Sarkath
Active Member
- Sep 8, 2019
- 547
- 949
- 245
The iterations were a fraction of the size of FS, and it's basically impossible to tell what an engine's breaking point is going to be unless you actively push against it. So far FS seems to be the only game (out of possibly thousands of IF titles that have used Inform 7 since its release in 2006) that has managed to kill the compiler this badly, and even then it took over a decade for it to become large enough to do so. There are some things you simply can't plan for, and this absolutely is one of them. I also don't think they have any actual programmers (if they did, the Godot port would have probably seen much more noticeable progress) so well…here we are.Technical Difficulty always happens. But it's devs job to solve them.
The iterations came before FS, is like experiments created for FS, which were moved on pretty quick.
But that's not what's happening to current FS.
I mean, just for context, I'm a fairly seasoned developer at this point (both professionally and personally) and sometimes it can still be tough to predict how well a from-scratch design is going to scale, even after doing your damnedest, running simulations, etc. Writers who just wanna make a game using an existing engine or framework generally don't even consider things like that because they tend to just trust the tech. Regardless of which camp you fall into, trying to plan for unknown situations that can happen a decade down the road is a borderline impossible, unenviable task. There's a reason veteran software engineers are worth so much money, after all.
I can't speak for their intentions with the recent Patreon shifts, but considering how much of the writing seems to be commissioned, coupled with the fact that their funding has been on a steady decline, coupled again with the technical issues, yeah, I don't see things ending well unless something changes. I mean, I highly doubt they just woke up one morning and said, "Alright, time to Blackgate this shit!" given their history, and at this point I'm still willing to give them the benefit of the doubt, at least through the first half of 2025.