LonerPrime
Well-Known Member
- Apr 9, 2018
- 1,130
- 4,390
- 448
Riveting discussion. Considering it's shown that Ash is severely traumatized over her father's passing in an accident- an event that is implied to have some connection to Ash, that leads to her having mental terror attacks, it's plausible that she might have developed a split personality. One that hides away the pain and other that takes control. Movies like The Beautiful Mind goes deep into this phenomenon albeit the root cause and effect are much different there than here. There is however one problem with this "alter ego" theory.
She is just not getting emails. She is actually talking in real time with the blackmailer. Now schizophrenics do tend to have memory blackouts but, these intervals are significant. They don't snap in and out of personalities in seconds. Even if the "Other One" has a phone she is using to converse with Ash and is able to switch in control at whim, it makes little sense that she is able to do all that so blatantly with people around.
Also, Ash's mother did see someone drop off the box with the anal plug. Granted she didn't see her face or any distinct features to make a positive ident, unless the Other One is really a demon capable of teleportation, it would be highly improbably for schizo Ash to both drop the box, leave and then somehow make it inside to her room without the mother noticing. So either Other One has an accompalice(very unlikely) or we are looking at another blackmailer.
She is just not getting emails. She is actually talking in real time with the blackmailer. Now schizophrenics do tend to have memory blackouts but, these intervals are significant. They don't snap in and out of personalities in seconds. Even if the "Other One" has a phone she is using to converse with Ash and is able to switch in control at whim, it makes little sense that she is able to do all that so blatantly with people around.
Also, Ash's mother did see someone drop off the box with the anal plug. Granted she didn't see her face or any distinct features to make a positive ident, unless the Other One is really a demon capable of teleportation, it would be highly improbably for schizo Ash to both drop the box, leave and then somehow make it inside to her room without the mother noticing. So either Other One has an accompalice(very unlikely) or we are looking at another blackmailer.
