To be fair (
to be faiiiiiir) Gabby had more love path stuff, up to this point. And with girls departing on the dark path, the love/grey paths will have more content in the longterm. The only love interests that haven't had a (mostly) equitable amount of light/dark content are Viola and Pepper. One's an ultra-shy virgin, and the other was explicitly designed to be the tsundere, make-you-work-for-it archetype. So, I wouldn't really expect them to.
Also, there is a reason so much 'story' porn uses darker elements. If you have five minutes to set up a story which is meant to lead to sex, the easiest route there is through duplicity, coercion, etc.
- "Well, I don't have any modeling work for you, but if you were interested, I have another type of work available.."
- "Well, I have you on camera shoplifting, so unless you want me to call the police.."
- "Well, I know we just met, but let's fuck and watch as this blossoms into a beautiful relationship.."
One of these things is not like the other. Moreover, if I
do have a girl immediately fuck the player, or come on super strong, she tends to get a poor reaction/slut-shamed/not viewed as 'relationship material.' Everyone has their own standards, of course. But, I've said it before: Gabby would have gotten sex content wayyyyy back in Chapter 2, if several people didn't spook me with their reactions to Nicki's scenes in Chapter 1. There was a real vibe of, "We've already done everything with Nicki, so I guess her story's over.."