I'm just at the begining, so maybe things will change, but ate you sure Emily is the protagonist? Because Nick sure get all the attention...
And about the choices... 1st guy we meet Emily thinks he's hot, whatever the player can think, then you need to choose a side between two guys, and after, all the female LI throw them to a side character (it's clearly NTR when he"s startig to tri to finger fuck a consentent LI)