Like
ChipLecsap I'm kind of tired of this Kate/Max thing. Not because of you, you are very civil
, but the whole thing in general.
But some points to clarify. By "speculative" I was only talking about point 1, or more precicely the assumption that these patrons would come back.
Point 4 to 8 I summarized as "subjective", as in no hard, clear facts. I wouldn't count the popularity on a pirate forum as a reliable messure of financial success.
And yes, you didn't say significant rise before an update. But precicely this insignificance makes the point pretty weak.