You have some points right. But that 2024 is probably 2023 awards because technically Eternum or SG didn't have any update in 2024. I like the story of Eternum, it doesn't have typically AVN story, it's pretty unique story. those 2-3 frame loop animations aren't unique, but they are on the right places. Caribdis use them in a unique way. His approach to HS/HS2 renders is good too, I don't think it's the best, but isn't mediocre either. So, it's a subjective opinion of every judge, it does0t have to be the best overall, but if you count the votes, it's the best scored...
We all have our own opinion on every game, but I still believe they voted good...