so why give the power of protagonist to silas, when we could just as easily watch the events that happened to silas in a variety of ways that dont relegate him to MC. Considering some of the renders during Silas as MC are third person or bird eye view of Silas himself, it could easily have just been Silas reporting his mission while giving the reader/player visuals.
Oh I dunno, perhaps the dev just wanted to actually show Silas' story fully (with him actually roaming the places he goes to, describing fully what he sees and feels), instead of merely showing highlights/summary like you described in your "reporting mission" method?
Have you actually even thought about that? lol
The only reason Silas should be a protagonist is if the player can make Silas make choices against the Main Protags orders and wants. otherwise we are just watching Silas do what he was told to do by the actual protagonist. side characters get chapters and screen time, all the time without being consider protags.
where are you even getting this so-called "logic" from?
Silas is not a puppet of MC, he's MC's apprentice.
And while Silas believes MC and follows MC's orders, it is actually possible to shape him to take actions that MC may not necessarily take if good choice options are given (such as Zaton & Shani in Desert Stalker who are the primary & secondary protagonist in that game. You can shape Shani to have a bit of opposite morals to Zaton if the player chooses to).
So such a thing is not impossible.
Perhaps Silas may take an action in the future that MC would not take in same situation.
And what even are you referring to with the whole "watching Silas do what he was told to do by the actual protagonist." All MC gave to him in terms of instructions were "Go and spy on Falongor" and merely saying "If you get caught, I can't acknowledge you." (or something along those lines).
MC basically gave no instructions as to how Silas would go about his methods.
personally i dont care what dev calls him, but if we are being honest about it, for now, the people against it seem to have a point. which only last until silas actually influences game play via choices that actually effect gameplay
Disagree, cause I'll say this using example from Desert Stalker once again.
Yes, that game has choices (tons of choices actually), but regardless of how player chooses in terms of actions of secondary Protagonist Shani during her content, even if her actions contradict/go against what players have chosen against her father/mentor Zaton or not, it doesn't influence Zaton's arc as the primary main character, at least in major way.
So in the end, it's gonna depend on how the dev implements choices in the future Silas content.
Honestly, seeing how some folks are upset about this makes it seem like they think Silas is undermining Eliot (Primary MC of Elleria 1) or something, when that's not even the case
