VN Ren'Py Eternum [v0.8.5 Public] [Caribdis]

4.80 star(s) 1,075 Votes
Discussion Reviews (1,075)
PervyParadox

PervyParadox

Member
Apr 26, 2022
415
1,264
jahall said:
I think the dev has been very clever in how he's handled it, so that Orion having sex with Nancy, Annie, Dalia or Penny will feel like incest but isn't.
Click to expand...
It would have been even more clever to just not have Nancy Dalia and Penny be related at all, just three women living together. They'd act exactly the same, and we'll all know what's really up, but it would have given Cari free reign to make all the scenes he wants with them.

To me, this self-censorship is the only thing that's really disappointing about Eternum. I mean having scenes with Nancy, Dalia, and Penny together should be a given and the fact it's never going to happen is very upsetting.
 
  • Like
  • Angry
Reactions: BTungsteno, ChipLecsap, Bobolkich and 1 other person
dante4ever

dante4ever

Newbie
Dec 9, 2020
36
26
guys in once in a lifetime, the protagonist at the end have sex with both stepsisters. so if it is the modus operandi of Caribdis, i am not surprised if Orion will have sex scene with Dalia Penny and Nancy
 
Lyosta

Lyosta

New Member
Jun 27, 2022
1
1
Another masterpiece! :D NSFW aside, story is great with LOL plot here n there , every character is kinda unique, and the comedy is absolutely hilarious xD. I say it's an upgrade from Once in a Lifetime (but it's an absolutely good game too, try if haven't) but sadly OiaF placed at no. 3# for me (NFSW 3D Novel Game). I still haven't decide which will be the 1# between Eternum or Projeckt Passion (Another masterpiece NSFW aside) cus I also love the content and humour too. Much support
 
  • Like
Reactions: Finuee
PervyParadox

PervyParadox

Member
Apr 26, 2022
415
1,264
sexypeanut said:
But that would make 0 sense with the story
Click to expand...
Nancy is a babysitter. Have her be the nanny of Dalia and Penny as well as Orion. Once they're adults, they come live with her, like Orion. Everything makes sense, even the flashbacks. Cari would then be free to do whatever scene he'd wants.
Zegion101 said:
I appreciate Cari for not exploiting such loopholes. The Carter's relationship would've felt so cheap otherwise
Click to expand...
What feels cheap is having teasings of scenes between Nancy, Dalia, and Penny, and knowing you'll never get those not because the dev doesn't want to do them, but because of stupid rules that have nothing to do with the characters or the story.

Changing this single thing wouldn't feel cheap because Cari could make their relationship works. Even if, on paper, they wouldn't be family members, they'll still act like they are. This would literally just give more creative freedom to Cari, and potential hot scenes for us. These kinda of loopholes are the only weapon we have against stupid rules, unfortunately.
 
  • Like
  • Angry
Reactions: Magnumhawaii and ChipLecsap
sexypeanut

sexypeanut

Well-Known Member
Jun 30, 2020
1,956
3,134
PervyParadox said:
Nancy is a babysitter. Have her be the nanny of Dalia and Penny as well as Orion. Once they're adults, they come live with her, like Orion. Everything makes sense, even the flashbacks. Cari would then be free to do whatever scene he'd wants.

What feels cheap is having teasings of scenes between Nancy, Dalia, and Penny, and knowing you'll never get those not because the dev doesn't want to do them, but because of stupid rules that have nothing to do with the characters or the story.

Changing this single thing wouldn't feel cheap because Cari could make their relationship works. Even if, on paper, they wouldn't be family members, they'll still act like they are. This would literally just give more creative freedom to Cari, and potential hot scenes for us. These kinda of loopholes are the only weapon we have against stupid rules, unfortunately.
Click to expand...
Why would Dalia and Penny go live with Nancy if they had their own parents? They are FROM Kredon - they wouldn't need to live with her. Orion and Annie are living at Nancy's because they don't have family there.
Caribdis wouldn't retcon the story like that just to make the characters being able to fuck together. You can wait for when he releases the character cards and then use HS2 to make them do whatever you want.
 
  • Like
Reactions: yakfqww, jahall, Markel100 and 1 other person
PervyParadox

PervyParadox

Member
Apr 26, 2022
415
1,264
e6mill said:
Or he could not fix that which ain't broke...
Click to expand...
But it is broken.
Cari wanted to make scenes with them. It is teased numerous times. People would love to have scenes between them.
Patreon's shitty policy broke it.
And it could literally be fixed with some little dialogue tweaks and two name changes. It's not ideal, but it would be the only good solution.

Anyway, I'm just ranting. Pretty sure Cari won't listen to me anyway and that's just too bad.

Just getting tired of people shrugging it off because "it is what it is" like it's normal. Come on people, be a little more rebellious than that. Get a little angry about shitty policies ruining creative freedom at least, sheesh.
 
  • Like
  • Angry
Reactions: Magnumhawaii and ChipLecsap
Dorfnutter

Dorfnutter

Engaged Member
May 21, 2017
3,906
23,200
PervyParadox said:
Nancy is a babysitter. Have her be the nanny of Dalia and Penny as well as Orion. Once they're adults, they come live with her, like Orion. Everything makes sense, even the flashbacks. Cari would then be free to do whatever scene he'd wants.

What feels cheap is having teasings of scenes between Nancy, Dalia, and Penny, and knowing you'll never get those not because the dev doesn't want to do them, but because of stupid rules that have nothing to do with the characters or the story.

Changing this single thing wouldn't feel cheap because Cari could make their relationship works. Even if, on paper, they wouldn't be family members, they'll still act like they are. This would literally just give more creative freedom to Cari, and potential hot scenes for us. These kinda of loopholes are the only weapon we have against stupid rules, unfortunately.
Click to expand...
I mean, that's well and good. Just one tiny problem tho...

Screenshot_20250301_044258_Discord.jpg

Yeah, good luck trying to convince the guy to do a rewrite just to accomodate those scenes, especially this far into the story.
 
PervyParadox

PervyParadox

Member
Apr 26, 2022
415
1,264
sexypeanut said:
Why would Dalia and Penny go live with Nancy if they had their own parents? They are FROM Kredon - they wouldn't need to live with her. Orion and Annie are living at Nancy's because they don't have family there.
Caribdis wouldn't retcon the story like that just to make the characters being able to fuck together. You can wait for when he releases the character cards and then use HS2 to make them do whatever you want.
Click to expand...
Why would Axel be blonde and not have black hair ? Why Kredon is called Kredon ? Why this, why that. You're just fishing for details. Dalia and Penny going to live with Nancy is very easy to justify: their own parents leave, maybe they're shitty parents, maybe it's just closer to the school and the university, maybe they just know each other well so they want to live together. There's tons of possible explanation.
Dorfnutter said:
I mean, that's well and good. Just one tiny problem tho...

View attachment 4597602

Yeah, good luck trying to convince the guy to do a rewrite just to accomodate those scenes, especially this far into the story.
Click to expand...
I know, I'm not expecting Cari to change anything. Although like I said a few dialogue tweaks with those changes made into the "official" version would just be enough. There's literally just two names to change and some dialogues, but it has to be done by the dev for it to be official.

I'm just saying, this is a shame.
 
  • Like
  • Angry
Reactions: Magnumhawaii and ChipLecsap
Maviarab

Maviarab

I will have the penne all'arrabiata
Donor
Jul 12, 2020
12,053
29,336
PervyParadox said:
But it is broken.
Cari wanted to make scenes with them. It is teased numerous times. People would love to have scenes between them.
Patreon's shitty policy broke it.
And it could literally be fixed with some little dialogue tweaks and two name changes. It's not ideal, but it would be the only good solution.

Anyway, I'm just ranting. Pretty sure Cari won't listen to me anyway and that's just too bad.

Just getting tired of people shrugging it off because "it is what it is" like it's normal. Come on people, be a little more rebellious than that. Get a little angry about shitty policies ruining creative freedom at least, sheesh.
Click to expand...
PervyParadox said:
Why would Axel be blonde and not have black hair ? Why Kredon is called Kredon ? Why this, why that. You're just fishing for details. Dalia and Penny going to live with Nancy is very easy to justify: their own parents leave, maybe they're shitty parents, maybe it's just closer to the school and the university, maybe they just know each other well so they want to live together. There's tons of possible explanation.

I know, I'm not expecting Cari to change anything. Although like I said a few dialogue tweaks with those changes made into the "official" version would just be enough. There's literally just two names to change and some dialogues, but it has to be done by the dev for it to be official.

I'm just saying, this is a shame.
Click to expand...
5ywbmV.gif
 
  • Haha
Reactions: LaterGater, Finuee, ChipLecsap and 4 others
mike12013

mike12013

Member
Oct 3, 2024
427
728
Is there no workarounds he could do? Have the scene in the game, but disabled, download a file from his actual website that activates it? or are patreon THAT strict?
 
  • Disagree
Reactions: ChipLecsap
e6mill

e6mill

Engaged Member
Aug 4, 2022
3,335
6,615
mike12013 said:
Is there no workarounds he could do? Have the scene in the game, but disabled, download a file from his actual website that activates it? or are patreon THAT strict?
Click to expand...
Why? You are aware that not everyone on Earth has an incest kink, right? (I'm personally not especially against it, but I don't get people who insist it needs to be built into every story & VN.)
 
  • Like
Reactions: jahall, Finuee, suntzu and 5 others
mike12013

mike12013

Member
Oct 3, 2024
427
728
e6mill said:
Why? You are aware that not everyone on Earth has an incest kink, right? (I'm personally not especially against it, but I don't get people who insist it needs to be built into every story & VN.)
Click to expand...
Well aware. I don't like it when it's related to the MC but sisters or whatever are fine to me. Only one of my top 10 VNs have incest and even then it's not known at the time of the scene.

That's why i suggested a completely optional file that reactivates the scene, im hardly sat here saying a VN that i love, sucks because it doesn't have incest
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
4.80 star(s) 1,075 Votes