Hm, i choose dark or romantic depending on character.
Nikki - can't stand her so dark path, well she run away...hopefully the MC learned from his mistake and is properly chaining them going forward.
Gabby - don't really like or dislike her, but the hope of some good racial/slave ''play'' makes me choose dark path and i have no interest in any romantic path with her.
Pepper - cam whore, get's dark path by default.
Ashe - Only the best for her, so romantic + rolleplay
Mason - My MC is busy making sure she will become a girly girl and sees herself as such, but no humiliation....so i'm usure if that counts as dark path
Carolina - is nice and i like her daughter, so she get's the romantic path
Brittani - i like her, romantic path, curious if she will get along with Ashe
Viola - she is sweet, clearly romantic path
Cassie - i'd want to say romantic path, her being the sister...but, if she is some annoying/spoiled/slut/brat, full on dark path with no remorse
Risa - undecided, but tending towards dark path
Alex - undecided, but so far i like her
Wren - don't care, but would be fun if can take that prosthesis
Maddison - undecided