NewTricks

Forum Fanatic
Nov 1, 2017
5,405
11,815
823
the dev of that game wanted to make it longer , so it does say it found a big playerbase , dark games are very niche , but they do have a very loyal fans , and seen dev's still make profit while being banned from here (f95zone) , and patreon , let alone be in steam...but then again , we do have 2 versions Friends Indeed can be considered fine for steam.
I hate to say it, but since Steam is so finicky, it might be best for Neon to only submit Friends Indeed and let word of mouth about a more intense version drive traffic to his Subscribestar. It sucks, but it is the better business decision in the long run.
 

Joshy92

Message Maven
Mar 25, 2021
14,023
35,719
967
I hate to say it, but since Steam is so finicky, it might be best for Neon to only submit Friends Indeed and let word of mouth about a more intense version drive traffic to his Subscribestar. It sucks, but it is the better business decision in the long run.
He can just put Friends in Need on there, with most stuff locked behind the patch.
 

soldano

Member
Jan 29, 2018
354
666
244
But we have no idea about the script yet. Neon is adding another section between 1 and 2 and has been going back and making tweaks to the story since he finished the revised chapter 1. So we haven't actually read the script that everyone is complaining about. Also the people who keep coming back, proclaiming the game dead and "quitting" (especially the ones who do it multiple times) are just trolls, not critics.
Well, that's a good straw man. Who's talking about the people who say they're leaving the game? What I said is that there are a lot of people who didn't like the remake, and I did so by responding to a user who said that everyone had to agree that all the game's updates have been quality. And that's what I deny. No, not everyone has to agree with that. In fact, there are plenty of arguments to argue otherwise. Does that mean there can't be many people who think the game is excellent? No, of course not. For me, this game was the best on this site for a long time. But then things started to change. The game's tone shifted. Some will like it more, others less. I don't like it, frankly. And that's what I criticize.
As I've said many times, the game reaches its narrative zenith at dinner with Ashe. That's its prime. From there, it had its ups and downs. Until the remake, which destroyed some of the game's best narrative elements. If someone enjoys it, that's fine. But if someone criticizes it, that's fine too. Let's not be sectarian.
 

NeonGhosts

Well-Known Member
Game Developer
Mar 20, 2019
1,380
17,430
698
He can just put Friends in Need on there, with most stuff locked behind the patch.
Yurp, this is the route I plan to take. I’ll most likely include the corruption content in the Steam build, and omit the dark path. I also need to look at some stuff around Mason. I’m not sure if I’ll run afoul of any rules around hate speech, etc. even though the story is ultimately sympathetic to Mason’s experience.

But the nice thing about having a multi-route game, where all the sex can be avoided, is that I could basically trim out every ero scene and still have an entirely playable story.
 

DETROIT123_io

Member
Apr 16, 2023
200
203
62
The remade Ch.1 will be integrated into the main game and it will continue from Ch.11. Neon didn't do the artwork on the original Ch.1, so he wanted to re-do it to match the rest of the game.
okay I played this game long time ago and loved it . Did the dev change?
 

DETROIT123_io

Member
Apr 16, 2023
200
203
62
Well, that's a good straw man. Who's talking about the people who say they're leaving the game? What I said is that there are a lot of people who didn't like the remake, and I did so by responding to a user who said that everyone had to agree that all the game's updates have been quality. And that's what I deny. No, not everyone has to agree with that. In fact, there are plenty of arguments to argue otherwise. Does that mean there can't be many people who think the game is excellent? No, of course not. For me, this game was the best on this site for a long time. But then things started to change. The game's tone shifted. Some will like it more, others less. I don't like it, frankly. And that's what I criticize.
As I've said many times, the game reaches its narrative zenith at dinner with Ashe. That's its prime. From there, it had its ups and downs. Until the remake, which destroyed some of the game's best narrative elements. If someone enjoys it, that's fine. But if someone criticizes it, that's fine too. Let's not be sectarian.
What happened ? Is this game not dark anymore ? What do you mean by tonal shifts and what narrative changes was done? I am coming to this game after a long time , Please get me up to date
 

Simpgor

Well-Known Member
Apr 18, 2020
1,205
3,346
428
What happened ? Is this game not dark anymore ? What do you mean by tonal shifts and what narrative changes was done? I am coming to this game after a long time , Please get me up to date
Considering they've been on this exact thing for at least days now im sure you are going to get a very unbiased answer. Why there still here after 6+ months of the game going down hill (multiple updates) is anybodies guess :HideThePain:

Real answer: chapter 1 was remade, changes are not universally liked (realationship between Nicki and Guy)......but the poster you are quoting says issues started waaaaay back when ashe and Guy last hung out, there was never any foreshadowing to a "bigger bad guy" (drug dealer), and a lot of other things that would have made sense to bring up when they happened instead of now :KEK:
 

DETROIT123_io

Member
Apr 16, 2023
200
203
62
Considering they've been on this exact thing for at least days now im sure you are going to get a very unbiased answer. Why there still here after 6+ months of the game going down hill (multiple updates) is anybodies guess :HideThePain:

Real answer: chapter 1 was remade, changes are not universally liked (realationship between Nicki and Guy)......but the poster you are quoting says issues started waaaaay back when ashe and Guy last hung out, there was never any foreshadowing to a "bigger bad guy" (drug dealer), and a lot of other things that would have made sense to bring up when they happened instead of now :KEK:
What about the darkness? is the game getting soft?
 

Dessolos

Post Pro
Jul 25, 2017
20,036
28,313
936
I tried the remake of Ch1 now, and I like that you flesh out some parts, but I think the initial sex scene with Nicki is worse. I miss the part where you paint on her and take more photos etc. :p
Not for me cause I never go that route in the old version. As a Good path player it's improved for me. I hated having to give Nicki money and getting sex because of it. Now the way it's handled on that path doesn't feel like it's a transaction but rather something romantic and guy is offering because she is a friend in need of help.
 

armond

Engaged Member
Apr 26, 2020
2,422
9,789
678
Not for me cause I never go that route in the old version. As a Good path player it's improved for me. I hated having to give Nicki money and getting sex because of it. Now the way it's handled on that path doesn't feel like it's a transaction but rather something romantic and guy is offering because she is a friend in need of help.
It's called a
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 

PHIL101-YYouPPHard

Well-Known Member
Jan 11, 2022
1,208
2,601
386
Let me give you an example:
Imagine you're watching a traditionalist film and, suddenly, halfway through the film, without any foreshadowing, all the characters in the film turn out to be aliens. Can you like that? Yes, of course. Taste is a personal and subjective thing (since it depends on the subject). However, objectively (since it depends on the object), that's a mistake in the narrative structure. Why? Well, because the plot needs to be coherent, and if you haven't foreshadowed that this could happen in the first act, it doesn't make any sense for it to happen in the second.
Truly, surprising people like that is cheap and very low-level. Bad Hollywood movies tend to do that. Why? Because most people don't give a shit. And that's fine. If it's fun, it's fine. But if someone points at you and says, "Hey, that's a script flaw," then they're also right. Does that mean you have to stop liking the movie? No, of course. But if you tell me that script is well-made, I'm going to laugh at you. And rightly so.
That's not a good comparison, and that's not a mistake in the narrative structure for FiN. You go around making moral choices about sex and money throughout the game, and then an antagonist, whose presence and effects on the lives of others has been sprinkled throughout the story through various clues and hints, makes their debut.. and their theme is.. the worst horrible acts one can do with sex... and money.

I'm not trying to argue that your opinion of disliking the plot turn is wrong, btw. I get people not liking it, I mean it's always subjective and some people don't want this kind of stuff in their erotic VN. But, your post-hoc reasoning about it is a misfire, though, especially when you try to argue that there's something objectively wrong about it because there just isn't.

And, side note: I've seen a few films where it starts in one place and then totally switches the kind of film it is ~mid-way through and I still enjoyed them. Take From Dusk Till Dawn, for example (I'm sure there are better examples out there, but this is all I could think of for now :LOL:). Obviously, this film isn't a porn VN, and obviously it's subjective and a lot of people don't like it, but my only point is there are examples where big narrative/tonal switches can work and are well-received by many (maybe not the majority) and, in fact, maybe are kind of the point (it makes for an interesting watching experience). But, again, that's not at all what FiN has done.
 

ename144

Engaged Member
Sep 20, 2018
3,740
15,524
681
That's not a good comparison, and that's not a mistake in the narrative structure for FiN. You go around making moral choices about sex and money throughout the game, and then an antagonist, whose presence and effects on the lives of others has been sprinkled throughout the story through various clues and hints, makes their debut.. and their theme is.. the worst horrible acts one can do with sex... and money.

I'm not trying to argue that your opinion of disliking the plot turn is wrong, btw. I get people not liking it, I mean it's always subjective and some people don't want this kind of stuff in their erotic VN. But, your post-hoc reasoning about it is a misfire, though, especially when you try to argue that there's something objectively wrong about it because there just isn't.
Obviously taste is subjective, but I would argue the game went from focusing on the MC and how his decisions affected those around him, to focusing on Lucien and how the MC measures up to him. The fact that Chapter 10 was bookended with a newly introduced, likable character purely to play up the dramatic irony as she inadvertently falls into Lucien's clutches shows just how big a presence Lucien has become overnight.

I know Neon believes a hero is only as good as his villain, but I think he's taking that metaphor way too literally. Prior to Lucien, the MC was effectively his own villain because of how different the story was depending on whether he broke bad rather than becoming a genuine philanthropist. Now it's about how he deals with our resident supervillain. The fact that Lucien's introduction is so tightly tied into Risa's personal storyline just makes it feel that much more intrusive on what used to be the MC's story.

Personally, I consider this change both discordant with the early game and and entirely unwelcome. You and many other disagree, which is certainly your prerogative. But that doesn't invalidate our reasoning for disliking the change.
 

Pixillin'

Well-Known Member
Oct 8, 2024
1,906
2,386
341
Obviously taste is subjective, but I would argue the game went from focusing on the MC and how his decisions affected those around him, to focusing on Lucien and how the MC measures up to him. The fact that Chapter 10 was bookended with a newly introduced, likable character purely to play up the dramatic irony as she inadvertently falls into Lucien's clutches shows just how big a presence Lucien has become overnight.

I know Neon believes a hero is only as good as his villain, but I think he's taking that metaphor way too literally. Prior to Lucien, the MC was effectively his own villain because of how different the story was depending on whether he broke bad rather than becoming a genuine philanthropist. Now it's about how he deals with our resident supervillain. The fact that Lucien's introduction is so tightly tied into Risa's personal storyline just makes it feel that much more intrusive on what used to be the MC's story.

Personally, I consider this change both discordant with the early game and and entirely unwelcome. You and many other disagree, which is certainly your prerogative. But that doesn't invalidate our reasoning for disliking the change.
I don't really care that much about Lucien one way or the other. I still like my idea of hiring someone to remove Lucien as a problem, exfiltrate any girls there and torch his operation but Neon said no. You have to remember though that (unless they know about the patch) people on Patreon and people on Steam are largely playing a different game where Guy isn't really his own enemy, at least not nearly to the same extent. Maybe Neon wanted to give them a decent baddie to deal with.
 
4.50 star(s) 248 Votes