VN Ren'Py Futa's World of NTR [v1.4.2] [ScarletGames]

[Alter-san]

This is all based on my first impression of the v1.3.5 update (rather than re-checking and analyzing the update). I'll be as objective as I can be, and will specify if I'm leaning more into my personal tastes!

Criticisms:

Spoiler: Dom versus sub route

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Spoiler: NTR feeling off, confusion regarding character dialogue

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Spoiler: Inconsistency between words and what's being shown

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Spoiler: Perceived character behavior inconsistency

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

More technical-focused criticisms (all of these were things I spotted without trying to be nitpicky; things I naturally noticed):

• Lots of clipping, mostly in animations but also in stills (like Andrea's tongue clipping through the side)
• Lack of animation and SFX (the lack of SFX tying into the lack of animation)—for the dom route as mentioned above.
• SFX in animations not matching up with the action (presumably playing separately via Ren'Py instead of baked into the video)
• Lots of animation errors. Some I happened to write down: weird unnatural/stiff movements, hands not properly grasping stuff, weird dick angles, weird titty twisting, legs moving incorrectly. In multiple shots, the dick is clearly clipping up and down through the flesh instead of going inside properly, more clipping in various cases, like straight through a skirt, and a case of a missing dick.

Spoiler: Opinion regarding NTR

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Spoiler: Worry about potential for "ruining" characters

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Positives:
I wrote another long comment about buildup and not skipping sex scenes etc. last update I believe, and I really feel heard (not that my comment was ever necessarily read )! Issues above aside, the general buildup was much better, dialogue between characters was great, and the scenes "went through the motions" instead of skipping around, and it felt much better! In particular, the slow burn with Nadya and Andrea in the room was just great—it increased the sexual tension and kept it at a high for a bit before the sex scene began. Splendid stuff, building up such sexual tension and keeping it there for a bit is exactly how you make the payoff so much better! Reminds me of the scene with Sophie on the couch where Milly seduces her, and it lets sexual tension build by showing her struggle and slowly giving in.
Although there are animation issues, the actual looping of the animations is fantastic. Although I didn't go out of my way to look for faults, I didn't notice any either! Feels great when things don't shift when the video loops.

Side-note SFX recommendation:
You should look into

You must be registered to see the links

. It's a fantastic resource with amazing and free assets (only needs to be added to the credits—details on that in their terms). I am sure the pack would work great for enhancing the scenes—especially the internal cumshots. There are truly great sound effects in that ridiculously huge pack.

Long-overdue end:
All in all, I hope my many words are at least useful to some degree. I truly do enjoy this game and would like to see it prosper. Just remember you can only pick 2 of 3 when it comes to: amount of content, quality, and time required to develop. I personally prefer when the time to develop increases, but you can also pick and choose depending on what the next update entails. If it's more complex, like the dom/sub stuff, make it 3 or 4 months, instead of speeding up and making mistakes or having to cut stuff. Likewise, decrease the time when it's more linear and easier to handle. Thanks for reading!

Jesus Christ man, I lost almost an hour thinking about what to write when you posted literally EVERYTHING I was thinking about splendidly a few minutes before ! WTH
I pray to god that Scarlet sees this and it makes him reflect a bit on that path.

 

[ArashiNinja18]

So there's no new content unless you go with the ntr route and decide to make milly and hana a couple of whores for other futas since hana and ollie are dumb and ended up where they ended up. You really should stop being lazy and list the changes so people don't waste their time. I really wanted the other route to continue so I'd see the aftermath of milly fucking sophia and what ms. futaba does or says after, but I guess you'd rather be a cuck than continue the good path. Such a waste of a download and my time.

 

[chenzu77]

This is all based on my first impression of the v1.3.5 update (rather than re-checking and analyzing the update). I'll be as objective as I can be, and will specify if I'm leaning more into my personal tastes!

Criticisms:

Spoiler: Dom versus sub route

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Spoiler: NTR feeling off, confusion regarding character dialogue

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Spoiler: Inconsistency between words and what's being shown

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Spoiler: Perceived character behavior inconsistency

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

More technical-focused criticisms (all of these were things I spotted without trying to be nitpicky; things I naturally noticed):

• Lots of clipping, mostly in animations but also in stills (like Andrea's tongue clipping through the side)
• Lack of animation and SFX (the lack of SFX tying into the lack of animation)—for the dom route as mentioned above.
• SFX in animations not matching up with the action (presumably playing separately via Ren'Py instead of baked into the video)
• Lots of animation errors. Some I happened to write down: weird unnatural/stiff movements, hands not properly grasping stuff, weird dick angles, weird titty twisting, legs moving incorrectly. In multiple shots, the dick is clearly clipping up and down through the flesh instead of going inside properly, more clipping in various cases, like straight through a skirt, and a case of a missing dick.

Spoiler: Opinion regarding NTR

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Spoiler: Worry about potential for "ruining" characters

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Positives:
I wrote another long comment about buildup and not skipping sex scenes etc. last update I believe, and I really feel heard (not that my comment was ever necessarily read )! Issues above aside, the general buildup was much better, dialogue between characters was great, and the scenes "went through the motions" instead of skipping around, and it felt much better! In particular, the slow burn with Nadya and Andrea in the room was just great—it increased the sexual tension and kept it at a high for a bit before the sex scene began. Splendid stuff, building up such sexual tension and keeping it there for a bit is exactly how you make the payoff so much better! Reminds me of the scene with Sophie on the couch where Milly seduces her, and it lets sexual tension build by showing her struggle and slowly giving in.
Although there are animation issues, the actual looping of the animations is fantastic. Although I didn't go out of my way to look for faults, I didn't notice any either! Feels great when things don't shift when the video loops.

Side-note SFX recommendation:
You should look into

You must be registered to see the links

. It's a fantastic resource with amazing and free assets (only needs to be added to the credits—details on that in their terms). I am sure the pack would work great for enhancing the scenes—especially the internal cumshots. There are truly great sound effects in that ridiculously huge pack.

Long-overdue end:
All in all, I hope my many words are at least useful to some degree. I truly do enjoy this game and would like to see it prosper. Just remember you can only pick 2 of 3 when it comes to: amount of content, quality, and time required to develop. I personally prefer when the time to develop increases, but you can also pick and choose depending on what the next update entails. If it's more complex, like the dom/sub stuff, make it 3 or 4 months, instead of speeding up and making mistakes or having to cut stuff. Likewise, decrease the time when it's more linear and easier to handle. Thanks for reading!

waos, you tackled every issue in the best way possible, all in all, it feels like milly being so dominant by default hinders the ntr aspect of the futaxfuta route. it does keeps my hopes up that the futaxfuta will be in the backseat for a while so maybe with more time in the oven the next futaxfuta update will be even better, i really like this path and after reading all of this i just kept thinking of how much better it could have been, this doesn't mean i think what we got is bad at all. You really know how to put things into perspective. i once said that the futaxfuta route didn't struck me as ntr and maybe it could have more things to gain if it doesn't focus so much in that aspect but i also see what scarlet wants to do with it and i kind of like it.

wish i could say something else but you really summed everything up perfectly

 

[Saculgn]

In the sub route, will Natalie and Andrea eventually make Milly put on a chastity cage?

 

[CutieLvr]

The boy MC in this game is a real pussy. Hana tried to seduce him, and he wants to take it at a snail's pace. What a dweeb, loser. I hope his futa-sister rapes his stupid ass and turns him into a cock loving sissy, because that is what he is. If he has nuts, they are the size of peas. I haven't finished this version, so I don't know how it plays out, but I'm very much looking forward to continuing this game. Love the art and the animations. The story is awesome too.

 

[Farspire]

So the game has Incest tag but no way to activate it far as I've seen... no in game setting and no patch, am i missing something or was the incest tag added accidentally?

 

[Kadmus]

Does that mean the MC has to be a rapist to access futa on futa?

Yep

At least the FxF sub-path. Andrea is clearly infatuated with Milly, and also quite dominant. Thus it feels strange and out of character for her to knowingly and meekly pass her up. For the same reasons it also feels weird for her to more or less badmouth Milly earlier in the evening

I'm saying, like, really, Andrea? You're just gonna let Natalie, of all people, one-up you. Where was all the bravado and dominance when you told her straight up that Milly is yours now? Hell she even intervened in the FxF Dom path when Milly was fucking Natalie and she doesn't have any infatuation for Natalie like she does for Milly, so it's even crazier she just let it happen like that. Tbf, I don't remember when Andrea badmouthed Milly, and I'm too lazy to go back and check, so I can't say anything about that.

And Nadya has only talked to Milly a couple of times at school. How deep and credible a bond can two healthy of mind persons obtain within that timespan, for those kind of "super-drama feelings" of broken loyalty to feel natural? To me it doesn't.

In Nadya's case, I think it's a heavy infatuation. Close to love at first sight imo. This is the same girl whose been on a cock abstinence streak for apparently a long time with a futanari's libido and immediately was ready to give it up to Milly when she got a whiff that she was futanari. To the point of wanting their first time together to be special? Yeah, that was love blossoming extremely quickly. And the FxF path cements that with how she regrets fucking Andrea despite going for seconds and only let Natalie tapped because of that spiked drink. And she still wasn't as cock drunk as she was with Milly on the Netori path.
So I can see how she can be melodramatic about the situation, but at the same time, she also knows that Milly is drugged, so she suffers the same problem as Andrea, just letting it happen and not intervening.

And Milly herself seems weirdly eager to drug herself into oblivion, even if the "juice's" effect, and Andrea and Natalie's malicious intent is clearly stated right in front of her. As if she was already broken.

Honestly, Milly does seem like the person who would try new things. Like allowing Andrea to fuck her although I feel it's mainly because Natalie raped her that she felt an itch enough to let it happen. While I do think Milly drinking that spiked beer should've been something that only happens if you accepted the weed from Andrea, but that's too much work to expect from a solo dev whose work is already doing well so far imo.

To me, the only character in this update that acts true to her character, is Natalie...who's incidentally also best girl.

Damn, I disagree on Best Girl. She's too cocky for a bottom bitch. Nadya, for me personally.

If I were to pick 1 example, it would be the dom route where the classic "getting boned behind the door" thing happens with Nadya and Natalie. I know very well her brain was drugged so much she'd be super horny, but that actually works against the NTR writing. I'll go into this on a more personal note below, but Milly is simply written to be a dominant character by default. As far as "I know her", she would just not be standing there by the door in a meek manner, stuttering all that—especially when she's super horny. Yeah, she's taking a short break at that moment, but having gotten her rocks off never made her act meek like that, and running into that situation might stump her for a moment but not knock out her feet from under her.
How she acted felt like it was taken straight out of NTR manga and applied to Milly, a character who would not act like that. At the very least, she would've taken control of the situation in some manner, and I know that's less objective to say, but even as far as the game aspect goes here, we're on the dom route. If the player had actively made the choice to be submissive, it would make more sense that she'd act meek/awkward when she sees Nadya getting boned, and she might awkwardly stand there for a moment and maybe leave, but it's still pushing it on the NTR thing for the previously mentioned reasons.

YES. I felt the same way. No way in hell would Milly see that kind of situation and not jump on it even after cumming her brains out right before. That scene would've put her into an instant hard-on, especially with that spiked drink in her system that reduces her restraint. That scene alone felt more NTR than the Sub path. And it kills me that it happened to an unhinged Milly of all people.

Like I've mentioned, Milly is dominant by default and constantly acts as such. That's a strong trait of hers. Even Milly herself and other characters state as much. I think the approach of futa x futa being submissive in general, and you can either dig into being submissive or be dominant in some situations, is backwards based on her character. In my opinion, it would've made much more sense for her character to be dominant in the route, and you have to choose as the player to be submissive—this ties back into the NTR feeling forced as who we know she is has to be somewhat overridden.

I see what you mean here, but I feel like that's exactly what's in the game rn? Choosing to send pics to Natalie and sucking the drug dealer's dick seems a lot like the Player being able to choose the moments where Milly's submissive nature starts to come out. The spiked beer at the end also sped things up in that direction.
Unless you meant from the beginning with her letting Andrea fuck and honestly that felt less like submission and more like a test run because of curiosity. Personally, I was fine with it because it's a much better angle for Milly to be curious about how it feels to be the bottom rather than making her submissive all of a sudden.

All in all. I agree with your takes. Especially on how the characters acted.

The boy MC in this game is a real puss

The boy isn't an MC.

 

[Daryle1]

So the game has Incest tag but no way to activate it far as I've seen... no in game setting and no patch, am i missing something or was the incest tag added accidentally?

Must have been put there by a mod when the unfinished version leaked. There's no incest in the game.

 

[Míster R]

So there's no new content unless you go with the ntr route and decide to make milly and hana a couple of whores for other futas since hana and ollie are dumb and ended up where they ended up. You really should stop being lazy and list the changes so people don't waste their time. I really wanted the other route to continue so I'd see the aftermath of milly fucking sophia and what ms. futaba does or says after, but I guess you'd rather be a cuck than continue the good path. Such a waste of a download and my time.

Don't complain about wasting time when you spend your time on porn games and it wouldn't cost you anything to take 5 minutes to read the comments and see what the new update is about.

 

[Daryle1]

This is all based on my first impression of the v1.3.5 update (rather than re-checking and analyzing the update). I'll be as objective as I can be, and will specify if I'm leaning more into my personal tastes!

Criticisms:

Spoiler: Dom versus sub route

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Spoiler: NTR feeling off, confusion regarding character dialogue

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Spoiler: Inconsistency between words and what's being shown

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Spoiler: Perceived character behavior inconsistency

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

More technical-focused criticisms (all of these were things I spotted without trying to be nitpicky; things I naturally noticed):

• Lots of clipping, mostly in animations but also in stills (like Andrea's tongue clipping through the side)
• Lack of animation and SFX (the lack of SFX tying into the lack of animation)—for the dom route as mentioned above.
• SFX in animations not matching up with the action (presumably playing separately via Ren'Py instead of baked into the video)
• Lots of animation errors. Some I happened to write down: weird unnatural/stiff movements, hands not properly grasping stuff, weird dick angles, weird titty twisting, legs moving incorrectly. In multiple shots, the dick is clearly clipping up and down through the flesh instead of going inside properly, more clipping in various cases, like straight through a skirt, and a case of a missing dick.

Spoiler: Opinion regarding NTR

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Spoiler: Worry about potential for "ruining" characters

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Positives:
I wrote another long comment about buildup and not skipping sex scenes etc. last update I believe, and I really feel heard (not that my comment was ever necessarily read )! Issues above aside, the general buildup was much better, dialogue between characters was great, and the scenes "went through the motions" instead of skipping around, and it felt much better! In particular, the slow burn with Nadya and Andrea in the room was just great—it increased the sexual tension and kept it at a high for a bit before the sex scene began. Splendid stuff, building up such sexual tension and keeping it there for a bit is exactly how you make the payoff so much better! Reminds me of the scene with Sophie on the couch where Milly seduces her, and it lets sexual tension build by showing her struggle and slowly giving in.
Although there are animation issues, the actual looping of the animations is fantastic. Although I didn't go out of my way to look for faults, I didn't notice any either! Feels great when things don't shift when the video loops.

Side-note SFX recommendation:
You should look into

You must be registered to see the links

. It's a fantastic resource with amazing and free assets (only needs to be added to the credits—details on that in their terms). I am sure the pack would work great for enhancing the scenes—especially the internal cumshots. There are truly great sound effects in that ridiculously huge pack.

Long-overdue end:
All in all, I hope my many words are at least useful to some degree. I truly do enjoy this game and would like to see it prosper. Just remember you can only pick 2 of 3 when it comes to: amount of content, quality, and time required to develop. I personally prefer when the time to develop increases, but you can also pick and choose depending on what the next update entails. If it's more complex, like the dom/sub stuff, make it 3 or 4 months, instead of speeding up and making mistakes or having to cut stuff. Likewise, decrease the time when it's more linear and easier to handle. Thanks for reading!

This is a lot and I think the dev should be notified of this if you want it to be seen because he's always busy with something. He's really nice but this post could fade into the comments before he logs in to this platform again. But no dev likes to be micro managed and this is really a lot. I'm not criticizing, but I'm just saying even a dev like this one can't get everything right and this is probably the best he could put together in under 2 months. Especially with all the buildup and scenes he probably had to add this time around. I'm not sure how he could improve any of your points other than needing more time for writing and development.
Also, Milly DID try to barge in when she caught Nadya and Natalie but the door was slammed in her face and locked, then she still tried to break in but she couldn't really do much in that situation except take it out on Andrea. I think the dom path probably suffered due to fatigue from making 2 paths at the same time for the first time and scarlet was right to try and keep futa on futa mainly a sub path and focus mainly on Andrea and Milly.

Last time I asked, he says he wishes he could finish futa on futa on day 5 and call it a vacation lol. And he says he wants the game to have the risky path but he's 'debating' if the depravity will lead to his early grave. So... I'm sensing a roadblock for netorare in week 2.

The only solution I see for futa on futa is appealing to scarlet to make it just one path with choices because the issue here is time. The only problem is Dom fans and Sub fans, who is he going to sacrifice?

 

[Daryle1]

So there's no new content unless you go with the ntr route and decide to make milly and hana a couple of whores for other futas since hana and ollie are dumb and ended up where they ended up. You really should stop being lazy and list the changes so people don't waste their time. I really wanted the other route to continue so I'd see the aftermath of milly fucking sophia and what ms. futaba does or says after, but I guess you'd rather be a cuck than continue the good path. Such a waste of a download and my time.

I don't understand, who are you complaining to? Complain to the mods who upload the game and see if they will do that every update. Did you expect the dev to come and give a changelog for a leaked version of his game? Read the comments for 1 minute like every normal person would next time.

 

[U-niverse]

Crazy how mac gets the mega.nz link but win/linux doesn't. Even though more people have a pc, instead of a useless laptop that can't handle most games.

who would choose mega over gofile?

 

[BLOOD!]

UPD got released, now we pray for not getting same treatment for the NTR/Netori path with a UPD without any spicy scenes and get the normal schedule of UPD as before, with day events and stuff and then a final UPD with night events and shit. ☝

 

[paypayon]

Wait, after reading the comments, is the futa x futa route planned to end shortly and then only the other route will keep being updated?

 

[Míster R]

Wait, after reading the comments, is the futa x futa route planned to end shortly and then only the other route will keep being updated?

The fxf path is just a subpath of the depravity path which is the main path along with the netori

 

[Rexermus]

Wait, after reading the comments, is the futa x futa route planned to end shortly and then only the other route will keep being updated?

I believe it's going to more so be a break so Scarlet can focus on the Netori path, and then come back to Futa x Futa later on, after they've made significantly more progress with Netori

 

[wolas3214]

Utterly bizarre choice to make the MC a cuck in the dom path.

 

[RisingDawn00]

I believe it's going to more so be a break so Scarlet can focus on the Netori path, and then come back to Futa x Futa later on, after they've made significantly more progress with Netori

Nah I believe it ends. It's the bad ending remember? Plus he wouldn't mention netorare in week 2 if that were the case. But that too might be cancelled from what I'm hearing.

Utterly bizarre choice to make the MC a cuck in the dom path.

It's a bad ending, and it seems scarlet doesn't want it to be redeemable that's why he dropped so many disclaimers. We're lucky the futa haven't gone and r*ped her entire family by now.

 

[BLOOD!]

Nah I believe it ends. It's the bad ending remember? Plus he wouldn't mention netorare in week 2 if that were the case. But that too might be cancelled from what I'm hearing.


It's a bad ending, and it seems scarlet doesn't want it to be redeemable that's why he dropped so many disclaimers. We're lucky the futa haven't gone and r*ped her entire family by now.

That's going to happen 100% anyway, if it's a bad ending, the futa's have to rape every girl in th family included Ms Futaba + Milly being a complete slut to futa cock, the first it seems that was Hana, but we won't know it until the next UPD of Futa x Futa path.

 

[Konius]

This is all based on my first impression of the v1.3.5 update (rather than re-checking and analyzing the update). I'll be as objective as I can be, and will specify if I'm leaning more into my personal tastes!

Criticisms:

Spoiler: Dom versus sub route

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Spoiler: NTR feeling off, confusion regarding character dialogue

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Spoiler: Inconsistency between words and what's being shown

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Spoiler: Perceived character behavior inconsistency

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

More technical-focused criticisms (all of these were things I spotted without trying to be nitpicky; things I naturally noticed):

• Lots of clipping, mostly in animations but also in stills (like Andrea's tongue clipping through the side)
• Lack of animation and SFX (the lack of SFX tying into the lack of animation)—for the dom route as mentioned above.
• SFX in animations not matching up with the action (presumably playing separately via Ren'Py instead of baked into the video)
• Lots of animation errors. Some I happened to write down: weird unnatural/stiff movements, hands not properly grasping stuff, weird dick angles, weird titty twisting, legs moving incorrectly. In multiple shots, the dick is clearly clipping up and down through the flesh instead of going inside properly, more clipping in various cases, like straight through a skirt, and a case of a missing dick.

Spoiler: Opinion regarding NTR

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Spoiler: Worry about potential for "ruining" characters

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Positives:
I wrote another long comment about buildup and not skipping sex scenes etc. last update I believe, and I really feel heard (not that my comment was ever necessarily read )! Issues above aside, the general buildup was much better, dialogue between characters was great, and the scenes "went through the motions" instead of skipping around, and it felt much better! In particular, the slow burn with Nadya and Andrea in the room was just great—it increased the sexual tension and kept it at a high for a bit before the sex scene began. Splendid stuff, building up such sexual tension and keeping it there for a bit is exactly how you make the payoff so much better! Reminds me of the scene with Sophie on the couch where Milly seduces her, and it lets sexual tension build by showing her struggle and slowly giving in.
Although there are animation issues, the actual looping of the animations is fantastic. Although I didn't go out of my way to look for faults, I didn't notice any either! Feels great when things don't shift when the video loops.

Side-note SFX recommendation:
You should look into

You must be registered to see the links

. It's a fantastic resource with amazing and free assets (only needs to be added to the credits—details on that in their terms). I am sure the pack would work great for enhancing the scenes—especially the internal cumshots. There are truly great sound effects in that ridiculously huge pack.

Long-overdue end:
All in all, I hope my many words are at least useful to some degree. I truly do enjoy this game and would like to see it prosper. Just remember you can only pick 2 of 3 when it comes to: amount of content, quality, and time required to develop. I personally prefer when the time to develop increases, but you can also pick and choose depending on what the next update entails. If it's more complex, like the dom/sub stuff, make it 3 or 4 months, instead of speeding up and making mistakes or having to cut stuff. Likewise, decrease the time when it's more linear and easier to handle. Thanks for reading!

Comments like these are a charm to read while we wait for more content, If I can throw my 2 cents in the ring especially regarding your opinion on NTR. To start off I vaguely remember the dev speaking on the side paths and saying characters/milly making choices they normally wouldn't. Despite that I don't find Millys fall in the side paths that hard to believe for a few reasons. Chief among them is that we gotta remember Milly is really only now blossoming as a futanari after ten years of keeping it on the down low which makes her more easy to manipulate. Another thing, we know how much of a toll a futanaris libido takes on them especially Milly who I like to think of as a young alpha without an outlet they go on the "Night Train". Last I would say what really kept Milly from the side paths we see is Nadya(The GOAT) shes the only one so far that can match our MC's freak and keep her libido in check also helps that she has a fat crush on Milly.

Offtopic but I know Scarlet mentioned that not every character we see in the side path will get scenes in the main. But I reallly hope we get to see more of Andrea/Natlie in the main and we get scenes with them. The latters basically guaranteed considering how much of a schemer and antagonist she is. Regardless heres to being optomistic.