Welll this may gets me some face palms, but it is not only Andres who is put in a bad light by his actions on screen but also MC in a way, by his inaction?
Just going a bit against the view in the game to tease and provoke everyone a bit to look at the situations MC gets in and blaming him or calling him the male slut.
Our poor MC is mainly surrounded by a cast of selfish women, that lie to him, never ask him what it is he wants out of a life with them or in at least one instance if he even wants one and then after seducing him with no strings attached and him being in no steady affirmed relationships and start making demands and decisions for him instead of with him. Like in the sister choice option, it would have been nice if he had the choice to say neither. You know I care for and love you both and will whatever happens, Now if that is not good enough for you both I am sorry, but then neither. It would have ended path for both, but that is fair enough, choices have consequences after all.
MC would be best off to say to all of them, I am going to BBQ and shoot pool with Dylan, get your shit together and if then feel like it still we can talk about what we both want. I am out for now.
Just to look at it a bit from the other side, those girls get way too much sympathy for all the shit they pull and bad decisions they make and have the lead way too much.