Dessolos

Message Maven
Jul 25, 2017
14,453
18,980
Nikki and Cara, although it happens in one long scene, there's a month or 2 that goes in that flashback... 2 months sharing a house, seeing each other everyday, helping them...
Cara in particular kissed the MC at her birthday party, before he moved in, so something was there from the start.
Nikki, things in common, working out together, saving her from getting ran over, helping with her ex... and it clicked.
That's true I think the fault is in the fact these games take a long time to develop so can't really show alot of that 2 months. So while alot did happen in those 2 months I always felt like I wanted to see more to feel the connection between them especially Cara. Tho it could also be just me as well. I honestly never felt anything between them other than something that was casual something like good friends or friends with benefits at the most would have.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LSC82

Martin_S7

Newbie
Dec 28, 2023
21
37
Nikki and Cara, although it happens in one long scene, there's a month or 2 that goes in that flashback... 2 months sharing a house, seeing each other everyday, helping them...
Cara in particular kissed the MC at her birthday party, before he moved in, so something was there from the start.
Nikki, things in common, working out together, saving her from getting ran over, helping with her ex... and it clicked.

Layla is fine, she's the young and innocent archetype getting the hots for a boy... and despite that fact that she's flirty right away, it took her a long time to commit, nothing wrong with that.


Agreed on Erynn, she's obviously predisposed to like the guy due previous relationship, that brings positives and negatives.
Positive that she's always gonna pay attention to him and give him time, and wants him close to her by default.
Negative that she's a little(very slow actually) slow moving because she's scared it might hurt the friendship.
That, plus her history of abuse, makes her both an easy target... and slow to commit.
The way things play out make sense.

Alexis is a bit harder for me to buy too, he stole a kiss from you 5 years ago, he looked way too young for her back then, and after that you never saw him again...
She's not some innocent virgin like Layla and Cara, so it's a much harder sell that she's immediately obsessed with the guy.


Valeria is the "realistic" hot girl, she has a bunch of dudes going after her so isn't dropping head over heels for anybody.
She knows the power that she has and plays with her cards close to her (awesome ;))chest and keeps her options open.
That's a great point about Erynn. I think she’s a well-crafted character vulnerable because of what she’s been through and scared of losing her friendship with the protagonist. The relationship with her is a slow process, but it’s rewarding, even if it causes issues with others. To me, if we follow logic and "destiny," ending up in a relationship with her feels like closing a circle that’s been there since childhood.
 

xapican

Devoted Member
May 11, 2020
10,955
16,852
Alexis is a bit harder for me to buy too, he stole a kiss from you 5 years ago, he looked way too young for her back then, and after that you never saw him again...
She's not some innocent virgin like Layla and Cara, so it's a much harder sell that she's immediately obsessed with the guy.
I'm more and more convinced that Alexis was added after the start of the Novel, due to her popularity, and wasn't planned from the scratch to be in the LI rooster.
so yes is unfortunately one of the paths with more flaws and plot holes.
Only in the higher chapters she gains carisma and character, when on her solo monogamous path and on "friends with Erynn"
 

byaaahh

Member
Feb 3, 2018
362
664
A lot of people are ignoring the passage of time, most girls don't instantly fall for MC. There is initial attraction, but there is build up.

Cara makes out with him on a dare because she's attracted to him, but it doesn't escalate until they have lived together for months, Same with Nikki.

The only girls who really throw themselves at MC are Julia?(girl from class, friend of Cara), Rachel and Tori. None of these are looking for anything more than a quick jump.
 
Sep 3, 2020
4,663
34,415
I have to agree with you, and this is the reason, besides Tori, why I don’t even try to pursue a path with Elena, because no matter what I do, I always end up hurting Layla’s feelings.
I actually don't mind hurting someone's feelings if I'm upfront about it from the start

but what really made me feel horrible as I was forced to do intimate things with her as her first love knowing I did not love her
 
  • Like
Reactions: valbitterb

xapican

Devoted Member
May 11, 2020
10,955
16,852
I have to agree with you, and this is the reason, besides Tori, why I don’t even try to pursue a path with Elena, because no matter what I do, I always end up hurting Layla’s feelings.
Let me confirm it later on, but I mean having played an Elena path with Layla Friendzoned from the beginning, similar as the one to get on Valerias path.
 

byaaahh

Member
Feb 3, 2018
362
664
Let me confirm it later on, but I mean having played an Elena path with Layla Friendzoned from the beginning, similar as the one to get on Valerias path.
If you want a solo Elena path, you definitely have to break Layla's heart. The choice between them comes when Layla offers her virginity and MC declines which wrecks her.

Can't remember how the threeway path ends up though
 
  • Like
Reactions: LSC82

Dessolos

Message Maven
Jul 25, 2017
14,453
18,980
Yeah I think Nyx said on discord there won't be a Elena path without Layla so gotta break her heart
 

LSC82

Engaged Member
Jul 27, 2020
2,485
5,177
That's true I think the fault is in the fact these games take a long time to develop so can't really show alot of that 2 months. So while alot did happen in those 2 months I always felt like I wanted to see more to feel the connection between them especially Cara. Tho it could also be just me as well. I honestly never felt anything between them other than something that was casual something like good friends or friends with benefits at the most would have.
Because it was a flashback, we had 2 months abbreviated into 30-40 minutes, but still the girls don't meet him and jump into bed right away, it might feel that way for us because we bang them in the same scene they are introduced, but in universe there's passage of time.

Cara was smitten from the start but resisting because this was her new "brother".
Nikki, did have things gradually heating up even in the flashback.

That's a great point about Erynn. I think she’s a well-crafted character vulnerable because of what she’s been through and scared of losing her friendship with the protagonist. The relationship with her is a slow process, but it’s rewarding, even if it causes issues with others. To me, if we follow logic and "destiny," ending up in a relationship with her feels like closing a circle that’s been there since childhood.
Yes, at the same time that there's a reason why she gets attached easily, there's reason why she's slow to commit.

The Erynn relationship is getting a second chance to fix something that wrong from the past, through trials and tribulations get what you always wanted/meant to be.
I'm more and more convinced that Alexis was added after the start of the Novel, due to her popularity, and wasn't planned from the scratch to be in the LI rooster.
so yes is unfortunately one of the paths with more flaws and plot holes.
Only in the higher chapters she gains carisma and character, when on her solo monogamous path and on "friends with Erynn"
That's factual and well documented, Alexis wasn't supposed to be a long term character, she was going to be a quick fuck and disappear.

Nyx changed her mind about Alexis early on and made her a permanent cast member, after that she started getting connections to the rest of the girls, friends with Erynn, sister to Layla... and so on.
The kiss was added to retroatively "justify" her going immediately head over heels for the MC, to the point of lying to the guy and to her friend.

Yeah I think Nyx said on discord there won't be a Elena path without Layla so gotta break her heart
Sad, but true.
 
Last edited:
Sep 3, 2020
4,663
34,415
If you want a solo Elena path, you definitely have to break Layla's heart. The choice between them comes when Layla offers her virginity and MC declines which wrecks her.

Can't remember how the threeway path ends up though
and even done there are certain things you have to do to get on a Elena path

no joke even with a walkthrough I couldn't get on it I had to use a walkthrough and advice from are brothers here

I'm praying to God I don't have to start a new playthrough when I decide to play
 
  • Like
Reactions: xapican and byaaahh

flaviopaganini

Steam Fanboy
Donor
Feb 25, 2024
1,371
2,811
Let me confirm it later on, but I mean having played an Elena path with Layla Friendzoned from the beginning, similar as the one to get on Valerias path.
Of everything I've tried, she ends up in tears. If you have a step-by-step guide, I could give it a try, but it seems impossible.
 
4.40 star(s) 305 Votes