dominant MC. The "(disabled)" after the choice only mean that you'll not get the points, and eventually flags, not that you can't pick this choice.
And, as I said, I don't know if it's a design choice, or if the dev don't know how to actually disable a choice.