Dorfnutter
Forum Fanatic
- May 21, 2017
- 4,300
- 26,930
- 745
Then you should've done that in the first place instead of basically countering "trust me bro, I know what I'm talking about" and sounding like a privileged elitist who thinks he already knows everything about how the world works and anyone who says otherwise is just flat out wrong.Are sure I'm not able to show statistics which prove my point?
Imagine thinking that a player being locked on two choices in a porn game whose author has a story to tell is remotely comparable to a dropout who stopped schooling because of factors beyond their control or factors that force them to choose not going to school because the alternative (continuing to go to school) is life-threatening or has actual negative consequences from an economic and social perspective."But sure, let's blame thosestudentsplayers who were forced todrop outbecause of factors that they have no control of."
I'm sorry but I couldn't help.
With that kind of mentality, maybe it was a mistake expecting a decent argument from you.
Except if he did that the pacing would've slowed to a crawl as far as Nancy's arc is concerned. Remember, we have 7 LIs (8 if Calypso ends up being a love interest in the future). That means, aside from the main storyline, we have 7-8 separate storylines to go through that touches upon Orion's and the LI's romance progression in both the real world and Eternum. If we lock Nancy in a yoga route while we leave the rest of the LI's progressing as-is then she'll end up having the most uninteresting route out of all of them (unless you REALLY like yoga).In my opinion the greatest issue with that scene is the timing: Caribdis has dismissed the entire subplot in a single yoga lesson and with few dialogues to justify the Orion's action, while he should have spent more time (three or four yoga lessons), to achieve the same ending. In this way he could have described in a more detailed way the true nature of that guy, his true intentions with Nancy and doing so, he could have make the players more involved in the Orion's feeling that he must act to protect Nancy from that womanizer. Moreoveer Caribdis could have spent that time to prepare in a better way the punchline: the intervent of the repeaters.
And right from the start the game's already shown to be fast-paced as far as plots and subplots go, so Nancy's would end up being an outlier compared to the rest. Had Caribdis chosen to do a slow-burn story, then maybe, MAYBE your issues with Nancy's yoga subplot would be addressed. But given that he seems to be trying to rectify two of the major issues about OIAL (that being not every LI got a decent amount of screentime and the issue about the slow pacing) and that even now some people are complaining that the story is a bit slow (like, go back to the past few pages, there's actually someone who's asking if the pacing is going to stay the same) EVEN if it's noticeably sped up compared to his past game, then yeah, can you even blame the guy?
Last edited: