I think not all of it was known, too. Like in one of the flashbacks Ethan agrees to stop being harsh on MC, then walks round the corner, bumps into him, and pushes him over and tells him to stay away from Erynn. It's a bit naive perhaps, but I don't think she knew the worst of it, which if she did, would probably have pushed her to act, or act more forcefully, at the time.
I would buy that if it didn't come from her own mouth that Ethan always picked on MC during a flash back.
Yeah, so she knew about it, but did she know the extent of it? There's a difference between picking on someone and properly bullying them (though I accept it's a nuanced difference). Not an excuse, by any stretch, but even at 15, kids might easily miss the full depth of something like that.
My memory of that scene is hazy but didn't she also say that she told Ethan to stop and she believed he had stopped (that's when he started doing it out of her sight like the pushing over scene).
One of the more well rounded ladies
Their is a fine line between Picking on and Bullying and either way i would not be friends with someone that picked on or Bullied a close friend of mine.
One thing you got to remember as well that is how you feel now at your current age but what about when you were that age maybe nothing is different. But not everyone had the backbone and same moral values when they were young hell I didn't. I would let my self get pushed around and be too scared to stand up for my self or anyone else if it came down to it and still be friends with said person even if I knew it wasn't right because I was super shy and introverted. With all that being said you are correct and she should of cut him off completely.
The important thing regarding Erynn is, does this girl deserve a second chance?
), and she admits that she should've done better regarding Ethan.I get what your saying but do you remember the flash back? She did not lack a backbone or confidence. Remember her telling him off?
100% hell I started the game off not wanting to like her thinking she is your typical mean girl but this and many other interactions with her she is probably one of the nicest and most caring LI ive seen in a AVN she just makes bad decisions. ( probably because she is a bit to nice at times) Like hell I really love how she feeds you and take you to school like she kind of starts to feel like a second mother and giving off a motherly vibe I adore that about her. To me that just shows how much she cares for the MC's well being and future.The important thing regarding Erynn is, does this girl deserve a second chance?
My opinion is an unreserved, yes, absolutely.
She cares about the MC, anything she did wrong or attitude that you question... she did it by mistake or poor level of knowledge.
She never had any intention of hurting the MC, she only wanted(and still wants) the best for him.
She only wants to be a good friend(maybe more
That's the type of person that deserves a second chance.
Your right about that she does deserve a second chance after MC finds out what really happened. They both was young and to be honest both was at fault her more than him but still. He should have heard her out instead of ignoring her.The important thing regarding Erynn is, does this girl deserve a second chance?
My opinion is an unreserved, yes, absolutely.
She cares about the MC, anything she did wrong or attitude that you question... she did it by mistake or poor level of knowledge.
She never had any intention of hurting the MC, she only wanted(and still wants) the best for him.
She only wants to be a good friend(maybe more
That's the type of person that deserves a second chance.
I'm like this too, it's why in my first (blind) save I didn't even think about staying with Erynn instead of getting the train with Layla and Elena. A couple of other early interactions got me right in the mood to be kicking Erynn to the kerb, but then she started turning it around. It's another really well-done piece.
I've ranked the girls by looks elsewhere (link in my signature), so based on character/personality instead... It's tough, and I'm still fresh to all of them, but I think Layla, Nikki, Alexis, Val, Erynn, Elena, Cara. That'll probably change a bit next time I'm asked, and I'm deliberately not making it harder by adding anyone you didn't
You are a bit sadistic pal.
I have Erynn, Nikki/Layla tied in second place, wildcard Gabi... Iris, Val, Elena>>>>> Cara and Alexis
true I do forget how the scenes plays out exactly but still my point stands about her being young even if she does have backbone. I think why my thoughts on this is a little strong / alot different than what makes sense and acting like it isn't that big of a deal while it is for others is because of my personal experiences.
Not going by looks but for me Erynn , Alexis , Elena / Niki ( both tied) Val , Cara Layla. I don't dislike Layla but she is in the friendzone for me so she is automatically in lastI've ranked the girls by looks elsewhere (link in my signature), so based on character/personality instead... It's tough, and I'm still fresh to all of them, but I think Layla, Nikki, Alexis, Val, Erynn, Elena, Cara. That'll probably change a bit next time I'm asked, and I'm deliberately not making it harder by adding anyone you didn't
in my blind playthrough I got off the Layla path and on to the Erynn and Alexis one around the 25-50% point where I changed my mind about her. Tho I didn't get on the train with Layla as I wanted to learn and hear Erynn out more.
