- Jan 10, 2018
- 2,455
- 3,313
True, but the difference between good fiction and bad fiction (and, as you say, if an author wants to write bad fiction, they cretainly can) is that the differences between our world and the author's world are explained. Superman is an alien. Spiderman was bitten by a rat. Frodo lived a long time ago when magic and magical beings were more common, etc. Fiction is whatever the author wants it to be, but good fiction is not. Good fiction is what the reader wants it to be.Again, fiction is whatever the author wants it to be, not what you want it to be.
Irony isn't just the opposite of wrinkly.I'm going to put you on block now because arguing with the clueless gives me a headache.
Having said all of that, I think that the objection to the somewhat absurd premise of the story is overstated. The reason for the MC to flee her home is not at all central to the plot so far. It could as easily be an orc invasion. The author is rightly focusing on what is important to the plot, not whether hair dye actually completely washes off in a shower, or whatever.