recreation

pure evil!
Respected User
Game Developer
Jun 10, 2018
6,326
22,757
I have mixed feelings, not a big fan of mother/son stuff but brother/sister stuff is kinda hot. Might be because I'm an only child though.
I'm a big fan of incest stuff in games, or movies and I have a sister. But I would never even think about doing something with her.
Its like DrFrog said:
However, whenever my brain starts to wander unbidden towards people I'm actually related too, I'm like "wow, thanks brain, totally killed the mood there, jackass."
 

TheDevian

Svengali Productions
Game Developer
Mar 8, 2018
14,254
33,430
I think Runey meant bratty in the sense that she'd be unruly and rebellious, throwing the occasional tantrum. Indeed like Ellen in the flashback, she didn't want to do what she was told and stuff.

I think it could make for some good discipline bdsm play.
The problem with that is that we have tsundere already (Ellen and Kali), I like Kali's version, not fond of Ellen's, and really dislike when it goes further and turns into yandere. At least they are both Type B, and not a violent Type A, which is something I really can't stand (Akane and Taiga need to die in fire). IDK, maybe it's just me, but how many bitchy/standoffish characters does one game need? That was exactly what I was trying to avoid with the adoring brat idea. If you don't count the android who was built to serve and the elf who was abused her whole life, then it's basically just Maria who isn't. Even the new deredere (super nice girl) is doing her best to upset everyone right off the bat (not that I am complaining about that, it fits her).

The bratty thing can work, but if you pair it with tsundere and make her tiny like Lin, then we end up with another annoying character like Ashley that I just want to do my best to ignore. I prefer the idea that she is adoring, and willing to do what you tell her, but she wants to be punished, and so messes up intentionally on occasion. Like she is pretending to be the clumsy air-headed girl (which is a trope we don't really have), and she craves attention, maybe she didn't have a dad in her life (your left or died when you were young, and you were the closest she had to a 'father figure' to her, and mom's spankings (after you left) just didn't do it for her, so she decides one day to run away from home and find you, and shows up on your door step one day with a suitcase full of whatever she could carry. ;)
 

DrFog

Active Member
Sep 18, 2018
835
1,736
The problem with that is that we have tsundere already (Ellen and Kali), I like Kali's version, not fond of Ellen's, and really dislike when it goes further and turns into yandere
Even the new deredere (super nice girl) is doing her best to upset everyone right off the bat (not that I am complaining about that, it fits her).
The bratty thing can work, but if you pair it with tsundere and make her tiny like Lin, then we end up with another annoying character like Ashley that I just want to do my best to ignore.
Candere youdere pleasedere stopdere withdere thedere fuckingdere stupiddere Japanesedere subgenredere shitdere? Idere can'tdere understanddere whatdere thedere fuckdere you'redere sayingdere.
 

DrFog

Active Member
Sep 18, 2018
835
1,736
The problem with that is that we have tsundere already (Ellen and Kali), I like Kali's version, not fond of Ellen's, and really dislike when it goes further and turns into yandere. At least they are both Type B, and not a violent Type A, which is something I really can't stand (Akane and Taiga need to die in fire). IDK, maybe it's just me, but how many bitchy/standoffish characters does one game need? That was exactly what I was trying to avoid with the adoring brat idea. If you don't count the android who was built to serve and the elf who was abused her whole life, then it's basically just Maria who isn't. Even the new deredere (super nice girl) is doing her best to upset everyone right off the bat (not that I am complaining about that, it fits her).

The bratty thing can work, but if you pair it with tsundere and make her tiny like Lin, then we end up with another annoying character like Ashley that I just want to do my best to ignore. I prefer the idea that she is adoring, and willing to do what you tell her, but she wants to be punished, and so messes up intentionally on occasion. Like she is pretending to be the clumsy air-headed girl (which is a trope we don't really have), and she craves attention, maybe she didn't have a dad in her life (your left or died when you were young, and you were the closest she had to a 'father figure' to her, and mom's spankings (after you left) just didn't do it for her, so she decides one day to run away from home and find you, and shows up on your door step one day with a suitcase full of whatever she could carry. ;)
In all seriousness though, I think the bratty thing could work so long as it's a good-natured type of bratty. Like a bratty sub that just does shit she knows she's not supposed to in order to get more punishments because she's masochistic as fuck. I agree that she shouldn't actually be a brat though. I'm still in favor of her being a total goody-two-shoes that we corrupt the fuck out of, but the bratty sub alternative isn't bad either.
 

aolli

Member
Nov 15, 2018
337
771
The problem with that is that we have tsundere already (Ellen and Kali), I like Kali's version, not fond of Ellen's, and really dislike when it goes further and turns into yandere. At least they are both Type B, and not a violent Type A, which is something I really can't stand (Akane and Taiga need to die in fire). IDK, maybe it's just me, but how many bitchy/standoffish characters does one game need? That was exactly what I was trying to avoid with the adoring brat idea. If you don't count the android who was built to serve and the elf who was abused her whole life, then it's basically just Maria who isn't. Even the new deredere (super nice girl) is doing her best to upset everyone right off the bat (not that I am complaining about that, it fits her).

The bratty thing can work, but if you pair it with tsundere and make her tiny like Lin, then we end up with another annoying character like Ashley that I just want to do my best to ignore. I prefer the idea that she is adoring, and willing to do what you tell her, but she wants to be punished, and so messes up intentionally on occasion. Like she is pretending to be the clumsy air-headed girl (which is a trope we don't really have), and she craves attention, maybe she didn't have a dad in her life (your left or died when you were young, and you were the closest she had to a 'father figure' to her, and mom's spankings (after you left) just didn't do it for her, so she decides one day to run away from home and find you, and shows up on your door step one day with a suitcase full of whatever she could carry. ;)
I kind of agree that we've got a lot of reluctant/tsundere girls already, i'd like it to be the other way round for one and I think a little sister could be the perfect oppotunity for a girl to be trying to get with the MC and the MC being reluctant.
 

Runey

Harem Hotel
Game Developer
May 17, 2018
3,965
20,010
The problem with that is that we have tsundere already (Ellen and Kali), I like Kali's version, not fond of Ellen's, and really dislike when it goes further and turns into yandere. At least they are both Type B, and not a violent Type A, which is something I really can't stand (Akane and Taiga need to die in fire). IDK, maybe it's just me, but how many bitchy/standoffish characters does one game need? That was exactly what I was trying to avoid with the adoring brat idea. If you don't count the android who was built to serve and the elf who was abused her whole life, then it's basically just Maria who isn't. Even the new deredere (super nice girl) is doing her best to upset everyone right off the bat (not that I am complaining about that, it fits her).

The bratty thing can work, but if you pair it with tsundere and make her tiny like Lin, then we end up with another annoying character like Ashley that I just want to do my best to ignore. I prefer the idea that she is adoring, and willing to do what you tell her, but she wants to be punished, and so messes up intentionally on occasion. Like she is pretending to be the clumsy air-headed girl (which is a trope we don't really have), and she craves attention, maybe she didn't have a dad in her life (your left or died when you were young, and you were the closest she had to a 'father figure' to her, and mom's spankings (after you left) just didn't do it for her, so she decides one day to run away from home and find you, and shows up on your door step one day with a suitcase full of whatever she could carry. ;)
I think you mean Emma and Kali?


I kind of agree that we've got a lot of reluctant/tsundere girls already, i'd like it to be the other way round for one and I think a little sister could be the perfect oppotunity for a girl to be trying to get with the MC and the MC being reluctant.
Tsundere was and still is the most popular personality type on all of my polls. Emma isn't as big as a tsundere as Kali, but she does have tsundere traits.

Candere youdere pleasedere stopdere withdere thedere fuckingdere stupiddere Japanesedere subgenredere shitdere? Idere can'tdere understanddere whatdere thedere fuckdere you'redere sayingdere.
While words like Himedere and Yandere don't need to be used (meaning acts like a princess. And Psycho) Tsundere is very hard to explain in English.

A Tsundere is typically a girl who likes the protagonist but doesn't want to admit it. Summed up with "Not that I like you or anything". That's a lot more words than "Tsundere", so it makes sense to use Tsundere over it's description.
 

recreation

pure evil!
Respected User
Game Developer
Jun 10, 2018
6,326
22,757
I dont know if that was mentioned somewhere before, but for me it would depend on how old she is. If shes younger than the MC, I would go for the cute route. If shes older, then I'd make her a bit bitchy, not as much as ashley though. Ashley is unique and should stay that way (I like her btw). I think I would make the older sister struggle with herself, because she knows its a bad thing to do something with her brother, even though she wants it soooo badly :p That way she wouldn't be bitchy to everyone, but only to the MC because of her struggles AND without being a tsundere.
 

TheDevian

Svengali Productions
Game Developer
Mar 8, 2018
14,254
33,430
Candere youdere pleasedere stopdere withdere thedere fuckingdere stupiddere Japanesedere subgenredere shitdere? Idere can'tdere understanddere whatdere thedere fuckdere you'redere sayingdere.
Sorry, they are both confusing and convenient to use. Runey posted the chart for the girls though, so it's not my fault! :ROFLMAO: The sad part is it could be worse... :geek:
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
I think you mean Emma and Kali?
If you mean the Akane and Taiga, no, those are characters from anime, I like Emma and Kali very much. They are the good kind.

Tsundere was and still is the most popular personality type on all of my polls. Emma isn't as big as a tsundere as Kali, but she does have tsundere traits.
Yes, but you have 3 now, Emma, Kali, and Ellen.

I dont know if that was mentioned somewhere before, but for me it would depend on how old she is. If shes younger than the MC, I would go for the cute route. If shes older, then I'd make her a bit bitchy, not as much as ashley though. Ashley is unique and should stay that way (I like her btw). I think I would make the older sister struggle with herself, because she knows its a bad thing to do something with her brother, even though she wants it soooo badly :p That way she wouldn't be bitchy to everyone, but only to the MC because of her struggles.
No, please gawd no.... The bitchy older sister is so played out. :p Luckily, we were talking younger here anyway. ;)
 

aolli

Member
Nov 15, 2018
337
771
Sorry, they are both confusing and convenient to use. Runey posted the chart for the girls though, so it's not my fault! :ROFLMAO: The sad part is it could be worse... :geek:
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
If you mean the Akane and Taiga, no, those are characters from anime, I like Emma and Kali very much. They are the good kind.

Yes, but you have 3 now, Emma, Kali, and Ellen.


No, please gawd no.... The bitchy older sister is so played out. :p Luckily, we were talking younger here anyway. ;)
I'm not sure I'd call Ellen a tsundere, she seems to genuinly have no romantic interest in MC.

I would like to see other personality types though.
 

Runey

Harem Hotel
Game Developer
May 17, 2018
3,965
20,010
Sorry, they are both confusing and convenient to use. Runey posted the chart for the girls though, so it's not my fault! :ROFLMAO: The sad part is it could be worse... :geek:
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
If you mean the Akane and Taiga, no, those are characters from anime, I like Emma and Kali very much. They are the good kind.

Yes, but you have 3 now, Emma, Kali, and Ellen.


No, please gawd no.... The bitchy older sister is so played out. :p Luckily, we were talking younger here anyway. ;)
No, no, you called Ellen a Tsundere earlier, I thought you meant Emma. Ellen is absolutely not a Tsundere. She's a romantic. Not sure what dere I'd give her, doesn't need to be one. But she absolutely doesn't have any "hidden feelings" for MC she doesn't want to admit.
 

TheDevian

Svengali Productions
Game Developer
Mar 8, 2018
14,254
33,430
I'm not sure I'd call Ellen a tsundere, she seems to genuinly have no romantic interest in MC.

I would like to see other personality types though.
No, no, you called Ellen a Tsundere earlier, I thought you meant Emma. Ellen is absolutely not a Tsundere. She's a romantic. Not sure what dere I'd give her, doesn't need to be one. But she absolutely doesn't have any "hidden feelings" for MC she doesn't want to admit.
Maybe you forgot her intro, but she was VERY standoffish and fit the trope to a tea. Go back and read the old flashback when Ellen first arrived at the hotel, when Graps was still alive. That is a text book example. :geek:
 

Runey

Harem Hotel
Game Developer
May 17, 2018
3,965
20,010
Maybe you forgot her intro, but she was VERY standoffish and fit the trope to a tea. Go back and read the old flashback when Ellen first arrived at the hotel, when Graps was still alive. That is a text book example. :geek:
Oh yeah, at her youngest seen, she was a brat. She was 13 then. In the intro, she was 16, and very much a Tsundere. Now (roughly 32 - 38 years old) she's a romantic.

So yeah, youngest Ellen was a brat, teen Ellen was a Tsundere, and current Ellen is a romantic.
 

TheDevian

Svengali Productions
Game Developer
Mar 8, 2018
14,254
33,430
Oh yeah, at her youngest seen, she was a brat. She was 13 then. In the intro, she was 16, and very much a Tsundere. Now (roughly 32 - 38 years old) she's a romantic.

So yeah, youngest Ellen was a brat, teen Ellen was a Tsundere, and current Ellen is a romantic.
Well, I don't rememebr seeing her at 13, just the ~16 or so one, with her and Sophie, but you know what they say about first impressions. ;)
If you were following the trope, that side of her might come out more if she found herself attracted to the MC (old habits), otherwise she is just keeping up her work persona, a facade (same thing most people who work in customer service do, pretend to be nice to your face, and then complain about how rude you were while alone). :p
For example, Akane Tendo (Ranma 1/2) is perfectly nice to most people, it is only when around her supposed love interest (well, any guy that hits on her really), that she goes all bitchy/crazy/violent. The rest of the time, she pretends to be a nice person. :whistle:
 

TheDevian

Svengali Productions
Game Developer
Mar 8, 2018
14,254
33,430
No worries mate, I was just joking. Well, that, and reasserting my viewpoint on how unnecessary all these damn Japanese terms are.
:LOL: For most of them I agree, but 'bitchy/lovey' doesn't really have the same explanatory power to it. IDK, maybe we can start it as a thing.

I have spent way too much on TVTropes over the years...
 

recreation

pure evil!
Respected User
Game Developer
Jun 10, 2018
6,326
22,757
Sorry, they are both confusing and convenient to use. Runey posted the chart for the girls though, so it's not my fault! :ROFLMAO: The sad part is it could be worse... :geek:
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
If you mean the Akane and Taiga, no, those are characters from anime, I like Emma and Kali very much. They are the good kind.

Yes, but you have 3 now, Emma, Kali, and Ellen.


No, please gawd no.... The bitchy older sister is so played out. :p Luckily, we were talking younger here anyway. ;)
Younger? Good :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheDevian

random.person

Active Member
Aug 11, 2017
802
1,292
At the end of the day, I just trust whatever Runey cooks up for the sister. I'm sure it'll be interesting, if not for me for someone else. And anyway I already have a lot of girls I really like in the game, so even if I were to not like the sister I'd have no issue.
But I'd still max out her stats. I never forget my manners.
 

TheDevian

Svengali Productions
Game Developer
Mar 8, 2018
14,254
33,430
At the end of the day, I just trust whatever Runey cooks up for the sister. I'm sure it'll be interesting, if not for me for someone else. And anyway I already have a lot of girls I really like in the game, so even if I were to not like the sister I'd have no issue.
But I'd still max out her stats. I never forget my manners.
For me, I will have to wait for the full package, too many traits I don't like, and they will get the Ashley treatment. Her affection is not high enough for me to even try to max the others out any more. It's only as high as it is because I said I liked her brown hair. ...though it did seem to make her tits shrink, or was that just me? :unsure::whistle:;) Must have been because she got wet. :ROFLMAO:
 

random.person

Active Member
Aug 11, 2017
802
1,292
For me, I will have to wait for the full package, too many traits I don't like, and they will get the Ashley treatment. Her affection is not high enough for me to even try to max the others out any more. It's only as high as it is because I said I liked her brown hair. ...though it did seem to make her tits shrink, or was that just me? :unsure::whistle:;) Must have been because she got wet. :ROFLMAO:
I thought you were a gentleman: how can you ignore the poor puppy?!
 
4.70 star(s) 468 Votes