- Jan 12, 2017
- 1,303
- 4,343
- Thread starter monroe
- Start date
What is the nonsense? In my opinion, I described what was happening with Charlotte during the game quite accurately. The claims are not against me, but against the screenwriter. Secondly, I do not justify my preferences, but try to explain them. Logically. I do not pretend to be the absolute truth.
Just playing through the Game. I quite like the different persona and aspects of the girls. But this "David" guy is the words dumbass and coward ever... sorry.
At first he is too much of a coward to stand up for his "love" when she is bullied... and then he ist dumb enough to threaten someone, he knows being an unscrupulous asshole when this person has 2 other people to help him out - the result is obvious.
You don't threaten a psychopath on his own turf 1 against 3 and expect o survive that, even less "being the hero" - if he would have simply told charlotte, he could have ruined zaks grand plan, using his own arrogance against him... but nooooo he has to run his mouth and gets beaten up... sorry, but that kind of idiocy is ridiculous. I can get Charlottes resentments agains men, i can understand suzy regarding her pride and stubborness - especially being an athlete. But what i do not get is how people can be so fucking stupid trusting and naive when everyone knows that hillside is effectively a pool of sharks. the innocent and naive schoolgirl in love is somewhat believable, but david and some other peoble are nothing else than hell screeching idiots. Even out MC is one of them. He knows charlotte does not trust him, he wants her to open up.. but he can't take the first step, a leap of faith so to say, and tell her at least something about his past with her attacker. - Stubborness, pride and straight up idiocy - thats what gets people hurt. Every. Single. Time. - Though they never learn...
now, the second idiocy happend. The MC dealing with Johno. I was looking forward to this scene when this scumbag gets what he deserves... but out MC is no Ex military Bodyguard, but a soft teddybear. One hit in the guts? - Really? - Is that how you interrogate someohen who has an informational advantage over you? The MC has no way to know if Johno would delete the messages, he obviously is a scumbag. but he has all the cards in his hands. He even mentioned being paid for his miserable deeds and sais he is more scared of this other person than the mc... i in the MCs shoes would take that as a challenge... how do you deal with such people? - Yoi make them shit themselves from fear of you so they would never ever dare to cross you! - Think about crocodile dundee 2, mick hanging tha mafia guy headover from the balcony on a flimy rope and threatens to let him fall to his death if he keens his mouth shut! - This is an example of how to scare someone. Putting a large army knife to his balls and threaten to cut them off would also likely have had some effect. But simply walking away, trusing that scumbag and being literally told of not being scary enough...!? really? WTF? And this even should be MC being Angry? I guess even suzy would heve been more threatening... how will he deal with this wolf or jason guy... cuddeling them to death? my oh my... why does the bad guys alwasy get pampered in this kind of stories..?
At first he is too much of a coward to stand up for his "love" when she is bullied... and then he ist dumb enough to threaten someone, he knows being an unscrupulous asshole when this person has 2 other people to help him out - the result is obvious.
You don't threaten a psychopath on his own turf 1 against 3 and expect o survive that, even less "being the hero" - if he would have simply told charlotte, he could have ruined zaks grand plan, using his own arrogance against him... but nooooo he has to run his mouth and gets beaten up... sorry, but that kind of idiocy is ridiculous. I can get Charlottes resentments agains men, i can understand suzy regarding her pride and stubborness - especially being an athlete. But what i do not get is how people can be so fucking stupid trusting and naive when everyone knows that hillside is effectively a pool of sharks. the innocent and naive schoolgirl in love is somewhat believable, but david and some other peoble are nothing else than hell screeching idiots. Even out MC is one of them. He knows charlotte does not trust him, he wants her to open up.. but he can't take the first step, a leap of faith so to say, and tell her at least something about his past with her attacker. - Stubborness, pride and straight up idiocy - thats what gets people hurt. Every. Single. Time. - Though they never learn...
now, the second idiocy happend. The MC dealing with Johno. I was looking forward to this scene when this scumbag gets what he deserves... but out MC is no Ex military Bodyguard, but a soft teddybear. One hit in the guts? - Really? - Is that how you interrogate someohen who has an informational advantage over you? The MC has no way to know if Johno would delete the messages, he obviously is a scumbag. but he has all the cards in his hands. He even mentioned being paid for his miserable deeds and sais he is more scared of this other person than the mc... i in the MCs shoes would take that as a challenge... how do you deal with such people? - Yoi make them shit themselves from fear of you so they would never ever dare to cross you! - Think about crocodile dundee 2, mick hanging tha mafia guy headover from the balcony on a flimy rope and threatens to let him fall to his death if he keens his mouth shut! - This is an example of how to scare someone. Putting a large army knife to his balls and threaten to cut them off would also likely have had some effect. But simply walking away, trusing that scumbag and being literally told of not being scary enough...!? really? WTF? And this even should be MC being Angry? I guess even suzy would heve been more threatening... how will he deal with this wolf or jason guy... cuddeling them to death? my oh my... why does the bad guys alwasy get pampered in this kind of stories..?
Last edited:
- Jun 14, 2020
- 2,702
- 8,413
The whole part you wrote about Charlotte. You clearly missed the whole point about her character and that's on you, not the dev. As you can see many times in this thread other players understood that character.
- Jun 14, 2020
- 2,702
- 8,413
- Nov 14, 2017
- 65,260
- 32,910