My feelings too. I've just finished playing the latest update, and it seemed like it was the biggest - and possibly the best - yet. With each new scene with a girl, I seem to change my mind about who my favourite is. I think ATM Alex, Penny, Luna and Nova are in a four-way tie, with Nancy, Dalia and Annie not far behind.
If I have one minor criticism, it's that a few of the scenes are so dark - in the literal sense - that it's hard to see what is going on, and I'd sooner not mess about with the brightness control on my monitor.
It seems unlikely that Orion will turn out to be impotent, and so before long it looks like some of the girls are going to become pregnant, which could lead to some interesting complications.
I see people are discussing who would be the most heartbroken should Orion really die, but we all know that's not going to happen. It doesn't look good for being able to complete the quest he's currently on in time, though.
Because in the early stages of the game I didn't use the walkthrough, I found that Orion didn't have enough eternals to buy the polyjuice potion, so I hope that's not going to come back to bite me at some future point.