VN Ren'Py Eruption Imminent [v0.5.1] [MorriganRae]

[flachelence]

I'll eat my own words if I'm wrong but from a writing perspective I can't imagine introducing a mystery and giving the solution to that mystery 10 minutes later. The blackmail thing seems like an arc, that it will play a small part across several updates before its resolved. So I would have a hard time believing the writer would so explicitly say "it's this character" and then 9 months later when Scooby and the gang pull the mask off the villain it turns out to be that character, there's no element of surprise or revelation. That's why red herrings exist to extend the mystery to give it intrigue. Although I guess it's hats off to the dev for writing a mystery that is getting this level of engagement.

 

[Ebonheart (FR)]

I'll eat my own words if I'm wrong but from a writing perspective I can't imagine introducing a mystery and giving the solution to that mystery 10 minutes later. The blackmail thing seems like an arc, that it will play a small part across several updates before its resolved. So I would have a hard time believing the writer would so explicitly say "it's this character" and then 9 months later when Scooby and the gang pull the mask off the villain it turns out to be that character, there's no element of surprise or revelation. That's why red herrings exist to extend the mystery to give it intrigue. Although I guess it's hats off to the dev for writing a mystery that is getting this level of engagement.

I think I pretty much agree with what you're saying, I don't really see a big plot really coming together at the moment. For the time being, the developer is content to give us some narrative leads for characters and to build up their dedicated story arcs. We'll have to wait and see where the developer takes the story. I hope he has some pleasant surprises in store for us in the plot department.

 

[Kontralta]

Ashe told her (like an eejit) in the line immediately previous, she just had to latch onto that.

Are you saying that she is so smart and cunning that she arranged blackmail, but she is so stupid that she spill the beans, not knowing what to answer, because she didn’t know that Fiona knew about it, and then she got lucky and Ashe helped her? It doesn't look real.
What Fiona would tell Delilah was as very expected and inevitable.

 

[Kukipett]

Well it's a nice story i like it and the models are great but just a question, how those futa reproduce??!!
The MC is a duplo, she has both sex but all other in the family are not, they just have a dick, so my question is how her mother gave birth to her, are we in a magical world where you find girls in roses or in a shobox someone lays in front of your door?

 

[Ebonheart (FR)]

Well it's a nice story i like it and the models are great but just a question, how those futa reproduce??!!
The MC is a duplo, she has both sex but all other in the family are not, they just have a dick, so my question is how her mother gave birth to her, are we in a magical world where you find girls in roses or in a shobox someone lays in front of your door?

There are females (fems) with female genitalia, futas with only male genitalia, and duplos with both reproductive organs in this fictional universe.
However, the 3 categories of people are referred to in the feminine most of the time, even if sexual orientations seem to exist (FutaxFem, FutaxFuta, FemxFem ?). Nevertheless, it's still not quite clear how everything works from my point of view.

 

[stahalle]

Well it's a nice story i like it and the models are great but just a question, how those futa reproduce??!!
The MC is a duplo, she has both sex but all other in the family are not, they just have a dick, so my question is how her mother gave birth to her, are we in a magical world where you find girls in roses or in a shobox someone lays in front of your door?

no they dont have all dicks. there are futas (only penis), duplos (both vag and penis) and normal woman. the mom and sister are normal. her best friend fiona is a futa and mc is a duplo. and her mother that died was a futa.

 

[Knight_of_the_lance]

With Patreon Tightening their TOS on blackmail, I can't see that plot line going to far in the sexual abuse way regardless of who the blackmailer is.

Spoiler: additional blackmail info from episode 4

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

An option to make the blackmail plotline more in line with Patreon TOS is to make it less sexual in nature. We are used to a certain kind of blackmail here on the forum because of the nature of the games we play, but most blackmails IRL use sex or some kind of financial document as material to force the blackmailed to perform actions unrelated to sex. If the blackmailer's end goal is not sex it might not be as a problem with Patreon. (I did not personally read those TOS) In term of story it might reshuffle the list of possible candidate as the blackmailer. There are also two other options in my head. the first is that the blackmailer morphs into an anonymous ally for Ashe as she helps her become the person she wants and the mention of threats disappear from the discutions overtime. The other option is that the blackmail stops out of the blue because the blackmailer would have gotten what they want by other means leaving that mystery to the players to solve. That last option I could see more as playing out in one of the paths and and not the others or for each path to have different clues.

If we go by motive for blackmail we can also make a list. Most people on it would be to get Ashe to get laid or to get in control of her anxiety. There are a few Outlier that we can guess. Also those reason might differ depending of the path we choose for Ashe making it more difficult to identify correctly. Hell with the pathing system, the blackmailer might not be the same person in each path.

Spoiler: list of motive

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Anyways, with the recent Patreon TOS enforcement this plotline is bound to either a short shelf life or to morphing into something else.

 

[TheLecher]

Well it's a nice story i like it and the models are great but just a question, how those futa reproduce??!!

If you didn't play the game, how do you know that it's a nice story?

 

[TheLecher]

Anyways, with the recent Patreon TOS enforcement this plotline is bound to either a short shelf life or to morphing into something else.

Possibly, but this remains to be seen. Fashion Business is still on Patreon after years of running a plot which is entirely centered around blackmail, so some games do fly under the radar. And the fact that this game is focused on futas may provide it with a bit of magical protection. Also, there's the possibility of a mass migration of support to SubscribeStar. MorriganRae wouldn't be the first developer to refuse to bow to Patreon and then bounce back from being kicked off the platform.

We'll have to wait and see.

 

[Knight_of_the_lance]

Are you saying that she is so smart and cunning that she arranged blackmail, but she is so stupid that she spill the beans, not knowing what to answer, because she didn’t know that Fiona knew about it, and then she got lucky and Ashe helped her? It doesn't look real.
What Fiona would tell Delilah was as very expected and inevitable.

People are claiming that Delilah is fixated on Ashe to the point of craziness. And intelligence, imagination, memory and focus are all factors that could contribute to her making a mistake. There is apparently a whole aspect of her life we don't interact with. Right now that kind of mistake does not make sense to you but if we had all the picture it might. And in the story Ashe is keeping stuff from Rachel so her thinking that Fiona told her and then later rationalizing it is on her only. Making Delilah a good candidate or a red hareng that some will be mad about if it is not her.

 

[Jafo]

Well it's a nice story i like it and the models are great but just a question, how those futa reproduce??!!
The MC is a duplo, she has both sex but all other in the family are not, they just have a dick, so my question is how her mother gave birth to her, are we in a magical world where you find girls in roses or in a shobox someone lays in front of your door?

I have never thought how they reproduce. But thinking about it Ashe has a wonderful dick which is long enough to make love with her own pussy?! Or with one of the other lovely ILIs

And the second question is even easier. How do you think, knowing that the mum of Ashe is fully female gave birth? I don't think anal.........

 

[Kukipett]

If you didn't play the game, how do you know that it's a nice story?

I played it but as i'm getting old i did not remember all the details, i though it was a futa world, i just started thie update and this went in my mind.

But well they are not futa as futa are supposed to have both, there are normal female and males look like female except for the dick.

 

[Hungover00]

With a new update out, it's time for me to review my previous suspect list for the blackmail plot. I won't retype the whole thing. Not much has changed. I mostly stand by all of my previous assessments, but there are a few changes.

Also, in my previous write-up, I forgot about Siri (the employee at the gym) and Luna (the gym customer who asked Ashe to help her snap some pics), so I'll be adding them. I'll also add Victoria (who has not yet appeared on screen), Kendra (Ashe's aunt who was introduced in this update, but hasn't yet appeared), Marita (Ashe's boss), and Jane (just to have all the named characters included).

As before, I'll put all of my thoughts behind spoiler tags.

Spoiler

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

That's it. Those are the changes to my list of suspects. I'll revisit the question again when there's more evidence of guilt or more grounds for suspicion.

Moved some things around, because it's awkward to quote from two different spoiler messages. Firstly, not reviewing Delilah after the new events that show she does know about Ashe's duplo status makes all your other work and conclusions more suspect. It's basically theory-crafting malpractice.

And the logic for Isabella being on the "definitely not" list is thin and dependant on a 19 year old being a perfect judge of character, and Isabella is a bitch towards Ashe. If she thought she could get away with it, I do think she would. And Rachel might be able to trust Isabella with her shit, but that doesn't mean that loyalty transfers to her sister. I personally think it's probably not Isabella because she'd just say it or make a big public deal about it some other way.

 

[Hungover00]

She could easily be a red herring, but I think the real red herring is the blackmail and not her suspicious nature. I don't think she was ever going to out Ashe. She was just hoping for some spank bank mats and thought it'd be a good way to make Ashe think she's there for her. Fiona implied pretty heavily when she was warning Ashe not to make a move on her that she's kinda crazy. The exact kind of crazy I'm totally down to stick my dick into as well.

Spied on her maybe. Pull Ashe's pants down to molest her during a sleepover maybe. I'm not sure what she did but I'm pretty sure it was a, illegal and b, something I'm into.

I think part of the evidence for this point is the blackmailer seemed satisfied with the crappy work out pics Ashe ended up sending. That could totally be Delilah. She could get weeks or months out of that, with her obsession. I do think the threat is also a bluff. As for finding out, I think the most likely way (if it turns out to be Delilah) is she spied on Ashe and Zoey having sex, and she had the right angles to see. After their seven minutes in heaven, Delilah would feel betrayed and could potentially push herself to call Ashe a duplo-slut. Plus, obviously she lied on the bus.

 

[Kontralta]

People are claiming that Delilah is fixated on Ashe to the point of craziness. And intelligence, imagination, memory and focus are all factors that could contribute to her making a mistake. There is apparently a whole aspect of her life we don't interact with. Right now that kind of mistake does not make sense to you but if we had all the picture it might. And in the story Ashe is keeping stuff from Rachel so her thinking that Fiona told her and then later rationalizing it is on her only. Making Delilah a good candidate or a red hareng that some will be mad about if it is not her.

If she is so obsessed to the point of madness, then she would not be able to act as calmly and calculatingly as that blackmailer. And if she can do that, then she would never make such a stupid mistake. You don't need to be a detective to understand this. How would she have gotten out of it if Ashe hadn't told her that Fiona knew her secret? People write that the whole game screams that this is Delilah, but I don’t see where the game screams about this, these are some unfounded speculations. So far, Delilah and the blackmailer look as different as possible. And if Delilah had been pretending, then again, she would never make such a stupid mistake.

 

[Hungover00]

If she is so obsessed to the point of madness, then she would not be able to act as calmly and calculatingly as that blackmailer. And if she can do that, then she would never make such a stupid mistake. You don't need to be a detective to understand this. How would she have gotten out of it if Ash hadn't told her that Fiona knew her secret? People write that the whole game screams that this is Deilala, but I don’t see where the game screams about this, these are some unfounded speculations. So far, Delilah and the blackmailer look as different as possible. And if Delilah had been pretending, then again, she would never make such a stupid mistake.

I'm trying to recall, what makes you call the blackmailer calm and calculating?

Also, competence in one area doesn't transfer to all areas, so theoretical mistakes could happen. Whatever competence you're seeing in the blackmailer would be in a controlled situation for them. They pick the time, have probably prepared, send the first message, etc. If we're talking about a hypothetical blackmailer-Delilah on the bus she isn't prepared, she ran into Ashe, let a slip of the tongue reveal she knew Ashe's secret, was fed the info that Fiona knows (but not how recently) and jumps on that to cover for her slip. Seems perfectly within the bounds of possibility.

 

[TheLecher]

I played it but as i'm getting old i did not remember all the details, i though it was a futa world, i just started thie update and this went in my mind.

But well they are not futa as futa are supposed to have both, there are normal female and males look like female except for the dick.

In this fictional universe, there are three genital configurations.

1. Femme - This is your female, equipped with a pussy, and capable of child-bearing.
2. Mono Futa - This is your dickgirl. She has a cock and balls, and no pussy. She gets femmes pregnant, and can't get pregnant herself.
3. Duplo Futa - This is the "true futa" for people who are sticklers about the genre. She has a cock, balls, and a pussy. In theory, she can both impregnate femmes and be impregnated by other futas, though this isn't certain. We're told in the game that one or the other set of equipment might not be useful for reproduction.

The MC is a duplo futa, meaning that she has the full array of genitals. So far, not counting a duplo influencer who appeared on the news and a duplo porn star, the MC is the only character in the story who has been revealed to be a duplo.

Moved some things around, because it's awkward to quote from two different spoiler messages. Firstly, not reviewing Delilah after the new events that show she does know about Ashe's duplo status makes all your other work and conclusions more suspect. It's basically theory-crafting malpractice.

I have addressed the developments with Delilah at length on the game's Discord server. I chose not to reproduce all of that here, because my bottom line conclusion, after discussing the new developments, is that Delilah is not the blackmailer. She hasn't moved either up or down on my list. If anyone is desperately curious about my thoughts on the new developments with her character, they can join the Discord and read what's been said there.

And the logic for Isabella being on the "definitely not" list is thin and dependant on a 19 year old being a perfect judge of character, and Isabella is a bitch towards Ashe. If she thought she could get away with it, I do think she would. And Rachel might be able to trust Isabella with her shit, but that doesn't mean that loyalty transfers to her sister. I personally think it's probably not Isabella because she'd just say it or make a big public deal about it some other way.

My decision to put Isabella on the "definitely not" list was not purely due to Rachel trusting her. I already made that clear. I don't accept that my reasons are "thin", just because you failed to parse them all.

Spoiler

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

 

[dolfe67]

There are multiple red herrings, Siri and Delila. Maybe one of them is the blackmailer, maybe not, but the writing is quite good

 

[Hungover00]

I have addressed the developments with Delilah at length on the game's Discord server. I chose not to reproduce all of that here, because my bottom line conclusion, after discussing the new developments, is that Delilah is not the blackmailer. She hasn't moved either up or down on my list. If anyone is desperately curious about my thoughts on the new developments with her character, they can join the Discord and read what's been said there.

My decision to put Isabella on the "definitely not" list was not purely due to Rachel trusting her. I already made that clear. I don't accept that my reasons are "thin", just because you failed to parse them all.

Spoiler

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Maybe add an asterisk and explain you've written about it elsewhere, because unless every reader here is also there, they wouldn't know. I'd say put a summary in, but it feels like you would find that offensive.

And I can 'parse' your logic, I just don't weigh them to the same extent to feel it deserves "definitely not" status. I also don't necessarily agree with your assumptions or conclusions, but that's a separate point that I don't feel like debating over.

 

[SerHawkes]

People are claiming that Delilah is fixated on Ashe to the point of craziness. And intelligence, imagination, memory and focus are all factors that could contribute to her making a mistake. There is apparently a whole aspect of her life we don't interact with. Right now that kind of mistake does not make sense to you but if we had all the picture it might. And in the story Ashe is keeping stuff from Rachel so her thinking that Fiona told her and then later rationalizing it is on her only. Making Delilah a good candidate or a red hareng that some will be mad about if it is not her.

Enough of a warning for me. Already have vietnam flashback ready to go ala AL.

Jokes aside, for me Del kinda moved up on the list in the sus department, mainly because of how she talked and acted on the bus. While there could be a chance Fiona did possible mention Ashe being a duplo, there is some measure of doubt there for me. I mean she just learned her bestie is a duplo, and totally ate her out. I doubt she would purposefully say anything, atleast intentionally. Maybe by accident possibly.

I honestly don't think Isabella is involved either, mainly because she would have known already and likely would have made Ashe's life hell more so than already. Also, as much as I am still kinda on the fence with, I still kinda suspect Officer Small Dick, mainly because she could use two phones and an alias. Vanessa Mom could very well be a high suspect, given connections and possible contacts.