I actually want her story to go the other way. She already has an established character as a villain with no compassion.
I don't want a redemption arc. I want a story where:
1) She's not the good guy. It's not like Rye, she never loves you. But you continually show up to her even though she doesn't want anything to do with you. She just fucks you and throws you away. In the end you convince her to keep you as a pet because you can make her feel real good.
2) You convince other futa to hold her down and let you rape her. And you might literally be the first male to have ever penetrated her. This could even be the side ending in another love route. Look I just want 1 route to end in maledom okay? Not every route, but in a world like this it would be nice to have a male truly dominate a futa. Especially if she's normally a dominating bitch. Abbess Gretchen was a taste of that. I want the full meal.
Given Renee's character, I think having her be a bad end in other love routes is a really good idea. I don't want everyone to secretly have a good heart. Some people are broken.
I disagree. Renee only hates males and I would argue even has a reason. She's been proven to love her daughters and even loved her husband before he cheated.
1) We already have plenty non-redemption arcs, its basically every bad end. Hell Rye has like 5 on her own. It just proves to me that given the game's context "bad" characters make routes shorter and less substantial. It's basically just "mean futa binds male unfairly, keeps being mean to him" and we have plenty of that. The devs even gave a prolonged "bad" route with the valentine's update and people complained about how bad it was. I don't see the sense in going through all the trouble to write and code and art a long route for someone like Rye that is in essence more of the bad ends she already has. She only even starts not being a total asshole halfway through her route.
That story might work with another futa but I can't see it with Renee. If she doesn't like a male she'll just get ride of him like she does in Rye's route when you lose and it's not like she doesn't have options for males. At best I could see that route being one date and you either convincing her to bind you and keep you as a pleasure male or you piss her off and she either kills you or disposes of you horribly which is just another bad end and not really a whole route.
2) I don't might maledom but if we get too much the game stops being futadom-anything so I'll leave that up to the devs discretion since they haven't steered me wrong yet. I think Renee would be extremely unlikely to get maledommed anyways given her wealth, status, power, and personality. Much more likely to maledom a nobody like Diamond (who I think is more "irredeemably bad" than Renee) and still a bitch.
I like the Renee bad ends, they make sense and give me more of my fav character (if that hasn't already been firmly established). I agree that not every futa should be pure and virtuous because that makes a boring game but you should remember that almost every futa so far has shown the ability to be unfeeling and cruel to males, even the "nice" ones barring maybe Suni.
I just think Renee goes much deeper (based on my 3000 word analysis in my earlier post) and would therefore make a really good route given the writing skill we've seen so far from the team. I mean they made me like her and she's still supposed to be bad at the moment (I shall forever hold on to the hope that she gets a full route to herself).