gino.pilotino

Member
Nov 16, 2017
269
446
So you guys attacked me yesterday because I had a dissenting opinion. You had me delete everything. Somebody even managed to get me to delete the review that I thought was honest and not against the rules. And in fact--when they delete a review you usually get the message: you went against the forum rules. And they put the link to the rules asking you to read them again. That didn't happen this time. That's fine. You have succeeded in wiping me out. Bravo. As I promised, though, I would take the criticism to heart and give it a second chance. And I did. Honestly and seriously. And I stand by my opinion. As you told me, from chapter two things improve. The sliding show at the end of the chapter actually gives some excitement. In chapter two the characters are given a little more depth. It took a whole first chapter to get to something vaguely emotional. And in the later chapters, however, the characters remain rather sketchy and not particularly detailed. For me, this remains a mediocre game. I had gone to change the review, but you managed to make me throw that one out as well. I was going to edit it and bring it up to three stars. Patience, the game remains mediocre and I don't really care about failing to rate it. I'm more sorry to have been attacked and blown off for my opinions. You have not made a good impression.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: lnppo

Lynava

Newbie
Nov 1, 2020
91
97
So you guys attacked me yesterday because I had a dissenting opinion. You had me delete everything. Somebody even managed to get me to delete the review that I thought was honest and not against the rules. And in fact--when they delete a review you usually get the message: you went against the forum rules. And they put the link to the rules asking you to read them again. That didn't happen this time. That's fine. You have succeeded in wiping me out. Bravo. As I promised, though, I would take the criticism to heart and give it a second chance. And I did. Honestly and seriously. And I stand by my opinion. As you told me, from chapter two things improve. The sliding show at the end of the chapter actually gives some excitement. In chapter two the characters are given a little more depth. It took a whole first chapter to get to something vaguely emotional. And in the later chapters, however, the characters remain rather sketchy and not particularly detailed. For me, this remains a mediocre game. I had gone to change the review, but you managed to make me throw that one out as well. I was going to edit it and bring it up to three stars. Patience, the game remains mediocre and I don't really care about failing to rate it. I'm more sorry to have been attacked and blown off for my opinions. You have not made a good impression.
Your review is not correct or objective. If you had written a full review, no one would have a problem with it being a 1*. Personally I am not good at expressing my opinion in text so I don't write reviews. Your review is not correct or objective. If you had written a full review, no one would have a problem with it being a 1*. Personally I am not good at expressing my opinion in text so I don't write reviews. :HideThePain:
 
  • Like
Reactions: pitao

gino.pilotino

Member
Nov 16, 2017
269
446
Your review is not correct or objective. If you had written a full review, no one would have a problem with it being a 1*. Personally I am not good at expressing my opinion in text so I don't write reviews. Your review is not correct or objective. If you had written a full review, no one would have a problem with it being a 1*. Personally I am not good at expressing my opinion in text so I don't write reviews. :HideThePain:
Look, I don't want to get back into the whirlwind of the other night. I will say, though, that I can't stand reviews that analyze anything. I appreciate, look for, and read reviews that describe the emotions the reader felt when reading a story. And my review was exactly that. I don't care to say how the animations or renders are. A story, to be liked, has to give me emotions. And these I tell in my reviews. I try to let people who read my reviews know what emotions I felt. I think that's much more interesting than whether or not I liked the animations or renders
 

Buletti

Well-Known Member
Nov 7, 2023
1,133
1,207
So you guys attacked me yesterday because I had a dissenting opinion. You had me delete everything. Somebody even managed to get me to delete the review that I thought was honest and not against the rules. And in fact--when they delete a review you usually get the message: you went against the forum rules. And they put the link to the rules asking you to read them again. That didn't happen this time. That's fine. You have succeeded in wiping me out. Bravo. As I promised, though, I would take the criticism to heart and give it a second chance. And I did. Honestly and seriously. And I stand by my opinion. As you told me, from chapter two things improve. The sliding show at the end of the chapter actually gives some excitement. In chapter two the characters are given a little more depth. It took a whole first chapter to get to something vaguely emotional. And in the later chapters, however, the characters remain rather sketchy and not particularly detailed. For me, this remains a mediocre game. I had gone to change the review, but you managed to make me throw that one out as well. I was going to edit it and bring it up to three stars. Patience, the game remains mediocre and I don't really care about failing to rate it. I'm more sorry to have been attacked and blown off for my opinions. You have not made a good impression.
Dunno mate... All I did was pointing out that a one star rating was too low for not even finishing it. I could understand if you give it the 3 stars, even though I would not share that opinion. But that sounds way more reasonable to me.

Glad you came around.

Cheers!
 
  • Like
Reactions: pitao

gino.pilotino

Member
Nov 16, 2017
269
446
Dunno mate... All I did was pointing out that a one star rating was too low for not even finishing it. I could understand if you give it the 3 stars, even though I would not share that opinion. But that sounds way more reasonable to me.

Glad you came around.

Cheers!
I don't know man, ten of you jumped on me yesterday and I didn't know who to defend myself against anymore. Can I think differently without having to feel attacked?
 

Elduriel

Forum Fanatic
Donor
Mar 28, 2021
4,974
9,193
So you guys attacked me yesterday because I had a dissenting opinion. You had me delete everything. Somebody even managed to get me to delete the review that I thought was honest and not against the rules. And in fact--when they delete a review you usually get the message: you went against the forum rules. And they put the link to the rules asking you to read them again. That didn't happen this time. That's fine. You have succeeded in wiping me out. Bravo. As I promised, though, I would take the criticism to heart and give it a second chance. And I did. Honestly and seriously. And I stand by my opinion. As you told me, from chapter two things improve. The sliding show at the end of the chapter actually gives some excitement. In chapter two the characters are given a little more depth. It took a whole first chapter to get to something vaguely emotional. And in the later chapters, however, the characters remain rather sketchy and not particularly detailed. For me, this remains a mediocre game. I had gone to change the review, but you managed to make me throw that one out as well. I was going to edit it and bring it up to three stars. Patience, the game remains mediocre and I don't really care about failing to rate it. I'm more sorry to have been attacked and blown off for my opinions. You have not made a good impression.
sometimes you just have to let it go man, your 1 star review was objectively fucking wrong. Sure, you don't have to like it. Okay, you think it's mid. Whatever. So either you finish it and then rate it properly, or don't bother at all. We just pointed out that you shouldn't leave a review of a game after playing it for 5 minutes and saying it's trash. Because it's not.
 

gino.pilotino

Member
Nov 16, 2017
269
446
sometimes you just have to let it go man, your 1 star review was objectively fucking wrong. Sure, you don't have to like it. Okay, you think it's mid. Whatever. So either you finish it and then rate it, or don't bother at all. We just pointed out that you shouldn't leave a review of a game after playing it for 5 minutes and saying it's trash. Because it's not.
you are right. i stopped too soon. It took a whole first chapter before things got better, though. So you're partly right and I'm partly right because it's not pleasant to go to the end of a game you don't like.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Elduriel

lnppo

Active Member
Jun 23, 2018
867
2,151
So you guys attacked me yesterday because I had a dissenting opinion. You had me delete everything. Somebody even managed to get me to delete the review that I thought was honest and not against the rules. And in fact--when they delete a review you usually get the message: you went against the forum rules. And they put the link to the rules asking you to read them again. That didn't happen this time. That's fine. You have succeeded in wiping me out. Bravo. As I promised, though, I would take the criticism to heart and give it a second chance. And I did. Honestly and seriously. And I stand by my opinion. As you told me, from chapter two things improve. The sliding show at the end of the chapter actually gives some excitement. In chapter two the characters are given a little more depth. It took a whole first chapter to get to something vaguely emotional. And in the later chapters, however, the characters remain rather sketchy and not particularly detailed. For me, this remains a mediocre game. I had gone to change the review, but you managed to make me throw that one out as well. I was going to edit it and bring it up to three stars. Patience, the game remains mediocre and I don't really care about failing to rate it. I'm more sorry to have been attacked and blown off for my opinions. You have not made a good impression.
Look, I don't want to get back into the whirlwind of the other night. I will say, though, that I can't stand reviews that analyze anything. I appreciate, look for, and read reviews that describe the emotions the reader felt when reading a story. And my review was exactly that. I don't care to say how the animations or renders are. A story, to be liked, has to give me emotions. And these I tell in my reviews. I try to let people who read my reviews know what emotions I felt. I think that's much more interesting than whether or not I liked the animations or renders
I don't know man, ten of you jumped on me yesterday and I didn't know who to defend myself against anymore. Can I think differently without having to feel attacked?
you are right. i stopped too soon. It took a whole first chapter before things got better, though. So you're partly right and I'm partly right because it's not pleasant to go to the end of a game you don't like.
Anyway enough. don't want to end up again in the crap we all did yesterday. Both me and you.
You:
kiryu.gif
 
4.70 star(s) 95 Votes